Lake house holiday rentals in New Buffalo

Find and book unique lake houses on Airbnb

Top-rated lake house rentals in New Buffalo

Guests agree: these lake houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favourite

Home in Cassopolis

5 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

The Cottage on Heiner Hill

The Cottage on Heiner Hill is that place- The one that fosters peace & could be that reset you're searching for. The open concept creates a space where the views are endless just like the memories you'll be making. This rehabbed 1952 house has helped our family reconnect, reclaim our childhood laugh & restore balance. Sitting on 3 lots with direct water access & private dock, the cottage gives you an escape to tranquility while having the time of your life with family or friends! @lovethatlake

Guest favourite

Home in Decatur

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 55 reviews

Luxury on the Lake: Southwest Michigan Retreat!

Welcome to your private lakefront retreat nestled on the tranquil shores of Lake of the Woods. This stylish, well-appointed 4-BR, 3-BA home is ideal for unwinding and soaking in the lake life. Highlights: Breathtaking lake views Expansive outdoor space for alfresco dining & sunset viewing Open kitchen with a large dining table- ideal for family meals Spacious floor plan with ample room for your entire group Complimentary canoes, kayaks, yard games, & bonfire pit Pontoon boat available for rent

Top guest favourite

Home in Dowagiac

5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Magician Lakehouse Escape

This Magical Lakeside Escape offers a perfect blend of luxury and comfort, making it an ideal destination for relaxation. Take a stroll on the private dock, swim in the sandy bottom waters, or kayak the shoreline. The spacious living area offers panoramic views, with breath taking sunsets. Enjoy cozy evenings by an indoor or outdoor fire. Spend the day on a (rentable) pontoon. Experience the magic of lakeside living at the newly updated Magician Lakehouse and create unforgettable memories.

Guest favourite

Home in Valparaiso

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

Lakefront House, Pontoon, Deck, Fire Pit & More!

Pontoon INCLUDED in all rentals thru Sept 2025! No extra fees for unlimited use of private pontoon, pier, paddle boards and more!! Rental price of our lakefront house includes the pontoon, deck, yard and endless activities!! Take the pontoon for a cruise, fish, swim, paddle board, kayak, watch the wildlife or have a bonfire!! Travel 15 minutes to the Indiana Dunes or 10 minutes to downtown Valpo. You will also be able to cook delicious meals on the propane grill & fully stocked kitchen

Guest favourite

Home in La Porte

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 70 reviews

Cozy home on Pine Lake. Huge lakefront yard

Pine Lake Family Summer Memories! A cottage with a million dollar, unobstructed view of north Pine Lake. Enjoy a different sunset every evening. Spend the day on your own private beach and relax on the luscious backyard. Lakeside relaxation is our main attraction; located on a dead end, the home offers a place to throw a line out and wait for a bite off the dock out the backdoor. Two kayaks included. (Paddle board & swim pad available for a small fee). Smart TV & wifi recently added.

Superhost

Home in Coloma

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

LakePath Beach House - hot tub, Lake Michigan

Hot tub, walk to beach, fireplace, great kitchen, pet-friendly Chic lake house w/ fireplace, year-round hot tub, firepit(Solo stove), deck and wraparound porch, wi-fi. Tucked in wooded rolling dunes 200 step path from Lake MI. Cross Blue Star Hwy to dog-friendly beach with great sunset views! 3 minute drive to Hagar Park beach; 15 minutes to wineries, beaches. GREAT SPACE for intimate wedding parties, family vacations, family reunion, birthday celebrations or hanging with your BFFs!

Top guest favourite

Home in Grand Beach

5 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Superhost, hot tub, golf cart, fire pit, large!

Newly renovated 5 bed, 2 bath home in the quaint village of Grand Beach. Golf cart included with rental (in season - May thru mid-Nov). Home is situated on a large lot, high on a sand dune that overlooks the 6th fairway and park area. Enjoy two large decks and year-round eight person hot tub. The property is very private, on secluded street and fully stocked for a great stay. It's a great place to enjoy some down time in an idyllic village in the heart of Michigan's "Harbor Country."

Top guest favourite

Home in Watervliet

5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Newly Renovated Lakehouse Directly on Paw Paw Lake

Welcome to our newly renovated lake house located directly on Paw Paw Lake in Watervliet Michigan! This 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers the perfect blend of modern comfort and lakefront charm. Enjoy direct access to the regions largest inland lake from your private dock—ideal for swimming, boating, or just soaking in the serene views. The large deck, complete with dining furniture, is the perfect spot to savor your morning coffee or enjoy a sunset dinner. Life's better at the lake.

Top guest favourite

Home in Marcellus

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 202 reviews

The Box for Guests Over 21

All guests must be 21 or older. Affectionately known as "The Box", this is a romantic getaway for water lovers, wine and beer tasters, and peace seekers. Enjoy excellent fishing, kayaking, swimming, and amazing sunsets. 5G Wi-Fi, Netflix, Pandora, and 2 TVs. Due to insurance and AirBnB policies, all guests must be listed on the reservation - even if they're just visiting and not staying overnight. We can't host dogs; please don't ask us to make an exception - we can't.

Superhost

Home in Elkhart

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Lakeshore Cottage🎣 🚣‍♂️Waterfront/Great Wi-fi

Book your family getaway at this charming Lakefront home on Heaton lake! Enjoy swimming, fishing and a 4 person paddle boat. 3 minutes from Ideal Beach Family Water Park. Peaceful setting with a large back yard for games. Only 7 minutes from great food and shopping in Elkhart. Close to the toll road and 30 Minutes from Notre Dame Stadium. Excellent Xfinity wifi and TV. This is a very quiet neighborhood. No parties and there is a zero noise policy after 9 PM.

Guest favourite

Home in Lakeside

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 221 reviews

Couples alert! PVT beach access, hot tub, firepit!

ADORABLE HOME IN LAKESIDE WAS RECENTLY REHABBED & OFFERS A SUPER CLEAN AND MODERN FEEL IN THE HEART OF HARBOR COUNTRY. GUEST HAVE ACCESS TO PRIVATE BEACH WHICH IS A 7 MIN WALK AWAY - NO CROWDED BEACHES! YEAR ROUND HOT TUB, A SUPER COMFY KING SIZE BED AND ONE PULL-OUT COUCH FOR 4 GUEST (MAX). FIREPIT SUPPLIED WITH WOOD, AN OUTDOOR PATIO AND WEBER GRILL COMPLETE THIS LOFT LIKE HOME. FULLY STOCKED KITCHEN, HIGH DEF TV, STREAM MUSIC, ETC! YOU WILL LOVE IT!

Top guest favourite

Home in Cassopolis

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Lake House in Cassopolis

Immerse yourself in this "blast-from-the-past" retro getaway on Stone Lake. The property includes private pier and beach access. Enjoy stunning lake views, peace and quiet, and ample space for outdoor relaxation. We are within walking distance from the public beach and downtown Cassopolis, as well as 30 minutes away from South Bend and Notre Dame campus.