Private suite holiday rentals in Fire Island

We had a lovely stay at this beautiful property. The room was spacious, filled with natural light, and the entire space felt really welcoming. It's a beautiful spot in Old Lyme, and I’d absolutely recommend it to anyone visiting the area.

Great stay in Long Beach! Walking distance to almost everything, responsive and was flexible to our travel arrangements. Definitely would stay again!

Nice place to stay, easy to find and Liz responds quickly to messages. The house was clean and tidy. And the bed comfortable!

We love staying at George’s place, it feels just like home away from home for us. We’ve visited this property several times over the years, most recently with our son who’s now old enough to fully enjoy the yard on his own. He had a fantastic time playing outside, talking to the deer and rabbits that came to visit. We even saw some turkey vultures! Overall a solid place to stay and it’s become somewhat of a family tradition. Thank you George!

Sandy was great. The place was clean. I underestimated the size of the place for the length of time we stayed. We stayed a whole month and it was very small for my husband and I. It’s a good place to stay for a weekend or even a week. Otherwise the place was good. Private and clean

Lori’s place was just right for me on a quick trip up to NY for the weekend. It was very comfortable and cozy. She was very helpful and communicative as well. If I decide to go back and explore the city I’ll definitely stay here again.

The home was absolutely gorgeous and peaceful. It's exactly as described but even more spacious than I expected. They put a lot into making guests feel welcome, including prompt communication, a quick walk through to explain where things are, numerous suggestions for the surrounding area, and even a tray of welcome cookies! I came for a 50k trail race, so the hot tub was a perfect added bonus. I HIGHLY suggest booking this property, and I'll definitely be back to spend some time at the beach.

Yinka’s unit was clean, comfortable, and in a perfect location for getting to the city while being in a quiet and safe neighborhood with easy access to the rest of Long Island. The train station’s very walkable. The unit was well equipped with anything you’d need during a stay (TV, toiletries, linens, fridge, microwave, etc). Yinka is so friendly and sweet. I appreciate how proactive she was about checking in to see if we needed anything. Great value. Highly recommend staying here!

We needed a place to stay when returning home for a family gathering. Ron and Joy were excellent hosts. Their place was immaculate. Amazing backyard seating area. The apartment was immaculate. Lots of nice touches throughout. Highly recommend.

Perfect place for a gate away while on Long Island. The unit is precisely what I needed while away from home and she was very accommodating considering I had my little dogs which btw loved her. The backyard is charming and the chicken coop give it a real farm feel. Backyard had plenty of space for the dogs to run. Would definitely recommend or rebook.

Tim and Lorna were excellent hosts! The place was better than expected and in a great area centrally located on the island. There were so many thoughtful little details they provided for both me and my my furbaby - from toys and a bed for him to all sorts of things we might forget when traveling (first aide kit, lint brush and so much more). The place was impeccable and very comfortable. My plans changed when I arrived and I needed up just relaxing for quite a bit of my stay and it was perfect. A very comfortable sitting area with books, games and a tv with lots of options. The bedroom was roomy and very comfortable. I slept like a baby throughout my stay as it is a nice quiet area and I barely heard anything from them as they are upstairs. There is a coffee maker, small fridge and microwave which was all I needed since I wasn’t looking to cook while away. They were very responsive when I misunderstood the instructions on how to get in. I will most certainly be back!

Had a great stay at Yussette’s place. The accommodations were as described in photos, clean, and comfy. My only concern was that during colder nights it was absolutely freezing. I reached out as there is no thermostat in the room and was told the heat would be raised. It was only temporary as a short time later it was freezing again. Other than that, everything else was wonderful.

Sahaja’s place is located on a quiet residential street and there’s a convenient parking place right in front. Check-in was easy and she answered any questions quickly. The place is very clean and the bed is comfortable. The shower is great.

This side unit was convenient, comfortable, and charming. We were visiting for the weekend to attend a wedding in Smithtown. Our ETA was earlier than expected and Patricia was responsive and flexible for check-in. We drove and parked on-property (also walkable to the train if needed). The instructions were easy to follow and the unit had everything we needed & more— felt at-home while still providing hotel-quality service. We appreciated that they were on-site if we needed anything. We recommend for any small group/family!

Was a cute little basement area. Would book again.

Dan is the most responsive host we've ever had. Usually we got a reply within minutes or even seconds. He happily got the hot tub heated up for us when we needed it and replenished our towels within an hour of our request. That hospitality made our stay so much better. The home is beautiful! It's right on the water, and features lots of luxurious tile, a huge patio, a little dock and lots of windows and open space from which to see it all. We especially loved the hot tub. I wouldn't hesitate to stay again if I'm ever on Long Island again.

Super clean and new-looking Airbnb. I’m not sure if they had recently renovated but looked brand new. It was very clean, private, and easy to find.

Great place and in a great location. Would 100% recommend it. This place exceeded my expectations.

We booked Barbara's place for a girls weekend and really enjoyed relaxing in a very homey, clean and well appointed environment. We would definitely stay here again in the future!

Everything was great and as described. Very clean, very close to the train station and we were able to explore different places in New York easily. I appreciate the generosity and acts of kindest we felt there. We will definitely come back.

Host was amazing. Everything in the house was clean. The host had helpful instructions on how to navigate within the Airbnb. Amazing host! I would book with them again for my next New York visit.

We just completed a wonderful family stay at this Airbnb, and it truly exceeded all our expectations! From the moment we stepped inside, we were struck by how beautifully decorated and immaculately clean the unit was. It's clear a lot of thought and care has gone into making this a welcoming and comfortable space. For a family experience, this unit absolutely hit every mark. There was ample space for everyone to relax and unwind, and the layout was perfect for both shared moments and individual quiet time. All our requirements were not just met, but surpassed. The amenities provided were excellent, catering perfectly to our family's needs, and everything was in perfect working order. The location was fantastic, offering convenience and easy access to local attractions without being in the middle of any hustle and bustle. Communication with the host Marc was seamless – he was incredibly responsive, helpful, and genuinely committed to ensuring we had a pleasant stay.

súper attentive hosts, we had a couple of circumstances affect our stay yet they were more than willing to make the accommodations that we needed. Went above and beyond to make us feel safe and welcomed. Would love to have them host again!

Victoria’s place is perfect for my needs in every way. It is consistently clean, quiet and comfortable. It is conveniently located to my reason to be in town every month, and the neighborhood sidewalk is an added bonus. Very highly recommend.