House holiday rentals in Sister Bay

Everything was great! Extremely clean! Loads to do, lots of fun! Amazing arcade games!

Great quiet, private location with unbeatable views of the bay! House was well equipped and matched the provided photos. Would definitely recommend!

We had an incredible stay! Stacie was an absolutely wonderful host. So kind, and very responsive, flexible, and helpful with check-in. The property was perfect- private, with lots of amenities that made us feel right at home. We spent 3 nights here with 11 people and there was plenty of room for everyone. While it feels remote, the town of Sturgeon Bay is very close so you get the feeling of being out in the country with the convenience of being close to town. We also loved being able to say good morning to the adorable cows. All in all, we had a 100/10 stay and will hopefully return soon!

Large home, perfect for a large group of friends or family. Great inside and multiple outdoor hangout areas. Perfectly located near coffee shops, bars, etc. No complaints - highly recommend!

Loved this place! The location is perfect. We started each day with coffee on the balcony and ended each day with wine on the balcony. Beautiful view of the harbor. We made a couple meals in the kitchen. Kitchen was fully stocked with all pots, pans, utensils and everything we needed. We got great sleep on mattresses. I want to buy the mattress for home. We walked into Egg Harbor every day for coffee and shopping. We went to 2 plays nearby, antique shopping, vintage pop ups and ate at great restaurants. I can’t say enough. We already booked for next year.

The condo was so beautiful and clean! Felt like I was at home and such a beautiful view in the back of the condo! Chris was very clear on the instructions the only thing that was missing was the unit number but not a big deal at all. The place was worth what we paid to stay there. I will for sure be staying here again next year I believe we have started a tradition!! Thank you Chris for such a beautiful place that made us feel at home!

excellent property and well worth what we paid. we enjoyed the decks and the views and the ability for walk access to many areas for breakfast and dinner. thanks

Awesome place! The layout of this place worked so good for our family with all our grandkids. The place was so clean and well equip with everything you need! We have stayed at quite a few AIRBNB properties and this one ranks up there with the best. We were not there during weather where we used the pool, but the pool area looks great and well taken care of by the owner's crew. So happy we found this gem!

Dan & Beth said they wanted us to feel at home and we certainly did! We had 7 adults in our group & we talked about the house & cost to stay there. We all agreed it was absolutely worth every cent. Dan couldn’t have been more helpful whenever we reached out with a question. Being right on the beach was magical. Fires at night with a plentiful supply of dry wood was a nice surprise! Anything you could possibly think of was at our disposal! Even the refrigerator was pristine, which in my experience, doesn’t always happen in a rental. We will miss Sandvik house!

I had a fantastic stay at this cozy gem in Door County! The place was incredibly cute and had everything I needed for a comfortable and relaxing getaway. We especially enjoyed the bonfire pit in the evenings, grilling out for dinner, and playing bag toss together. The location was also great, with so many fun things to do nearby. Whether we were exploring the local shops, heading out for a hike, or just enjoying the peaceful surroundings. Everything was clean, well-stocked, and thoughtfully set up. You can tell the hosts put care into making it feel like a home away from home. I wouldn’t hesitate to stay here again — highly recommended for anyone looking for a peaceful and charming spot in Door County!

John and Tracy's home is beautiful. Exactly as described. We enjoyed every minute of our stay. There was plenty of room for our family to spread out and have private space when necessary. We grilled and made breakfast every morning, played lots of games, and enjoyed local restaurants for dinner. We also had music playing constantly through the beautiful speaker system. My son and I also enjoyed 3 games of chess! Loved the board. As it was our first family trip to Door County, we did not know what to expect. Thank you to John and Tracy for meeting our every need. It was an amazing weekend, and we ended at the Farm with our 1 year old granddaughter. Highly recommend both the Airbnb and the Farm!

Goathaus is the GOAT! My family enjoyed a stay here over a fall weekend with our close friends - being the offseason in Door County, we were looking to be leisurely and slow down a bit, and Goathaus was the perfect place to do just that. The house was super clean and beautifully done in a midcentury modern with a touch of cool sci-fi vibes, the surrounding property is gorgeous and serene with views of the lake, there were plenty of fun activities and games at the house for our 4 kids ages 5-8 to keep busy with, and with downtown Sister Bay just a short drive down the hill, good food and drink options were easily accessible. We appreciated the welcome package and book of "How to Stay" instructions/recommendations from our hosts, along with the delightfully witty and helpful labels placed around the house to proactively address any wonderings about how to work this or that. Goathaus has everything you could want for a peaceful Door County retreat!

We felt right at home at this amazing house in Sister Bay! I came with my wife and 2 young kids for Fall Fest and we had a blast. The house was close to everything, Fall Fest was within walking distance, the beds were super comfy, the house had everything we needed and more and the fall colors were pure eye candy. We cooked plenty of breakfasts on the gas stove and had bonfires most nights in the fire out back (which was also super convenient for our dog and for the kids to let out some steam). Our kids also loved hanging out in the She Shed. The hosts were very friendly and responsive. I was so comfortable that at times I forgot I was in Door County and thought I was at home! Would definitely go back!

We enjoyed a long weekend with both sets of parents and our toddler and infant. Lots of thought and detail at the house that made it feel cozy and comfortable. Beautiful space! Having the kids room with kid stuff made things so nice and convenient. One thing we didn’t realize when booking was that one of the advertised bedrooms was in the open loft so to access the other bedrooms and upstairs bathroom you were walking though the bedroom space. Would book again.

I stayed here with 8 of my best friends for my bachelorette weekend and it was perfect! There was space for everyone and the three bathrooms was great for getting ready in the morning. We loved hanging out in the spacious living room and took full advantage of the back screened in porch space. We also walked to places from the house which was nice too! Would highly recommend staying here and hopefully will be back in the future :)

Beautiful home. It was the perfect get away with our kids. Clean and comfortable. Easy check in. Jamie’s place was perfect. We felt right at home and will definitely be back. Also I accidentally left my fanny pack at the house, and Jamie kindly offered to ship it to me, but I was able to turn around and pick it up. She was so sweet about the whole situation. We had a great time!

We had the best time! Such a beautiful space to enjoy and create memories to last a lifetime. The outdoor space was beautiful to relax by the fire. We will be back and recommend to all of our friends and family!

Jill’s furniture was very comfortable. We enjoyed the outdoor furniture, fire ring and grill as well. The quality of the house and furnishings were great. Thank you Barb and Don

This place is beyond breathtaking and worth every penny. Not only is it a dog-friendly haven, the privacy, serenity and accessibility to the beach and sunset views is unbeatable. I highly recommend to disconnect, be present and enjoy the place - no need to leave the house. The host has plenty of in-house amenities, stocked kitchen, and a fenced in yard. We are so excited to return to this cozy cottage soon!

The house was just as described with amazing amenities. Would stay again, loved how walkable it was to Sister Bay!

Our stay at the Alma cottage was even better than we expected! The minimal yet thoughtful design boasted large windows that really let the surrounding landscape in allowing for a peaceful ambiance throughout the cabin. The beds were comfortable and we felt at home. Everything was wonderful. We will be back!

Beautiful historic home in Fish Creek. We enjoyed the outdoor space and walkability to the local beach, Restaurants, State Park and shopping. The house was clean, bright and airy. A really nice space to spend time with family and friends. We appreciated the sun and shade options for spending time outside at the home and the privacy of the yard. We will definitely return to this property for a future trip to Door County. Thanks for sharing your home!

We had such an enjoyable stay, and thank you for all your help. It's a great place and was just what we were looking for!

We had a wonderful stay at this adorable home! The house was spotless and felt very welcoming from the moment we walked in. One of our favorite parts was the backyard—it was private, peaceful, and such a great spot to relax. Everything was exactly as described, and you can tell the hosts really care about the guest experience. They were quick to respond and very helpful anytime we had a question. We’d definitely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a cozy, clean, and comfortable place to stay!