Skip to content
Sign up
Log in
Vacation rentals in Lake Shafer

Vacation rentals in Lake Shafer

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Lake Shafer

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Indiana Beach Lakehouse ⛵2-9 Person, 80' shoreline
SUPERHOSTEntire house · 9 guests · 4 beds · 1 bathroom
Indiana Beach Lakehouse ⛵2-9 Person, 80' shoreline

This recently purchased paradise on Lake Shafer provides much needed serenity and comfort to both my family and yours alike. Recent renovations have been undergoing rendering the upstairs of this lake house available and awaiting your arrival. As for the other two units on this property, both a separate lake house and the downstairs of this Lakehouse, they are continuing their development which will not interfere with your tranquil stay. New siding is scheduled later in the year for both homes.

What guests are saying:

“Michael’s place was perfect for us. We had 4 adults and 5 kids ranging from 4-14. There was plenty of room to sleep and the kids ended up crashing in the living room. The scenery is spectacular and we enjoyed fires every night. We had a wonderful time.”

Lake house, tons of deck space, Indiana Beach view
Entire house · 11 guests · 7 beds · 2.5 bathrooms
Lake house, tons of deck space, Indiana Beach view

2 level, 4 bedroom lake house across from Indiana Beach, with multiple levels of outdoor decks, including a deck off 2nd story master bedroom. Great fishing off our docks. TVs in all bedrooms. Boat lift, 3 kayacks, lily pad, charcoal grill, fire pit. A place for relaxion, not partying. ***NOTE**** We spend HOURS cleaning between guests but we live here and are HUMAN so please come expecting 4/5 stars for cleanliness. I make up for it in responsiveness and little touches, I promise!

What guests are saying:

“Sarah's lake house is a great value. We loved the great views and having multiple decks to use was awesome. The neighborhood seems quiet and safe, and we felt relaxed from the first day through the last day. Living on the lake, even for a short time, can't be beat. There is lake traffic but it was never crowded or noisy, and was very pleasant. The house is located less than 10 minutes from stores and whatever you need. The hosts provide everything you need including a nice welcome plate of cookies (really nice touch when you get in from travelling hours). The communication from Sarah was as good or better than anywhere we've stayed over the years, and she really wants to make your stay as good as possible. I'd recommend this to anyone who wants to experience lake life.”

Sleeps 15...Hot tub, fireplace, lakefront!
SUPERHOSTEntire house · 15 guests · 10 beds · 3 bathrooms
Sleeps 15...Hot tub, fireplace, lakefront!

Listing includes main house + attached in law suite apartment. Sleeps 15 in beds. 5 bedrooms + sleeping nook, 3 bathrooms. 2 kitchens. 2 screened porches. Perfect space for entertaining a larger group. Hot tub with incredible Lake Shafer views. Huge wooded lake front lot with private dock, 2 bonfire pits, sand beach area. Great location- 2 hrs from Chicago, 1.5 hours from Indy.

What guests are saying:

“Scott and Heidi's home is ideal for a large family gathering! We spent the July 4th holiday enjoying the beautiful view of Lake Shafer and Indiana Beach Amusement Park (complete with fireworks every night). The house is designed with an open living design and we fully used the main house and attached apartment for all fifteen of us. They thought of every detail to ensure our stay was comfortable--a well stocked kitchen, super comfy beds, toys/equipment for children, a well-placed playground, 2 firepits, 2 large grills, a well-used hot-tub and most of all--2 screened in porches with comfortable sitting areas. We spent most of our time here. One of the best places we've ever stayed in!! We made wonderful memories here! Thanks Scott & Heidi!”

Holiday rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you.

  • Homes
  • Hotels
  • Unique stays

Popular amenities for Lake Shafer holiday rentals

  • Kitchen
  • Wifi
  • Pool
  • Free parking on premises
  • Air conditioning

Other great holiday rentals in Lake Shafer

Great getaway cabin, waterfront.
Entire house
Great getaway cabin, waterfront.
Price:₹5,742 / night
Penthouse on the Lake
SUPERHOSTHotel room
Penthouse on the Lake
Price:₹45,050 / night
Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities!
Entire house
Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities!
Price:₹26,198 / night
The House at Pirate's Cove with room for the whole family
Entire guest house
The House at Pirate's Cove with room for the whole family
Price:₹20,734 / night
'Cozy Cottage' w/Dock & Patio by Indiana Beach
Entire cottage
'Cozy Cottage' w/Dock & Patio by Indiana Beach
Price:₹15,591 / night
2 bedrooms Cottage
Entire cottage
2 bedrooms Cottage
Price:₹13,826 / night
Unit 5 Cute getaway for 2 on Lake Schaffer
SUPERHOSTResort room
Unit 5 Cute getaway for 2 on Lake Schaffer
Price:₹10,607 / night
Unit 7 Waterfront studio in Monticello, IN
SUPERHOSTResort room
Unit 7 Waterfront studio in Monticello, IN
Price:₹16,093 / night
Great Quiet Lakefront Ctg. 2 Bdrm Ctge (3)
Entire cottage
Great Quiet Lakefront Ctg. 2 Bdrm Ctge (3)
Price:₹5,988 / night
Two bedrooms Cottage
Entire cottage
Two bedrooms Cottage
Price:₹13,826 / night
Cozy cottage
Entire cottage
Cozy cottage
Price:₹5,614 / night
Celebrity Suite
SUPERHOSTHotel room
Celebrity Suite
Price:₹36,442 / night
Show all