Holiday rentals in Sanibel Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Home in Captiva

My Sea Shack~ 1 minute to beach, SH Club, G-Cart

Let "My Sea Shack" be your home away from home while you recharge your mind, body and soul on our island oasis, North Captiva! We are an unspoiled, low-key tropical paradise off the coast of Southwest Florida. This means that our beaches are uncrowded, and tourists and traffic are just a mainland memory! Leave your car and your cares at the marina because this island is only accessible by water taxi, boat or private aircraft. Each day, after exploring our paradise (by provided golf cart), let this spacious property welcome you back. Our new stilt home was built in 2018 and is ready to meet all your vacation needs! It features 2 bedrooms and a pull-out couch which will comfortably sleep 6. The master’s over-sized king bed will provide a nightly hug and a warm place to dream. Not tired quite yet...put on some tv and fall asleep while watching your favorite show on the flat screen. The 2nd bedroom can accommodate 3 people eaily with a comfy queen bed and twin. This room also has a flat screen making it a little easier for guests or little ones to doze off. In the morning, start your day off with your cup of coffee or tea on our sprawling deck. Relax and unwind in this comfortable home away from home! Spend your days on our beaches or stay as busy as you’d like with four on-island restaurants, two bars, kayak rentals, fishing charters, private chefs, cabana rentals, craft making opportunities, bicycle rentals, sunset cruises and our favorite - island hopping charters! My Sea Shack also comes with resort like amenities…take a dip in the community pool, play a game of tennis, enjoy priority seating at Safety Harbor’s restaurant -> On The Water or bring your private boat and have access to a boat slip (small daily fee applies). What makes this property TRULY SPECIAL though is the fact that it is only a 2-minute walk to Safety Harbor’s private beach entrance. This beach is so secluded, you will feel like you are on your own private beach. Choose your itinerary, let us take care of the rest~ your next adventure on North Captiva awaits. HOW TO GET TO THE ISLAND AND HOUSE Island Girl Charters has a ferry that runs from Pine Island to North Captiva. At the marina, you can leave your vehicle there. The boat crew will load up your luggage and groceries onto the ferry and you will be on your way..the actual ride is only about 20 minutes long. Many times you will see dolphins trailing behind as you make your way to the island. Upon arriving at the Safety Harbor drop off, our conceirge service will pick you up and load your belongings onto a trailer. If this is the first time, they will be happy to give you a quick tour before taking you to the house. The conceirge service will also take you back to Safety Harbor upon departure. INCLUDED~ Water osmosis system Wifi Netflix, disney +, hulu, amazon prime DVD player Blue-ray player 6 beach chairs Umbrella Beach towels Beach games Sand toys Pickle ball set Grill Propane tank Pack & play Highchair All spices Courant pizza maker (for frozen pizzas) Mixer Can opener Toaster Coffee maker Blender All kitchen cutlery Blowdryer T-fal cookware Vacuum Cleaning supplies Laundry det pods Hand soap Dish soap Toilet paper Paper towels 1 bottle of wine

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 84 reviews

Right on the Beach with the Best Views and Rates!

Sanibel Siesta looks amazing! Immaculate beachfront, 2BR, 2BA w/garage, nicely updated beachy unit at sand's edge. Amazing views of the Gulf with 5 star ratings! 3-day min. Sustained min. damage from Hurricane Ian. New hurricane windows, freshly painted with ELEVATOR IN BUILDING! Discount for weekly/mo. rentals. BR 1: King bed, en suite, smart TV. BR 2: 2 twin beds, smart TV. Qn. sofa bed in LR. Pool, golf course, bikes, laundry on site. No food or condiments stored in unit. May allow small dog.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

Beautiful Condo - Fully Equipped - Pet Friendly

Beautiful 2 BR, 2 Bath fully equipped condo in the Sanibel Siesta condo complex. Ideal middle island location and only steps to the beach, public golf course with private pool and indoor private parking garage. Tennis courts, shuffleboard and grilling areas are available to all. Beach accessories are available for guest use and complex has on-site bike rentals. 3 nt minimum stay with an on-site rental office to help during your stay. Beautifully landscaped grounds complete the total experience.

Superhost

Sundial A208- Stunning Beachfront 2BR at Sundial

Introducing Sundial A208- A true island oasis featuring phenomenal gulf front views! This beautifully updated and decorated condo offers all the luxuries of home with those spectacular Gulf views and magnificent sunsets to match! Featuring 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms and a fully stocked & equipped kitchen to make your stay as comfortable and enjoyable as possible! Available for the first time since its complete renovation in 2025, don't miss out on the opportunity to experience some of the finest

Guest house in Fort Myers

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

Waterfront Hideaway

This picturesque Airbnb is a hidden gem nestled along a canal with a one minute boat ride to the Caloosahatchee River. The living room, bathed in natural light is perfect for taking in the scenic views. The spacious bedroom has a king-size bed, ensuring a night of blissful rest. The full kitchen is equipped with all modern appliances. Bring your boat and dock it on the seawall, ready to set sail whenever your heart desires. (PLEASE NOTE-boats only) Book now - your coastal paradise awaits!

5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Home in Sanibel

Mangoes (Right Side)

Discover an escape to Mangoes, our Sanibel retreat where luxury and coastal charm intertwine. This haven features a full kitchen, living room, master bedroom with its own kitchenette and bathroom, bluetooth speakers, guest bedroom, and two pull-out couches. We've got you covered with starters — coffee, tea, etc. Step outside to discover an oasis with a HEATED SALTWATER POOL, hot tub and grill. Just a short walk to the beach, Mangoes captures the essence of Florida living—sun, sand, and sea!

5 out of 5 average rating, 74 reviews

View of Gulf, Steps to Beach@The Turquoise Turtle

Welcome to The Turquoise Turtle, the newest and most stylish condo in Loggerhead Cay! Our personal vacation spot; this family friendly, coastal property overlooks the pool and is a two-minute walk to the gorgeous white sand beach. Fully renovated in 2021 with new kitchen, bathrooms, flooring, furniture, and curated beautiful beach decor. Grab a drink and relax on the patio, with a view of the beach and listen to the sound of the waves. At The Turquoise Turtle you will truly make memories!

Superhost

Home in Captiva

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Villas in the Air – Elevated Island Living!

🏊‍♂️ Heated pool on the main living level—no stairs for easy access! 🌅 Rooftop porch with stunning views of the Gulf, Bay & Preserve 🛋️ Thoughtfully designed with elevated interiors & stylish decor 🍳 Restaurant-inspired kitchen plus indoor & outdoor dining for memorable meals 🏖️ Beach gear & 🛺 golf cart included for effortless island fun 🍹 Outdoor bar, 🎯 games, 📺 smart TVs & 🧘‍♀️ tranquil wellness area 🐾 Pet-friendly 🤝 local concierge support for a stress-free stay!

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 84 reviews

Home in Fort Myers

Experience of a lifetime

Get ready for the experience of a lifetime at this hidden gem! As you walk through the front door you will begin your journey into the best vacation of a lifetime. Keep on going through the sliders & that will lead you to the incredible resort style pool that will leave you in awe!!! Here you are in the heart of it all. Shopping-dining-entertainment is all within a 5 minute drive. The beautiful beaches just 7 miles away. If you enjoy boating & relaxing this is the place for you.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Home in Sanibel

Sanibel Delight

Per the Nice People at Sanibel City Hall My License number is RDWL-009981 and Tax ID is RDWL-009981. 28 Days min stay. To See Video please look on YouTube and search “5308 lady finger lake rd 4K” Open Concept Light and Airy 3 Bed 3 Bath Home on Beach Path to Bowman's Beach. Perfect for entertaining and enjoying our beautiful island oasis. Brand new landscaping with numerous fruit plants for your enjoyment. Newly Renovated and ready to welcome you for your Beach Getaway.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Home in Sanibel

Coastal Chic Island Escape

Just 150 yards from Sanibel's peaceful beach, our home offers unmatched luxury: direct beach access, a heated saltwater pool, private pickleball/tennis court, and sea-view dining. A king suite, additional king bedroom, playful bunk room, and separate apartment provide comfort for all. Perfect for those seeking a serene escape, our home is not suited for loud gatherings or parties. Please help us preserve the tranquility of this special place. 28-day minimum.

Superhost