Holiday rentals with outdoor seating in Shelter Island Heights

Erica and Janson's place was perfect for our group of eight to attend a wedding in the Hamptons. You cannot get closer to the North Ferry to Shelter Island and there are many restaurant and shopping options within walking distance... the pizza place next door is open late, PORT restaurant (across the street!) is great for waterfront drinks and dinner. While we didn't use it, the LIRR station from Manhattan is also 500 feet from the front door. Ample parking was appreciated and the place was spotless. Thank you Erica and Janson!

Spent a long weekend here with one other couple and had an amazing first trip to the North Fork. Karine's home was beautiful and close to everything we wanted to see, and her recommendations were excellent and super helpful! I hope to come back soon and would absolutely recommend this place to others. Thank you Karine!

Maura is an amazing host! She is super friendly and helpful and personable. The house was beautiful and very clean and the location was perfect! I would/will be booking it again in the future.

Kristin’s house was perfect!!! It was even more beautiful in person and had absolutely everything we needed to have the best stay at Greenport! Not only was it beautiful, but it was also in the best location, making it easy to get to and from the Main Street and wineries! I traveled with 8 friends and we all said we’d book again without a doubt! Thank you Kristin for an unforgettable stay!

I have a lovely time at this charming home. It was exactly as pictured and advertised. The home is warm and inviting and I was very comfortable throughout my stay. The backyard has a beautiful view of a lake. I spent quite a bit of time on the rear deck reading and getting distracted by that view. Locally there is Greenport Village, Orient Point State Park and Inlet County Park to name a few of my favorite outings. Thank you to my host for being so responsive when I called with a minor issue one late evening. I hope to return for another stay one day in the future.

This was a great spot to stay for our group. We would definitely stay here again!

Absolutely wonderful home. Stayed there as two families. Felt like staying at a friends house. Jake and Kim are flexible about check out which was greatly appreciated. Would highly recommend.

Great location, private and comfortable. Close to wineries and breweries. Very clean and convenient. I highly recommend.

We had a great weekend at Nicholas’s place. It was very peaceful in the woods, and we enjoyed using the record player and looking through the books spread throughout the studio. Nicholas was very responsive when I texted with questions and we used his provided recommendations to find breakfast and dinner. We’d definitely stay here again!

It was such a pleasure spending a weekend in Claire’s studio. The studio is very clean and comfortable, and my wife and I particularly appreciated the kitchenette, which allowed us to prepare a dinner one night and make our own pour-over coffee in the morning. We also loved hearing the birds as we woke up in the morning. And the location is terrific—an easy walk to the Southhold town center and a quick drive to other surrounding attractions like Greenport, nearby beaches, and wineries. Highly recommend!

Lovely town and environment. Very spacious and fully equipped apartment. The two bedrooms are separated from each other by the big kitchen, a little reading room and the living room…so good privacy. Two TVs. Comfy beds! The small town is an easy and pleasant walk. It’s a ground floor apartment under the owners house, so be prepared for the patter of little dog feet above. We did not see the owners but communication was terrific. Great place to stay in the vicinity.

Wonderful and cozy apartment! We were in town for a wedding and needed a clean and safe space to make home base. This was perfect. Would absolutely stay again!

Great venue. Hope to be back next year!

Great place ideally located next to town and the view is amazing. highly recommend in particular for short term stay.

Kevin’s place was great! Kevin was very helpful and responsive. The place was clean, neat & had everything you needed. The view from the living room & bedroom was beautiful & the lake was a great place to go kayaking. Great for groups looking to have a relaxing weekend, in close proximity to the beaches (~25 minutes). Would definitely come & stay again!

Came for college graduation. Shannan’s place was homey, spacious, and clean. Anything you might need is provided. Close to everything by car. Shannan was responsive to all our messages and seemed friendly, although we did not meet her in person. There is a warning in the listing, but I just want to reiterate that the steps are quite steep! Keep this in mind if you have heavy luggage. Overall a great and comfortable stay.

Mark's place was exactly what I was looking for to ring in the New Year in style, comfort and complete relaxation! I was able to start each day with a quiet cup of coffee and then head directly to the beach for a long morning walk (just a short drive away). Montauk Manor is an absolute hidden gem for a winter break and the indoor pool and hot tub are a rare find in the Hamptons. Check-in/out could not have been any easier and the Manor staff are wonderfully welcoming and friendly. There were still a good number of local shops open, including Left Hand Coffee. 100% recommend for all seasons and will eagerly book again!

We loved Montauk - low key, wild and upmarket at the same time. This apartment was perfect, super quiet yet near everything and loved seeing wild deer from the terrace

Lisa and I enjoyed our stay at Laurens place. Felt right at home. Very clean, open space. We had the best time and did not want to leave. We will be back for sure.

Had a wonderful stay with my family. Clean, comfortable, great location. Good communication. Had a little trouble with the front door first day but someone was available quickly to help. A+

Jeff's place has a lot of character and is spacious. The setting is excellent, near the water, with Satterly Landing right down the road. We enjoyed our stay.

Thank you for the stay. Price, location, communication and apartment were all top notch. We had a great week, definitely recommend, hope to be back.

Just had a wonderful stay at Robert’s place! The place was impeccably clean, and Robert was incredibly responsive and friendly throughout our visit. While the manor has a charmingly vintage vibe and could use a bit of modernization, we truly enjoyed our time there. The warmth of the atmosphere made it feel like a home away from home. We recommend for anyone looking for a cozy getaway!

What a perfect place for my girlfriend and I to celebrate her birthday. Michael’s place is beautiful, modern and extremely clean which is an absolute must for me. Also, he was very proactive in communicating and was great to work with. I would highly recommend the place and Michael overall, as a host. It was just a great experience all around and we had a phenomenal weekend in Mystic!