Cottage holiday rentals in City Island

Had a wonderful stay! The house was spotless, cozy, and had everything we needed. The host was friendly and responsive, making check-in super easy. Highly recommend!

Louise's place was perfect. Louise was so easy to communicate with, super responsive, kind, thoughtful and truly appreciated that she had the option of flexible dates (instead of so many sat to sat or sun to sun requirements in summer). The cottage was cozy, cute, spotless & well stocked. My teenage kids loved the hot tub (as it was a bit chilly in the evenings) and I loved the outdoor shower. We loved having the bikes to take rides around the Island and loved the location. Our only regret is that we didn't get to stay there longer! We will definitely try to stay at Old Snuggler again!

Peaceful surroundings, beautiful lake, wonderful house and amazing hosts! Had an absolute ball kayaking, fishing, and enjoying nature. This was my second trip and can’t wait to go back again.

Lil Nauti was perfect for our family. The bedrooms were adequate, with very comfortable beds and plenty of pillows. The wardrobe space and drawers were great as we had a long stay with a lot of baggage! Jason has absolutely everything you could possibly want or need for a stay. The kitchen is really well equipped. Cute cottage and delightful private garden.

What a gem of a find! Perfect for two. Exceptionally clean and perfect in every way for us. We were visiting family so usually only ate breakfast there but unit contained everything we needed to do so. Location was perfect as you could walk to many restaurants and a few stores. The host, Barbara, was so helpful before, during and after our stay. I felt she had put so much attention into the details of setting up her rental, so that you could just unpack and enjoy the reason for your visit. Hope to visit again. Highly recommend.

A great place for a weekend with friends. The views are immaculate, ideal if you love to watch a sunrise. The outdoor area is beautiful and accommodating all types of activities. Nice restaurants and stores nearby. Would definitely save this place for future trips.

The cottage is as pictured. Very clean with everything I needed. The area is beautiful for walking on the beach or the streets around the cottage. WiFi was strong throughout the cabin for working. Thanks Bert for your attention and listing this cottage.

Wish we had more time to enjoy here at the lake. The house was just what we were looking for and David was very helpful and quick to respond to our messages.

Jim’s place was an absolute gem for my inaugural trip to Black Rock! The Loft is incredibly spacious and equipped with everything you could possibly need for a perfect stay. From the moment I arrived, I was impressed by the meticulous cleanliness, attention to detail, and beautiful furnishings. Jim's communication was top-notch, making the entire experience seamless. One of the highlights was the extensive music collection, perfect for setting the mood during my downtime. The bed and furniture provided a level of comfort that made it hard to leave. Nestled on a serene, tree-lined street, the location couldn’t be better; it’s just a leisurely stroll away from delightful restaurants, charming shops, food markets, and more. I can’t wait to return for another stay whenever I’m in the area!

We enjoyed our stay! Such easy access to the beach was so convenient. You’re definitely better off venturing out after high tide to enjoy the most amount of beach and there are a lot of shells that make being barefoot challenging. We did arrive after major storms which could have contributed to that. The house was spotless with everything you need to be comfortable! We did not utilize the outdoor space but definitely would have if the weather was drier! Definitely would stay here again.

Our family and dogs had an amazing stay at this lakeside home! The location is absolutely perfect—right on the water with stunning views. We took full advantage of the kayaks, swam in the lake, and spent our evenings grilling, relaxing on the expansive patio, and unwinding by the fire pit. The house had everything we needed for a peaceful and fun getaway. The host was also excellent—very responsive and easy to communicate with throughout our stay. Highly recommend this spot if you’re looking for a relaxing escape

Great stay! Fergus was a great host - we drove from Boston with our dog and were attending a wedding the same day, so when I reached out to ask for earlier check in, Fergus didn’t hesitate and had the spot ready for us! They even were kind enough to drop off some bananas for us before the wedding. Check in was easy, an adorable, cozy cottage, and delicious muffins for us the next morning! Thank you!

Very great place to stay for a retreat or family vacation. Enjoyed and felt like home. The beds were so comfortable and the extra toiletries was even more than expected like Detergant, coffee, etc. Loved the welcome sign with our names and snacks when we walked in.

This was a return stay for us. We were here at Donna and Bill's cottage last year and will be for all our future trips up north. They are kind, friendly and we always feel very welcomed. The Cottage is lovely, clean, a quiet location and close to major highways. couldn't ask for more ...Highly recommend The Cottage ....Thanks to Donna n Bill for having us!!!

Malcom’s place is great! This is our 5th time staying here, coming back in September again. Very convenient location, EWR is 20 mins away. Uber delivers all types of food. Place is secluded and very private. Huge clean and kept back yard.

Great host, very fast to respond and super helpful. The space is perfect, worked well for our family of 4 (2 young children). We will definitely stay there again when returning to the area. Thank you!

Charming cottage with lots of room and fun decor in a garden setting. The kitchen is well equipped. The living room comforable. would love to try that wood burning stove in winter!A surprise was the screened porch, a perfect place for a summer nap. and the outdoor eating. Just 10 minutes from the cute town of Bethel where my niece's wedding was.

Perfect romantic location for our anniversary. Definitely would recommend to family and friends. Very private and clean. A lot of extra touches that made the stay that much more enjoyable. We’ll be back.. Thanks again, Joe & Beth

We had a wonderful stay at AnnMarie’s place. The space was clean, comfortable, and perfect for a quick visit with my mom and boyfriend. The host was incredibly helpful and responsive throughout our stay, which made everything smooth and easy. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a quiet, well-kept place to stay in the area!

Chrystal was super responsive to all our questions and needs, and gave us a warm welcome when we checked in on our first day. The lovely cottage was fully furnished and had everything our small family needed. The neighborhood was quiet, safe, and perfect for walks. Getting to downtown NYC across the G.W. Bridge only took about 20-30 minutes, very convenient. We made wonderful memories during our 9-day stay!