House holiday rentals in Cayuga Heights

This place was the perfect getaway. If you are looking for a place to stay and enjoy the wineries this is the place. Highly recommended. Would definitely come back if we come down this way again!

We were greeted with a welcome card and a bottle of Finger Lakes riesling. The cottage is in a great location for exploring the area. We stayed for Cornell's graduation weekend and going to and from Ithaca took about 25 minutes. The kitchen and bathroom were well-stocked, and the bedrooms were spacious. The guys using the sofa bed said it was not the most comfortable but OK overall. The decor was really charming, and I wish we'd had some down time to read the books John and his co-hosts picked out. I highly recommend this property for a family or small group trip because of the convenient and beautiful location and homey amenities.

This was a terrific stay. The hosts communication from beginning to end was as good as can be expected. The home was cozy and well appointed. The property was beautiful and peaceful. 5 stars, will recommend and return again. Thank you!

A completely renovated country house on a beautiful plot of land with a great view of Skaneateles Lake. This place has everything you need for a perfect Finger Lakes getaway- a lovely home, deck, pool, sauna... and that view! Really wish we had more time to enjoy it. Thanks for a great stay!

The Honeycrisp house was perfect for our family. The house was beautiful and very clean, and the views were outstanding.

Andy was very responsive from booking to checkout! The home was very clean and had everything we needed. The backyard pool looked very well maintained too-we were disappointed we didn’t get a chance to use it. Would recommend Andy’s place.

We enjoyed our four-night stay in this beautiful location. The home was well equipped and our family enjoyed the pool and hot-tub. The house is a few-minutes drive up a fairly steep gravel road, but it was manageable in our minivan nonetheless.

Joan and Leo are great hosts. The home and property are beautiful. Home is very spacious and unique. We had such a good time sitting out by the pool, walking the local trails, and just being able to spend quality time together as a family. All the books were fun to look at and read some. All the art work in the home inspired us to leave some of our own art for Joan and Leo.

We had the most wonderful long weekend at this serene Airbnb in Ithaca, staying with my husband and another couple. The space was absolutely stunning — I honestly felt like I had stepped into the pages of Architectural Digest. Every design detail was so thoughtful and elegant, from the furniture to the finishes, down to the little things like the toilet paper flower in the bathroom that made me smile. The home was spotless, calm, and incredibly peaceful — the perfect retreat. We didn’t even need to turn on the TV because we could sit on the couch for hours just soaking in the beautiful view of the trees outside. It was that tranquil. The location was also ideal — just minutes from Cornell’s campus and downtown Ithaca, but tucked away enough to feel like a true escape. And the host, Daniel, was fantastic: super responsive and helpful, with an easy/seamless check-in/check-out process. We absolutely loved our stay and are already talking about when we can come back. Highly recommend!

Myself and two friends had an amazing stay here. The house itself is clean, cozy, and updated. The outdoor area feels private, with a quiet view of the lake and convenient put-in for kayaks. A few of the neighboring homes appear somewhat neglected, so there is some overgrowth, but this is a fine trade-off for the solitude! It also gives the place a woodsy, calming feel. The location is perfect for visiting Cornell and exploring Ithaca's many waterfalls. It was a privilege to stay here and take in the scenery, and if you're considering a trip to Ithaca, I highly recommend booking Dominic's place.

Susan and Mick are amazing, accommodating and gracious hosts! There were so many things waiting for us upon arrival, from a bottle of local Riesling, cheese plate, baguette, cupcakes, and so much more. Their home is an oasis of calm, comfort and the yard is heavenly. They gave me a tour of the "neighborhood" and so much more. Their well-equipped home is stocked with anything you might need. The outdoors awaits with an abundance of wildlife and flowers! Our hosts had apples out in a bowl so we could feed the deer who wandered into the yard. The neighborhood is quiet and close to everything. We truly hated to leave.

Will’s place was beautiful and very clean! The beds were also super comfortable. The back room with the windows was extremely cozy and we loved it, especially on the days when it rained. Will was very easy to reach and even dropped off cookies at one point, which was so thoughtful! The place is a quick ten minute drive to Cornell’s campus and is baby friendly (he has a high chair). Also, we accidentally left my coat and Will was kind enough to ship it. We had a great experience and would stay again!

Jennifer's place had everything we needed for our stay and more. We would definitely stay here again next time we are visiting Ithaca.

We had a wonderful stay at this charming home in Ithaca! The location was perfect—just a short distance from the Cornell University campus, which made getting around super convenient. The house itself was even better than expected: beautifully furnished, cozy, and full of thoughtful touches. One of the highlights for us was the fenced-in yard—our dog absolutely loved having the space to roam and play safely. It’s not always easy to find a truly dog-friendly place, but this one was perfect. Mary was an exceptional host—friendly, responsive, and incredibly thoughtful. She went above and beyond to make sure we felt welcome and had everything we needed. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience.

We stayed here for two nights while we attended a curling event hosted by the Finger Lakes Curling Club at the ice rink just down the road. The house was perfect for the four of us: two bedrooms, a well-equipped kitchen, and comfortable living spaces. The house also included snacks (chips, chocolates, etc.) that were a welcome addition to its other amenities. Very happy with our stay!

My wife and I loved the place. Quiet, clean, and comfy - exactly what we were after. Jenn and Dean are great hosts, as well.

Clean home. Be prepared for the location to be just as advertised - out in the country.

Yuan’s 1 bedroom apartment was clean and bright. It gets a lot of light in the mornings. It had everything we needed, and check-in was easy. The location was great—just a short walk to downtown and the library.

We booked this home after changing our trip dates and losing the original house we rented. Boy, was it worth it!! The home is Beautiful! The views, natural light, huge master bathroom, and the most comfortable couch were just some of our favorite things. One of the bedrooms had kids' books and toys, and it was perfect for our 4-year-old daughter. The owners' communication with us was at its best! We look forward to returning next year!

Had a great stay at this house! Everything was clean, beds were comfy, had everything I needed. Responsive host. Needed a place close to Ithaca and this worked perfectly, very convenient!

First time in Ithica, and this was a great place to stay near downtown. We specifically wanted to be on the water, and this place delivered. Very cozy and comfortable house for our family. Looking to come back in the summer and bring our boat and take full advantage of the dock/lake.

Perfect venue for a family occasion.

Wonderful stay at this lovely, serene house! Stayed 10 days to visit family and attend school reunion. Claire keeps the house uncluttered but with artful touches, healthy houseplants, fresh flowers, paintings, comfortable modern furniture mixed with a few well curated antiques. All of the drawers and closets were empty, so you could feel at home! Kitchen well-equipped. We loved being able to walk easily to the Commons and surrounding neighborhoods. The Cayuga Waterfront Trail and Farmer’s Market is a doable walk/easy drive. Would definitely stay again!

So thankful to find an affordable place to stay in Ithaca to meet up with college friends. We were impressed by the cleanliness of the AirBnB and the location was easily walkable from Cornell’s campus and Collegetown. Mike was amazing. He called on the day we were supposed to arrive as the temps had dramatically changed. He got window AC units installed in every bedroom and the living room before we got there. We appreciated that AC and his proactiveness as we finally had summer temps. Thank you for a great stay!