Holiday rentals with a fire pit in West Milford

The house met all expectations everything is stylishly done, and the host is incredibly responsive and helpful 🤍

We had a great time at Luz’s place. She was very responsive and proactive. The place itself is perfect for a couple and the views/lake access are the biggest perk. Very close to many great restaurants (all within a 7 min drive) and not far from other great places if you don’t mind driving a bit further. It was the perfect place for a long weekend and we hope to be back soon!

SPECTACULAR! Tom & Carol are the nicest people you’ll ever meet and genuinely enjoy sharing their Piece of Heaven with guests. Anything you need, 24/7, just ask. Tom’s art & sculpture, inside & out, will blow you away! If you’ve stayed at their former AirB&B, the Art Cabin in the Woods, you’ll remember the little touches that made it magical, surprises at every turn - imagine that x5, that’s what you find here. GORGEOUS indoor space that’s colorful, whimsical and yet upscale & refined, from the radiant heated floors to the fully stocked gourmet kitchen..the cozy living room with the biggest TV I’ve ever seen to the bedroom’s atmospheric wall-mounted fireplace.. the PERFECT mattress & the deepest soaking tub these old bones have ever had the pleasure to melt in! True luxury Outside - hot tub, grill, fire pit, wood-burning sauna…3 decks, seating everywhere, and the views…all speak for themselves. 2 nights wasn’t enough, strongly suggest minimum 3, I’m already planning!!

If you value coziness, warm and inviting environment, responsive, friendly, and attentive host then Cozy House will not disappoint. From the moment you start communicating with Vera she lets you know you’re in great hands. She wants your stay to be the best possible. I highly recommend you spend few minutes reading about Vera and her family history. Only then you’ll understand Cozy House was decorated with love, with family in mind. The location couldn’t be better, safe, peaceful, beautiful surroundings, within minutes from all the amenities and lakes. My family and I enjoyed every moment and created lasting memories together!

Millionaire Mansion — Just Like the Name Says! This place truly lives up to its name! Everything about it is amazing — you can really feel how much care and heart the hosts put into making this home so special. I especially loved the breathtaking mountain views — absolutely spectacular!

Wow! I booked this lovely home just a few days prior to needing it and it was all we expected and more. It has 2 private docks on the upper part of Greenwood Lake with Adirondack chairs right by the water. The lots are separated with fences and shrubs and so it seems very private. Heron, geese, ducks and other birds visited our dock and yard. The town of Greenwood Lake had what we needed: ice cream, beer (go to Friendly Beer for the best selection), a few restaurants/food trucks & a Dunkin. We loved the hot tub and appreciated the board games since the weather was rainy at times. Rules and checkout procedures were simple and clear cut and John was responsive and helpful when messaged on the app. Any issues we had were unforeseen and dealt with immediately. We would love to stay here again!

Thanks to Dustin & Lisa for a great stay - they were always reachable and even helped after we had checked out (one of our party had left some very important medication) Cabin was great, the peaceful surroundings and passing Deer were just what we needed. Very conveniently located for Warwick Bethel. We also visited Wallkill and Paterson Bethels too about an hour ish drives to each. One thing to mention that we’d of benefitted from an Iron - but cabin was stacked with all other appliances and conveniences. Thanks guys - appreciate everything and we’d happily visit again and highly recommend.

This is the second time we took our family here. Everything is as great as we remembered. The kids enjoyed swimming, jacuzzing, rowing the boat and playing ping pong and billiards when it is raining. Great three-day weekend well spent. The lake view is fantastic and it is 1.5 hours from Manhattan or 2 hours from Brooklyn. The rate did get more expensive comparing to two years ago but I can tell the location is still very popular from June on. I guess May is a nice shoulder season and the host allowed us to do early check in and late check out. Maybe it is more affordable to combine two families or a group of friends.

Ami’s place was great! Stayed for my birthday and was surprised with a delicious tres leche cake upon my arrival! The view was incredible, amenities were amazing, overall it was everything I hoped for and more. Thanks Ami!

We really enjoyed our stay as a family at this location. Everything was clean and comfy with lovely, peaceful surroundings. Since the weather cooperated, we were able to enjoy the gazebo and pool area which our children especially enjoyed. The host was extremely responsive and courteous and also offered some excellent recommendations for restaurants and fun things to do in the area. We will definitely plan to stay here again when we visit the area in the future!

I had a great time staying here. A lovely and quiet retreat. Douglas and his family were very friendly and responsive to any needs I had. The place was tidy and clean and the grounds around the house were beautiful! Will definitely be back!

Donna was a great host and gave very clear instructions. The lectures match the description perfectly and it is a wonderful little spot to spend a few nights in.

My partner and I enjoyed a pleasant stay in New Jersey while attending the Cowboy Carter concert at MetLife Stadium. The home is conveniently located just a short drive from MetLife Stadium, the American Dream Mall, and NJ Transit, which provides easy access to New York City.

Dan & Jill’s home was beyond beautiful and comfy. It was very easy to find, private and felt safe. The inside of the home was more spacious than expected and extremely clean. The panoramic views from all windows was truly a treat. The hosts were very thoughtful and sweet. If you forgot to pack something, they most likely had it. Check in was smooth, stores/supermarket was a 3 min drive. 0 complaints and cannot wait to stay again!

The Modena House was perfect for our trip. We wished we had the chance to enjoy the outdoor aspect a little more, however time and weather didn’t cooperate with us. The place is adorable, a great kitchen, nicely decorated sitting room, bathroom and bedroom made for a lovely stay. The hosts are top notch! We hope to stay again in the future if we are in the area. Xoxo

Suzette’s place was exactly what we needed. The apartment provided plenty of room, a great bathroom, and a fully stocked kitchen. The outdoor patio was fabulous for us and our dog. The park that was right out the back door was perfect for going for walks. Suzette’s ‘s place is one of the nicest places we’ve stayed and we will definitely be back when in the area. If you have pets and want plenty of space, this is the place for you.

We had a wonderful stay in David’s cabin! The scenery was gorgeous, the space was cozy, and everything about the place felt thoughtfully prepared. David was also a very responsive and kind host. Thank you!❤️

We really enjoyed our stay at Dylan’s cabin. Is was super cozy and pleasing. We enjoyed our evenings around the fire. This place was clean and cozy. Thanks for having us!

This was my third time booking this enchanting Norway Chalet. It became almost my home away from home. Close to Jersey, close to trailheads, private, quiet and a ton of amenities. The host is very responsive and goes out of his way to make you feel welcomed. I highly recommend it.

Very nice house, good fishing and wildlife nearby. A little closer to the neighbors than expected, but overall a great place and would love to come back

great place to stay - would recommend!

The cabin was great! Just what our group needed. Very clean and in a nice private location.

Very cozy, private, clean and feellikehome spot. Beautiful house on the lake with everything you need. Definitely would stay there again and recommend to everyone who is looking forward for a little getaway from busy life. Great host, responds quickly if any questions, clear instructions and info made my stay super comfortable and memorable. Great experience.

Loved my stay here, nice environment, peaceful , very beautiful but watch staircase I almost fell 5 times . But overall 9/10