Family-friendly holiday rentals in West Milford

Such a beautiful spot on the lake!!! We had the most beautiful weekend, the kids loved he pool and the boats, nothing was missing! We would have stayed another week! Jennifer and Jose answered all our messages within a few minutes and were super accommodating. We will definitely be back!

Anthony is the best host I’ve ever had! So friendly, welcoming, and super responsive. He has clearly poured ample love and care into the space—it is immaculate, stylish, well-equipped, and truly an easy Williamsburg oasis!

My family of 8 adults needed a place to stay near a wedding at Glynwood. This wonderful spot was minutes away from the farm and town. The number of bedrooms and bathrooms gave everyone the privacy desired while the well equipped kitchen and living rooms had plenty of space for gathering. The house and land are beautiful, including the trail. Paula was easy to communicate with and my whole family felt comfortable and happy with the spot. Highly recommend!

My fiancé and I stayed at Lambs hill to celebrate our anniversary. We had the most wonderful time. The views are breathtaking. The wrap around deck with jacuzzi and hammock made our stay calming and serene. I loved seeing the horses and donkeys throughout the day. They made the experience even more special and unique. Charlotte was super responsive and accommodating. We took cabs to Main Street at night for dinner and drinks and it was so close and convenient. I left my heart in lambs hill and can’t wait to return one day.

This was our second stay with Joe and Amy hosting us and it was lovely yet again! They are extremely friendly and responsive. The place is serene and gorgeous. We absolutely adore the chickens and thoroughly enjoyed the fishing spot they told us about. It’s a beautiful place to unwind and relax away from city life. We plan to return again!

Had a great weekend with the family here! Recommend for anyone with little ones.

Julie's place was the perfect winter getaway. The fireplace, hot tub and sauna warmed us and the very well-equipped kitchen enabled us to prepare great meals. The house was beautiful, with two living rooms for different activities and energy levels, a game room downstairs, a dining room with a large table and chairs, and comfortable furniture and beds throughout. Julie texted me to make sure that our every need was met. We had a snow and ice storm, and she had the driveway and walkways plowed, shoveled and sanded twice, and kept plenty of salt on-hand. We hope to return sometime in warmer weather so we can enjoy the pond, too.

We had a very relaxing stay! The spacious cabin was very comfortable. Walter and Florence even left us an anniversary card because they knew it was our 40th!

This place is an absolute gem. From the moment I arrived, I felt a deep sense of peace—it’s incredibly tranquil, surrounded by beautiful natural scenery, with a running stream just steps from the front door. The home itself strikes the perfect balance between rustic charm and modern comfort. Inside, the decor is thoughtful and unique: a nostalgic mix of vintage childhood sports photos, striking modern art, and beautiful antiques. It all blends together to create a space that feels both stylish and deeply personal. The fireplace is a centerpiece—warm, inviting, and stocked with enough firewood to last all summer. This isn’t just a house—it’s a welcoming home. You can feel the care and intention behind every detail. Located just 15 minutes from Bethel Woods, it’s the ideal escape from NYC. I can’t wait to return.

We had a terrific experience with Robert's apartment. The hosts were flexible, informative, and responsive. The unit was extremely clean and well appointed with little touches that we appreciated. It is in a quiet part of downtown with walkable access to the waterfront, good coffee, and excellent restaurants. If you have a reason to be in the Yonkers region I couldn't recommend it highly enough.

Spent a week in a cozy cabin tucked away in the woods, and it was exactly the reset I needed. Peaceful, quiet, and surrounded by nature—waking up to the sound of birds and falling asleep under the stars felt like a dream. The cabin itself was warm, clean, and had all the essentials. Whether we were sitting by the fire, going on nearby hikes, or just enjoying the view on the porch, every moment felt grounding. No traffic, no stress—just stillness. Highly recommend if you’re looking to disconnect and recharge. Can’t wait to go back.

Peter's place is THE perfect stay for a couple (plus dog) planning a visit to Rockland County. The cottage is extremely clean and incredibly cozy. The surroundings are beautiful, with the property well set back from the road and bordering Harriman State Park. Suffern and its restaurants aren't far and there's easy access to the Palisades Parkway to go anywhere else nearby. I grew up in the county and visit my parents on a regular basis. Any time I can't stay at their home, Peter's place will be my go-to from now on.

Great place for those like us who love peace and quiet. It’s definitely the private escape we needed! Please take a moment to read Nicole’s directions in terms of getting around / staying there since you are in the woods. The detail was very helpful for us in enjoying our time and getting around. Plus she has an awesome book collection!

Really enjoyed our stay at this peaceful farm. The location was very convenient to Bear Mountain State Park / the Appalachian Trail. The sound of the frogs at the nearby pond and the friendly horses really make this place a gem. Would highly recommend for a relaxing getaway!

Peaceful and private! Situated on a dead end lane Patrick’s place had plenty to do outside - exploring the stream, near by waterfalls, local parks and attractions. Lake Superior State park and the Toronto Reservoir were great spots for swimming and exploring. The house itself was clean, comfortable and well stocked with all necessities. The yard provided a great space for pets and kids to play in addition to exploring the various seating areas and fire pits on the property. There were also many wildlife visitors from deer to fox. We will definitely consider staying again!

Really cute place. Comfortable beds and Sofas. The propane fire place was ideal. It was cold and icy when we stayed and we pretty much stayed in the whole time. It felt very warm and cozy. John was very responsive and helpful, he made the whole experience very easy for us.

Spent a weekend here with friends and had an awesome time. Yevgeniy was extremely accommodating, and responded to any questions very quickly. I would 100% come back.

Had a very enjoyable time during my stay. Hosts were very helpful, friendly, accommodating, and responsive. Gave lots of great recommendations for dinner spots and shopping. The house was very comfortable, clean, and cute. Will definitely be booking again!

The place worked perfectly for what I had needed. Travel a lot for work, and this time my wife and son came to visit for a few days of the stay. Host was very nice and helped us with accommodations and recomendations of local eateries. Very much enjoyed our time here, would stay again.

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (10/10) Review: The house was amazing, especially the pool, sauna, and steam room. A truly exceptional experience in every detail. Thank you, Ms. Lise, for your warm hospitality!

Responsive staff, detailed instructions were very helpful. Stayed here for a week-Beautiful property, stable WiFi-suitable for work, enjoyed the gym, easy access. Will stay here again. Thank you!

If you're after something warm and cozy, this is your spot! It easily fits a family of four and comes with everything you need. The views around the cabin are stunning, and the outdoor space is perfect! there’s a hot Jacuzzi always ready, a fire pit, two chill sitting areas, a big deck, and a massive pool. really recommend!

Great host and great place! We'll definitely consider coming back next time we want to visit Shawnee / Bushkill.

Our stay at Boris and Tina’s place was fantastic! The house was impeccably clean and well-stocked with everything we needed. Tina was very accommodating and was flexible with check in time. She provided all the instructions very clearly before we checked in. We can’t wait to come back again!