Holiday rentals in Kelleys Island

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 256 reviews

Apartment in Sandusky

180° Lake View in the Heart of Downtown Sandusky

This 3-BR, 2-BA loft's high-end furnishings & incredible 180° bay views make it truly unique. Located in the luxury waterfront Chesapeake Condos in the heart of downtown Sandusky with views of Lake Erie & Cedar Point, this is the ideal location for experiencing the North Coast & islands. Walk a few min to restaurants, shops & more, & ferry to Cedar Point or the islands. Less than 10 min to Cedar Point & other attractions. Building has outdoor pool and fitness room. Off-street parking for 2 cars.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 77 reviews

Chalet in Kelleys Island

Cozy Chalet, "On the Rock" Kelleys Island Ohio

Quaint island chalet offers a comfortable and pleasant place to relax after exploring the island. The Chalet includes the lower unit for 4 people with standard rental, with the option to upgrade to full upper and lower units for $25 per person/per day (2 addional people max) Upper unit has an additional kitchen, livingroom, bathroom and sleeping area. You will find trails to walk, beaches to stroll and sunsets/sunrises to marvel over. Everything the island has to offer within a short distance.

Superhost

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 87 reviews

Dannys Million Dollar View - Kelleys Island, OH

Awesome Lake View. A-Frame summer Cottage on Lake Erie with plenty of parking for our fishing guest boat trailer, 4 bed, 1 bath (tub shower), lovely corner Lakefront/Lake view and rocky beach in front of house. Loft with pool table. Built in 70’s, early American decor. Good for women’s retreat in fall, host an educational retreat, or a couple who wants to spend time together in a quiet place with and excellent view (extra guest fee over 4 guest, 5 people max). Prices include bed tax of 6%.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 223 reviews

Home in Oak Harbor

Golf Cart- Lake Erie Water Front Beach House

This home features a panoramic view of Lake Erie. You are minutes away from fishing charters, restaurants, activities & 45 min to Cedar Point, 15 min drive to ferry for Put-inBay. 2 private bed rooms, 1 up & 1 down, loft area with 3 queen beds & fun LED lighting! Plus a bunk room/entry way with 2 twin beds & TV. Home comes with everything that you will need to make your vacation a pleasant get-a-way. Kayaks, lawn chairs, coolers, bikes, and corn hole. We have many board games, dice & cards.

Superhost

Guest house in Kelleys Island

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Cottage for Two

This small quaint Island Cottage Suite offers a comfortable and pleasant place to relax between travels about Kelleys Island where you will find trails to walk, beaches to stroll and swim as you observe the beauty of nature. There are extraordinary sunrises to the east and sunsets in the west of the island, kayaking, and historic sites such as Glacial Grooves, the Historic Museum, churches, restaurants with varied cuisines, also offerings of breakfast specials, and various interesting shops.

Guest house in Lakeside Marblehead

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

Great Lakes Retreat

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. **No cleaning fee** Located near East Harbor State Park, Marblehead Lighthouse or take the ferry to Kelly's Island. Open floor plan offering a double bed, a perfect couple's retreat! Your stay includes a kitchenette equipped with coffee, tea and hot cocoa. Wifi and tv are in the open area, along with a settee area. Unique design using reclaimed wood, a custom bathroom you won't find anywhere else. Plenty of hot water. All guests must be 21.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

RED RETREAT is the perfect Kelleys Island getaway!

Red Retreat has all the amenities you'll need to enjoy your time on Kelleys Island! This spacious 3 bedroom home sleeps up to 8 guests. Located only 1.2 miles from the ferry and 1.5 miles from the downtown area. While here, you will love the nature, the history, the wineries/breweries, restaurants and live entertainment. You will be a short ferry ride to the world famous Cedar Point or South Bass Island, home of Put-In-Bay. We can't wait for you to experience the Kelleys Island life!

5 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Firefly Cottage

One of the best kept secrets in the U.S. is beautiful Kelleys Island, just a short ferry ride from the mainland in Marblehead, you will arrive to the island and in minutes be at Firefly Cottage. Walking in with your friends or family, you will feel an instant calm. Firefly Cottage is a unique home that can cater to young and old, smaller or larger groups, and a home that's child-friendly but not filled with child-specific items. We can't wait to talk to you about the stay of your dreams.

Apartment in Kelleys Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 69 reviews

Wake on the Lake

This island getaway is within walking distance of the Marblehead ferry and downtown, with great shopping, restaurants and entertainment. Tastefully decorated and meticulously maintained, you can enjoy your morning coffee on your private balcony overlooking the quarry pond. After a fun filled day of island exploration, relax on the spacious couch and enjoy Hulu live TV or stream a movie over Wi-FI. The pool was closed last summer but should be operational in 2023.

Cottage in Kelleys Island

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

Serenity Island Escape 3 bedroom cottage

Come and enjoy our cottage on the beautiful Kelleys Island. After a relaxing day at the beach rinse off with the outdoor shower. Then spend time with the people you love most at our outdoor fire pit. Crawl into bed relaxed after a serene experience at Island Life. Bedroom 1 First floor king bed, bathroom with jacuzzi tub & shower Bedroom 2 king bed Bedroom 3 Queen bed Loft 2 twin beds First floor washer and dryer. Located on one acre wooded lot.

Superhost

Cabin in Kelleys Island

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Kelleys Island Cabin Fever/Duplex Unit 1

Our unique cabin was built in the 1950's with 4 bedrooms, two baths and two small kitchen/living areas finished in knotty pine. In the 1990's, a beautiful enclosed porch was added as a common area for both units. We purchased our lovely home in 2016, updating the kitchens and expanding the living areas. Cabin Fever is a multi-use home that that can be rented as a 2 bedroom 1 bath unit or 4 bedroom 2 bath home.

Cottage in Kelleys Island

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 85 reviews

KI Modern Farmhouse + BBQ + Firepit + Backyard

This unique place has a style all its own. Your stay here will not only be peaceful but will give you all the comforts of home. This brand new Modern A-frame Farmhouse is situated less than 2 miles from town so you can have peace and quiet but also enjoy all the sites of Kelleys Island. Enjoy a night by the fire pit or a day relaxing on the decks. Send us a message with any questions

Holiday rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Cottages

Quaint homes, peaceful surroundings

Houses

A space that's all yours, with room for everyone

Hotels

Stylish accommodation and amenities

Popular amenities for Kelleys Island holiday rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great holiday rentals in Kelleys Island

Flat in Port Clinton

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Apartment in Port Clinton

LindaRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

The apartment was great, really clean, and Lacey was very easy to work with. She was proactive and contacted me 2 days before our arrival with the check-in procedures. I didn't quite understand, however, about the steps involved to get into the building and then the flight of stairs to get to the second floor where the apartment was located. They were open steps and it was difficult for me (partially handicapped) to get my suitcase up the stairs onto a landing, through another door, before getting to the apartment door. But, it was worth it. It was a lovely apartment with beautiful views of Lake Erie and very quiet. I particularly enjoyed the screened-in porch and hammock swing. It was very comfortable and easy for me to get in and out of (surprisingly). The sun coming into the apartment in the morning was just lovely. I thoroughly enjoyed my visit and would stay there again if I am in the area.

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Flat in Middle Bass

Waterfront Condo in Middle Bass

AnthonyRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

Simply Amazing! Words cannot describe. Beautiful view, very hospitable and accommodating host. Thank you for the wonderful stay!

Apartment in Port Clinton

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Luxe Lake Condo

MichaelRating, 5 stars5 days ago

The condo is a beautiful place to stay. It was easy to find and enter. It was one of the cleanest places we have stayed. It had everything one would need even for a long stay. The bed was very comfortable. It was nice to hear the sound of waves! The location is within walking distance of several restaurants as well as a great donut shop in town. We would definitely stay there again.

Cottage in Lakeside Marblehead

5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Cozy Anchor Cottage

KassandraRating, 5 stars2 days ago

We had a wonderful stay at this cozy cottage near Lakeside and Marblehead! From the moment we walked in, it felt like home — everything was spotless, and the amenities were truly top-notch. You can tell Amber put a lot of care into the space and they genuinely want their guests to enjoy their stay. Communication was excellent throughout the entire process, from booking to check-out. The location is great — close to both Lakeside and downtown Marblehead. While it’s walkable, be aware that you’ll need to use the main road, which can have a fair amount of traffic. We opted to drive and also rented a golf cart from Moke America Ohio, which made getting around super easy (and fun!). We would absolutely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a comfortable and convenient spot in the area!

Cabin in Kelleys Island

4.68 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

The Round House Retreat on Kelleys Island

StephenRating, 5 stars7 months ago

great spot on the island. you really get to be in the center of everything and feel entirely alone with full privacy.

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

A tranquil getaway at Beach Glass Cottage on KI

AndreaRating, 5 stars1 month ago

We have been staying here for the last 2 years and will continue to book with Rachel. House is wonderful and perfectly located for us to get the boat in and out. Rachel is also very considerate of doing her best to get us into the house early since we arrive earlier due to traveling. Would recommend this place 100%