Beach house holiday rentals in Bay Shore

Cassandra’s property is one of my favorite Air BnB’s to date. For a NYC trip, my wife and I decided to switch it up and stay on the north-shore of Long Island sound, instead of the typical hotel in the concrete jungle. Cassandra’s House comes stacked with upper echelon furnishings, beds, & cookware. No boiler plate decorations that are typical of most Air BnB’s like the cursive coffee sign. Cassandra has authentic artwork and antique decor making it feel very sophisticated i side. The property is situated atop a bluff overlooking the water on the North shore of Long Island. Therefore, it’s just. short walk to the beach nearby. It also is canopied by the vast nature and wildlife surrounding the neighborhood, making the outback living space out back a real deal bonus most other properties don’t provide. They also have a GIANT solo stove out back to cozy up by the fire at night. The tranquility just 45 minutes from one of the world’s largest Metropolis’s is very special.

Ashley’s house is the perfect get away. I booked this house for my family to stay for my wedding weekend. My mom had never stayed in an Airbnb before and I’ve never seen her so happy and relaxed. She truly enjoyed her first Airbnb experience at Ashley’s place. It was exactly as described and the view is beautiful. Ashley was very responsive and made sure to answer any questions I had.

Prince was a wonderful host, very responsive and quick to assist with any needs. Spotless house that felt like a home away from home. Gino’s pizza very close by. Quiet neighborhood. Full kitchen, plenty of street parking. 10/10

Bruce and his wife are wonderful people. The space was very clean, cozy and located right near the beach. I highly recommend staying here

Mario was an incredible host! Immediately responsive and encouraging of my relaxing getaway steps from the beach. Plenty of towels and beach chairs for my family. Great grill space for the kids to hang out while I cooked dinner before walking to town for ice cream.

Roberto was such a great host! The house was so cute and perfect for six people. It’s right off the water taxi stop, which was so convenient for getting to and from cherry grove (abt a 30 min ride to cherry grove, abt $20 per person). It’s also very close to a great beach. We would definitely stay again! Thank you Roberto!

We traveled to Nyack for a family wedding and this place was absolutely perfect for what we needed! Plenty of space, beautiful outdoor area overlooking the river, and located close to everything we needed. The rest of my family decided we had the best AirBnB for the wedding weekend! Mia was very responsive when we needed anything. Furthermore, my son left his kindle in the bedroom he slept in and Mia shipped it to us immediately after it was found. We will absolutely be booking here again.

Great home base for our friend group to share some time together with awesome water views! We enjoyed some of the rustic touches and open-concept kitchen and dining space.

This place was a great time, very private and quiet

We had a great weekend in Mattituck! The house is in a great location close to the vineyards and we enjoyed relaxing in the beautiful backyard. It was a quiet and a peaceful escape from the city. Fabio was also a kind and informative host.

Paula was great! The house was beautiful! Stayed here for my cousins wedding and we really enjoyed our stay!

This was truly a unique home in a quaint spot in New Rochelle. A friendly neighbor actually knew the original owner who she said was a Buddhist, which makes so much sense. The decor and homeyness was welcoming and intriguing. The house itself is very clean and well laid out for the space. The house is on a corner right next to a park which not a lot of traffic that comes through. The only downside is the lack of parking, the driveway fits one car. We would definitely stay again if in the area!

**A Perfect Stay – Couldn’t Have Asked for More!** From the moment I arrived, everything exceeded my expectations. The space was spotless, beautifully decorated, and had every amenity I could’ve hoped for. The host was incredibly welcoming, responsive, and thoughtful—truly making me feel right at home. The location was ideal: peaceful yet conveniently close to everything I needed. It’s clear that a lot of care and intention went into making this place feel special. I honestly didn’t want to leave. If I could rate it higher than 5 stars, I would in a heartbeat. I’ll definitely be back!

Christine's place was nice and clean! We especially loved the fire pit and the pool. Upon arrival of the AirBNB Christine was waiting to meet us and show us around. This was something that was new to me in my AirBNB experience, but it was honestly so nice and so was she! Christine let me know that I could communicate with her for anything that was needed and asked for recommendations to make her place better. This place was so well-equipped, close to everything and it comfortably fit me and my 6 other friends! I would definitely book again with Christine.

Great and responsive host. Home was lovely and we felt welcome. Host responded quickly to questions and requests. The home was very peaceful and relaxing. We really enjoyed the outdoor patio and pool area. I would recommend for a peaceful time away from the city.

The house was spacious with great outdoor seating, pool and hot tub. Great for large group

A very nice and spacious house, quietly located in the countryside. In 5 minutes by foot you are on the water. The neighborhood is very quiet and in the morning you can hear a lot of birds. Communication in advance was great. It was even responded to the wish of a toaster. The rooms are nice and the beds very cozy. There were three of us and we had good space. The kitchen is very well equipped with everything you need. There was even water ready upon arrival. In the living room there is a large TV with Netflix.

We had an event nearby and Brian’s place was a great base for us. Lovely and peaceful neighborhood. Brian was super responsive and reached out to us when the house was ready(before the official check-in time). Would def recommend to anyone!

This stay was truly beyond incredible—it far exceeded all of my expectations! The house was not only stunning and beautifully decorated, but it also had such a warm and inviting feel the moment I walked in. It was spotless, impeccably clean, and clearly cared for with love and attention to detail. The highlight for me was the serene back deck overlooking the canal—such a peaceful, calming space that made it easy to relax and unwind. I found myself spending hours out there, just soaking in the tranquility. Yoon was an absolute dream to communicate with—always prompt, kind, and so accommodating. Every part of this experience was seamless and full of thoughtful touches. I honestly can’t say enough amazing things about the home, the location, and the entire experience. It was perfect in every way! I’m already looking forward to my next visit.

The house was very nice and in a great location. Lots to do in the area. The kitchen and The upstairs bedrooms and bathroom were nice and remodeled. The downstairs bathroom needs updating. It is original to the house. The house was very clean and the kitchen was spotless. The house is nicely decorated. The host Gordon was extremely responsive.

Melissa’s place is in a wonderful locations. It is clean and comfortable. The host was responsive to all communication and issues.

The house was just as described and just as the photos show. Spotlessly clean. Comfortable beds, linens and pillows. Pretty neighborhood, and peaceful.

One of the best stocked places I've ever stayed. There was no kitchen amenity that wasn't conspicuously provided.

Angelique's home is absolutely charming and located in a lovely neighborhood. We were in town for a race at Jones Beach and loved how quiet and relaxing both her home and neighborhood were. The ground floor was very spacious and comfortable. The kitchen was very well stocked. Upstairs was quite cozy but there is also a bathroom on the main floor so my husband and I each "took" one. The home is very well located with easy access to local restaurants and coffee shops. Highly recommend.