Holiday rentals in Prospect

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Prospect

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favourite

Home in Delaware

Morticia’s Manor

Step into the shadows where elegance meets the macabre. This Morticia Addams–inspired escape is steeped in dark luxury, history, and the occasional unexplained moment. Built in 1870 along the Underground Railroad, across from a Gothic church (1886) & 1 block from a lively downtown square. Original details meet modern comforts. Embrace your inner Morticia — because life’s too short for beige walls & basic Airbnbs. Book now to see what the night brings and live deliciously. The night is yours.

LocationFamilyBathroom

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

Top guest favourite

A welcoming entrance features wooden steps leading up to a covered porch. Black railings and support beams frame the porch, which is adorned with large glass doors. Natural light streams in from the six-pane windows, offering a view of the surrounding greenery.

Home in Ostrander

Scioto River Cottage

Just a short walk to the Scioto River! Situated north of Columbus Ohio, central to Dublin (12 miles), Delaware (8 miles) and Marysville (10 miles). Near the Columbus Zoo, Bridge Park, Polaris, Ohio Weslyan University, Scotts Lawn Care, Honda of Marysville, Dublin Methodist Hospital, and much more! with plenty of room to park your trailered boat and enjoy Delaware or Alum Creek State Park lakes, sailing or kayaking on the Scioto River, this home on a 1/2 acre wooded lot is a relaxing stay.

FamilyLocationCleanliness

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Superhost

Home in Delaware

Charming & Updated 1867 Brick House Sleeps 12

🌟 GUEST FAVORITE 🌟 just 30 min N of Columbus, OH! Sleeps 12. Superhosts. Beautifully renovated all brick home w/ high-end finishes! Built in 1867, nearly 2700 ft.². Walk to Sandusky St., Ohio Wesleyan campus & Delaware County Fairgrounds in downtown Delaware! Enjoy a full kitchen, fenced backyard, on site laundry, beautiful alley & sidewalks for walking your dog (dogs allowed w/ prior authorization), within walking distance of the public pool, courthouse, parks, restaurants + shopping!

ValueLocationBack garden

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Top guest favourite

Home in Waldo

Waldo Ohio

Possible 2 nite stay with approval. Can accommodate 4 people/Murphy bed. Enjoy small-town charm with unbeatable convenience from this fully furnished, private home just off State Route 23. Walk to local restaurants, bars, and parks. Ideally located near Marion, Delaware, and Columbus and just minutes from the Little Brown Jug, Cardinal Center, and Ohio State sporting events. A welcoming home base for event weekends, work trips, or a laid-back getaway with a true hometown feel.

FamilyValueComfort

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

Superhost

A large grass-covered yard surrounds a charming two-story home with a covered front porch. A gravel driveway leads toward a spacious barn structure in the background. Mature trees provide shade, while neat landscaping enhances the outdoor setting.

Cottage in Lewis Center

Peachblow Farm House

4 bedroom 2 bath entire single family home. 1500 square feet pre-Civil War with exposed hand hewn beams. Complete house with full kitchen, washer and dryer, patio, and plenty of parking that could accommodate boats and campers. Wifi internet included. Furnished. Sleeps 8-two queen beds, a full bed, and a bunk bed with two twin mattresses. Kitchen has tableware and cookware. House is old but has been updated-some uneven floors and other features common to an older home.

LocationFamilyBack garden

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 141 reviews

Top guest favourite

Home in Delaware

1 Level|0.4mi OWU|Quiet Street|Patio|0.2mi Dwntwn

🔷Key Features🔷 ☀Single-level, ranch style home ☀Free street parking in front of the home on a quiet one-way street ☀Courtyard patio with outdoor dining and BBQ grill ☀Dog-friendly w/a fee — bring your furry friends; they like vacations too! ☀Electric fireplace ☀0.2mi to Downtown Delaware ☀0.4mi to Ohio Wesleyan University ☀Full-sized washer and dryer ☀Fully equipped kitchen ☀Central heating and cooling (no window AC units!) ☀Owned and managed by a local family with

FamilyLocationAccuracy

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Top guest favourite

The entrance showcases inviting blue doors with a 'WELCOME' sign. Colorful flower pots line the steps, featuring a variety of vibrant blooms. A well-maintained area leads up to the entrance, with soft greenery visible in the background.

Flat in Marion

The Mission House

A Charming Stay in a Historic Home Next to the Harding Presidential Museum: Escape to the charm and character of this beautiful historic Airbnb, located in the heart of a quaint downtown area filled with shops and restaurants. This lovingly preserved home boasts its original wood trim, offering a glimpse into its storied past while providing all the modern amenities for a comfortable and convenient stay.

LocationFamilyParking

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Guest favourite

The exterior of a single-story house is shown, featuring a gray facade with a sloped roof. Lush green landscaping, including shrubs and trees, surrounds the front porch, which has a welcoming entrance. A sign indicating 'Terradise' is visible near the pathway.

Home in Caledonia

Terradise

This is a scenic property along the Olentangy River. The Romine House offers a full kitchen, 3 bedrooms, 1 1/2 bathrooms, a large living space with a quaint theme. Terradise is a property rich with natural resources and Ohio's heritage. The village of Caledonia as well as the City of Marion, are just a short drive away and offer an array of comforts for your stay. Terradise is great for a quiet getaway.

FamilyLocationBack garden

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 192 reviews

Guest favourite

A charming guest house is set amidst well-maintained landscaping. The exterior features dark wood siding and a welcoming porch. Lush greenery and a tall evergreen create a serene environment, while an American flag gently flutters at the front of the property.

Farm stay in Plain City

Countryside Private Dwelling

Enjoy the peaceful countryside just 15 minutes off of the outer loop of Columbus. We have a seperate guest house on our small farm with a king size master suite and queen bedroom. This guest home is completely private from the main residence and is the perfect ambience for peace and quiet. . My place is good for couples, solo adventurers, business travelers, families (with kids), and big groups.

LocationFamilyPets

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 860 reviews

Top guest favourite

Flat in Marion

Flying Fish Loft

A vibrantly vintage experience boasting modern luxuries. This sun-soaked 2-bedroom historic loft is nestled in the heart of downtown Marion, located between two nationally registered historic buildings in the historic district. Explore charming boutiques, local theatre, dining, and entertainment- all within walking distance. Immerse yourself in a rare blend of history, culture, and contemporary.

ValueLocationDecor

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

Guest favourite

A charming two-story tiny home is depicted, featuring a traditional front porch with white railings. The exterior is clad in gray siding, complemented by a dark roof. Nearby colorful autumn trees add a vibrant backdrop to the property, creating a welcoming and serene setting.

Tiny home in Richwood

Cheerful one bedroom tiny home with parking

You'll have a great time at this comfortable place to stay.Welcome to the Travelers retreat! This tiny home retreat offers you the space to stay much longer than a weekend. Pack your bags and come enjoy a tiny home with amenities of a large retreat. The travelers retreat is lacking nothing in space and style. The home gives you a nice warm hug the minute you walk in the door.

ValueFamilyAmenities

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews

Superhost

The image displays a dining area featuring a wooden table accompanied by four white chairs. Rich wooden floors lead towards a staircase with intricately designed banisters. A door in the background opens into another space, while soft light creates warm shadows against the wall.

Home in Marion

Historical Duplex Near Downtown.

This unique and spacious historical duplex is available for short or longer term renting. It would be ideal for an intern or professional working in the area. It has all the comforts of a home with it's furnishings and full size appliances. It's less than a mile to the downtown and just a few blocks to the Harding Museum.

LocationValueWalkability

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews