Guest house holiday rentals in Schuyler County

No Wi-fi? No TV? No problem!  Spent a relaxing week shopping, site seeing and wine tasting during the day, and sipping wine under the grape arbor, enjoying the scenic vista of the vineyard overlooking Keuka Lake, and quilting! My friend and I were able to finish 4 quilt tops this week! Our host, John, was on premises in the main house. He greeted us on arrival, and was able to answer questions about the area, provide recommendations about the local wineries and restaurants, and some local sites of interest. Overall, it was a very enjoyable stay.

I really enjoyed my stay here! The cottage is super cozy and I love the decor. It’s easy to see a lot of care has gone into the place. The kitchenette on the second floor was really nice to use. Wylie was a really great and friendly host, and her cat Bleu was also a highlight of my stay. The location of the cottage is lovely, right by Stuart Park, Cayuga Lake, and a variety of trails. The walk to downtown Ithaca is only 35 minutes or so. I would definitely recommend this spot, and I’d stay here again if back in Ithaca.

The location is fantastic and Brian is incredibly helpful and responsive. My stay was absolutely wonderful.

Robert was a stellar host. He went above and beyond and truly loves hosting people and their dogs. If you are a dog owner and want to rent this place, you are in excellent hands. We asked to be on his mailing list for Summer 2026 as we will definitely come back for another visit.

Cutest little Airbnb!! My husband and I came up for the weekend so that I could run the Gorges Ithaca Half Marathon. It was equal in distance to Trumansburg and Ithaca (just 10 minute easy drive to each!) , which is exactly what we were looking for. We loved the peacefulness of our stay, the beauty of the location and Heather was more than responsive! We knew exactly what to expect (and even we greeted by the 3 sweetest little dogs!). We highly recommend this place and we will absolutely keep this place in mind for when we come back!

This was my second stay at Jackie’s house and my Mom’s first. She enjoyed it as much as I did. It’s a beautiful spot. The house is cute and very clean with everything you need. The dock is the perfect spot to sit on and enjoy the lake. Can’t wait to go back.

This apartment was very cute and clean! Easily accessible and Connie was very sweet and communicative! I would highly recommend this Airbnb!

Rented for 2 nights and had a wonderful time. Spacious, clean and very peaceful! Great view of the gorgeous pond outside the living room window and a back deck with table chairs to eat meals at. Check in was easy, wifi worked great. A/C also worked very well during hot summer heat. Not one bad thing to say! Very happy to have spent time at this wonderful airbnb and looking forward to booking it again in the future!

What a beautiful view, the best part was the dock on the lake watching the sunset and you cant beat the breathtaking beauty of it. The place was cozy and very clean. Hey if your looking for a getaway rather it be romantic or going to see what the lakes have to offer this place is a great location. We will be definitely returning. Thanks Marla

The Birdhouse was wonderful! So cozy and comfortable. Very clean and welcoming. It was in the best location and near everything. Karissa and Eric (property manager) were wonderful to work with and we're very quick to respond to any questions or concerns we had and were extremely accommodating. Thank you for a fantastic stay! we would definitely stay at the Birdhouse again and recommend it to our friends.

We had a great time. Location is central to 2 fingerlakes . Great hiking and wineries in the area. Lots of amenities for family fun. We hope to visit again.

We really enjoyed the place. Was close to all the State Parks we wanted to visit. Great secluded location. We had a good laugh at the Opera toilet. Didnt bother us at all. Was nice and cool during the warm weather bit cold at first as it was cold outside but plenty of blankets around to keep cozy. Really enjoyed talking with them as well and the recommendations for hikes to do for our next trip. Would definitely stay there again. Only improvement would be to let guests know what the grid is to plug space heaters in during colder weather so they don't trip the fuses.

This place is in the middle of nowhere — but a short drive to somewhere! There’s a store easy walking distance away. Otherwise, you are in the middle of farm country. Just what I was looking for! From the outside, the house isn’t much to see. My children were even a little apprehensive. But nice inside, it is bright and modern and clean. I highly recommend it!

The only thing I wish we had was more time to enjoy the views and area! Highly recommend booking with Jason if you’re looking for peace and tranquility!

We had such an amazing stay here in Penn Yan! We loved the home and especially the games and pool table downstairs! My boys loved playing in the huge beautiful backyard!

Hawks Landing is a beautiful, serene location nestled alongside Lake Canandaigua that is nothing short of breathtaking. We spent 4 days here and loved every moment of it. The property is well-maintained and offers plentiful amenities and privacy. Tom is a wonderful and generous host, and his two furry co-hosts were just as welcoming! We highly recommend this cabin to anyone looking to enjoy a vacation or even just a weekend to the country any time of year, and would definitely consider going back to experience it all anew.

Peaceful place. Was working very hard and long hours in the area. Very restful stay.

Daniel was a great host, and the place was exactly what we needed! We hope to stay again on our next visit to Ithaca!

6 STARS- if possible. Having had staying at more than 30 different listings through this platform, Jordan’s The Outlook not only ticked all boxes but simply exceeded all expectations and standards. Clean, neat, attentive setups, clear instructions, proactive communication…etc. on top of this dream location with lovely decor and breathtaking views of the Cayuga Lake. This experience was simply divine and for one to cherish forever. Now I’ll add one star more :)