Skip to content
Sign up
Log in
Vacation rentals in Lake Shafer

Vacation rentals in Lake Shafer

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Lake Shafer

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

  • Indiana Beach Lakehouse ⛵2-9 Person, 80' shoreline
    SUPERHOSTEntire house · 9 guests · 4 beds · 1 bathroom
    Indiana Beach Lakehouse ⛵2-9 Person, 80' shoreline

    This recently purchased paradise on Lake Shafer provides much needed serenity and comfort to both my family and yours alike. Recent renovations have been undergoing rendering the upstairs of this lake house available and awaiting your arrival. As for the other two units on this property, both a separate lake house and the downstairs of this Lakehouse, they are continuing their development which will not interfere with your tranquil stay. New siding is scheduled later in the year for both homes.

    What guests are saying:

    “This place has a nice view of the the amusement park. Nice space for cornhole and some other outdoor games. Mike is a great host. Let's you do whatever you want. My group had a great time. Would go back in the future”

  • NEW modern lake house w/ HOT TUB.
    SUPERHOSTEntire house · 10 guests · 7 beds · 2 bathrooms
    NEW modern lake house w/ HOT TUB.

    Visit Piper House to enjoy the lake life, beautiful views, hot tub, beach, dock swimming, private playground, fire pits and more in our NEW modern lake house. Easy getaway from Chicago (2hr)/ Indy (1.5hr). Impressive views from huge Lake Shafer lot with dock, beach, firepit & screened porch with outdoor living/dining room. No expense spared. It’s fully stocked, totally tricked out, and all about comfort. (For high-season May-Sept bookings, see https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/20663989/ instead)

    What guests are saying:

    “House, better than advertised! Very well organized, clean and streamlined, wonderful details. For background we rented the home as our son was graduating from Purdue and we were unsure of how many would be in our party. We wanted a comfortable space in case grandparents did not want to join in all of the festivities. And a place where we would not be navigating tons of people in hotels. Was an easy 40 min drive to Purdue campus. The info provided by the owners on local amenities was very helpful covering basics (grocery and drug stores) and including favorite restaurants and recommendations. The Kroger has two of my favorite wines- Santa Margherita Pinot Grigio and Meiomi Pinot Noir. Amenities and instructions in the house were clear and obvious so we did not have to look for the remote or figure out how to connect to WiFi. Firewood, hot tub grills all had signage too. The kitchen was smartly labeled so we knew what went where (indoor wine glasses, outdoor wine glasses.) the house has more than the basics-tea, coffee, oil, vinegar, spices. This is great in a short term rental as if you are cooking you don’t have to buy everything for a couple of uses. The beds were comfortable, plenty of quality towels. One unexpected helpful item was that shampoo, conditioner, soap were provided - spa quality. The design of the house is smart and details like having a tv and providing tons of movies (including children films) and games in the bedroom with the bunks and double(maybe queen) is terrific when kids need a break from adults. Also we found our daughter escape to the bedroom overlooking the lake to read. So although there is one large communal space, the house is organized to allow you to get away. Unfortunately we were on the go all weekend so we weren’t not able to enjoy the house and lake. Would have been neat to take in a drive in movie or visit the amusement park- maybe on a future visit. Communication was terrific. Heidi and Scott reaches out to confirm we received instructions to access home and checked in via text to ensure we did not have questions. Great stay! Thank you.”

  • Penthouse on the Lake
    SUPERHOSTHotel room · 12 guests · 8 beds · 3 bathrooms
    Penthouse on the Lake

    Alexander's Landing offers fully renovated rooms that can be rented individually or as a whole sleeping up to 56 people in total. We offer an indoor pool, spa, boat docks, kyaks, paddle boats, grill area, and a huge deck overlooking the lake.

    What guests are saying:

    “Nice location, cool amenities such as grills and kayaks available. This place is family oriented and common areas are shared with other families, penthouse is located above another unit, good to keep in mind when booking.”

Holiday rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you.

  • Homes
  • Hotels
  • Unique stays

Popular amenities for Lake Shafer holiday rentals

  • Kitchen
  • Wifi
  • Pool
  • Free parking on premises
  • Air conditioning

Other great holiday rentals in Lake Shafer

Lake house, tons of deck space, Indiana Beach view
Entire house
Lake house, tons of deck space, Indiana Beach view
Price:₹20,866 / night
Great getaway cabin, waterfront.
Entire house
Great getaway cabin, waterfront.
Price:₹7,474 / night
Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities!
Entire house
Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities!
Price:₹26,160 / night
'Cozy Cottage' w/Dock & Patio by Indiana Beach
Entire cottage
'Cozy Cottage' w/Dock & Patio by Indiana Beach
Price:₹11,959 / night
The House at Pirate's Cove with room for the whole family
Entire guest house
The House at Pirate's Cove with room for the whole family
Price:₹20,941 / night
Studio unit with kitchenette
Entire flat
Studio unit with kitchenette
Price:₹8,521 / night
Celebrity Suite
SUPERHOSTHotel room
Celebrity Suite
Price:₹41,956 / night
Great Quiet Lakefront Ctg. 2 Bdrm Ctge (3)
Entire cottage
Great Quiet Lakefront Ctg. 2 Bdrm Ctge (3)
Price:₹10,277 / night
Indiana Beach 1 BR LAKE PROPERTY 6 person, 1 bath
SUPERHOSTEntire cottage
Indiana Beach 1 BR LAKE PROPERTY 6 person, 1 bath
Price:₹12,111 / night
Unit 7 Waterfront studio in Monticello, IN
SUPERHOSTResort room
Unit 7 Waterfront studio in Monticello, IN
Price:₹18,761 / night
Cozy cottage
Entire cottage
Cozy cottage
Price:₹5,606 / night
Unit 5 Cute getaway for 2 on Lake Schaffer
SUPERHOSTResort room
Unit 5 Cute getaway for 2 on Lake Schaffer
Price:₹11,585 / night
Show all