Cottage holiday rentals in New Shoreham

Great house for our girls weekend. Jamestown is so cute and we decided to eat out for the weekend but the kitchen was stocked if we’re to stay in. SteveO is a great host and great communicator. The hot tub was perfect. Would definitely stay again and highly recommend to anyone visiting the area.

I had a wonderful weekend at Andrew’s place in East Hampton. It was gorgeous, perfect location, perfect layout, and such a central location to everything. It was incredibly clean and organized and the backyard was beautiful for relaxing. Andrew was also a terrific host- he left us beverages, was super communicative and flexible and I’m so happy I stayed here. Hopefully I’ll rent again soon!!

We had a wonderful stay at Leann’s! The home was absolutely lovely—clean, cozy, and beautifully decorated. The amenities were just what I needed for a relaxing getaway. Leann was a great host, and we truly can’t wait to come back. Highly recommend!

Wow!! The perfect peaceful getaway that is close to everything!! Tucked away off the road the house is quiet with a beautiful yard. The interior is both stylish and comfortable. The kitchen is extremely well outfitted. Andrew is a great host and an excellent communicator. We only wished we could have stayed longer!! The question isn’t will we come back, it’s simply when!

Our stay at this lakeside retreat was perfect! The house was exactly as described, with stunning views that exceeded expectations. Mornings with coffee and evenings with cocktails on the back porch became our favorite ritual. The picturesque fire pit and thoughtful touch of Hershey bars for s’mores were delightful, though we didn’t get to use them this time. Our host was incredibly responsive, quickly resolving a hot tub issue, and their winery recommendations were spot-on! Quick tip: If arriving after dark, keep exterior lights off initially to avoid lakeside gnats. We noticed a few stink bugs on day one (nature’s welcome!), but they completely disappeared afterward. Neither affected our enjoyment of this beautiful property at all. Thank you for an unforgettable stay!​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

My stay at the lake house was perhaps my greatest experience at an Airbnb so far. It was our wedding weekend and the girls got ready there in the morning and hubby and I relaxed there afterwards. The incredible thoughtful touches, the care Talita and Vinny took to go the extra mile and make sure we had a pleasant time, our stay here was beyond perfect. It is decorated beautifully, lovely location, peaceful and private and excellent communication from the hosts. Could not ask for more. Book your stay here now!!! ❤️

beautiful house, great location and very nice and peaceful neighborhood close to the beach and the vineyards the house is very well equipped ! Richard was very nice and even find a little bed for our baby boy ! thanks !

I loved this space so much. I felt at home and comfortable as a solo traveler and only wished for more time to enjoy and explore the area! ❤️

Don’s place is amazing! The location is prime, less than 10 walk to the most beautiful beach with wonderful pavilion. Morning sunrise walk to the beach and sunset walk to the beach was just incredible! The deck was very peaceful and relaxing for my husband and me and our favorite furry child to hang out and enjoy the marsh ponds. Walking distance to great restaurants. As a runner, it was a beautiful place to run and loved that it was dog friendly. Don was extremely communicative and offered an early check in and late check out, which was so appreciative. We will definitely be returning. Highly recommend!

Had a great 3 night stay at Pats cottage! Charming place with great amenities. Appreciated that it had a crib and gates for the kids. Only feedback would be that the sandbox needs a clean up and maybe some fresh sand, but that could have been limited for us bc we rented early in the season. Pat was great with communication before and during.

We really enjoyed our stay in the doll house. The proximity to the beach was perfect. They made everything easy by providing beach towels and beach chairs. The hosts are incredibly friendly and made us feel right at home. I’m bummed that we missed the breakfast and the wine and cheese hour but we will definitely be back again! Thank you for a great stay.

We love it here! So peaceful and relaxing. Beautiful views of the lake and loved the walks and kayaking! This was our third stay. Jasmine and Jason are great hosts. There was an issue with the Keurig, and they came and replaced it with a brand new one the next day! Thank you Jasmine and Jason for a great stay!

My family enjoyed our stay so much! The location of the house is phenomenal for walking short ways to mansion beach to relax. It is far enough outside of town that it is very quiet. The kitchen and linens were extremely well stocked! I couldn't recommend this place enough if you would like to enjoy the quieter side of BI. We will be back!

Beautiful, peaceful and serene. A place to completely recharge! For both the 2 legged and 4 legged!

The location and setting of this property is just beautiful and so peaceful. We loved being surrounded by the singing birds and croaking frogs by the pond. It is a fantastic yard for dogs and small children. Hope was lovely and very responsive. We recommend staying here for a family getaway. The space was very comfortable for our five adults, two children and two dogs.

My sister, dog and I stayed at the cottage for the weekend and had a great experience! Erika is a wonderful host and the property is beautiful. The cottage itself was exactly as pictured. Breakfast in the inn, cooked with natural and organic ingredients, is an absolute must. The location of the inn is great as well, with direct access to the Lantern Hill trail (which our dog loved) and only a short drive from downtown. Would definitely recommend staying here!

The cottage was a perfect home base for us while we attend my son’s Father’s Day soccer tournament Marie was very accommodating. We would definitely stay there again. Thank you so much!

We highly recommend anyone coming in out of town to stay at this cottage. It’s super cozy, private, and welcoming! It’s right by the water and it’s very quiet which we loved. In addition, there are also some great under-the-radar coffee shops close by. If we come back to MA, we will definitely be looking to stay here again!

beautiful, clean, peaceful place.

Doug and Robin were awesome! We had a nice relaxing stay and will definitely be back! Thank you!

We loved our stay and would definitely return. Getting in was easy and communication with the hosts was smooth. The cottage is on a main road next door to a spa and shares a parking lot, but it was quiet and felt private. The location is very convenient to Westerly and Watch Hill. It was easy to get around and everything you might need is near by (restaurants, groceries, CVS, Starbucks and Dunkin). The place is very nicely decorated, spotlessly clean and we felt very comfortable. My husband wished there was a couch, but the tv turns towards the bed or the two comfy papasan chairs. There is a large gap between the wall and the mattress, so we used the two poufs and some pillows as a backrest, and that worked great. We planned to go to the beach, but it rained. I booked a facial at the spa (discount provided for cottage guests), and it was amazing. Highly recommended!!!

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Place was immaculate and beautifully appointed. Dishes, utensils etc were top of the line. For its size the place is very efficient and overlooking the water. The area was very quiet and peaceful. Walkable to small town of Galilee. Host was also very responsive with any questions we had. Would highly recommend and am already planning to go back

We enjoyed our time at Vintage Bolton Lake Cottage. The place is cute, peaceful and quiet. Not having a TV was perfection! Kayaking was fun. Nice bass too! Top notch experience. Jason checked in to make sure we didn’t need anything or have any concerns mid stay, which I appreciate. Phenomenal host. Would love to go back!

We had a wonderful stay here and would come back a million times. The beds were comfortable, the ocean was in walking distance, and the place was sparkling clean.