House holiday rentals in Fishers Island

We had a perfect weekend at Mk’s place! After a very rough start to our weekend at another unsuitable air bnb (for reasons I won’t mention) Mk was extremely accommodating and her place was perfect. I would stay here again and again! We were sad to have to leave!

We loved staying at this home - it was the perfect place for our group of ten. The outdoor space was definitely the highlight, with the pool & spa being our favorite part of the trip. The only thing to note is that we weren’t supplied quite enough toilet paper or paper towels, though I did not reach out for more - It was the last evening when we ran out and we were leaving early the next morning. The trash requirements were a surprise after booking, but going to the transfer station was easy enough, and it is listed on the house rules. Overall, an excellent stay and would absolutely return!

Ashton’s house a very comfortable and extremely clean home. It is spacious, allowed tremendous privacy and met our needs perfectly for an amazing family vacation. Everything was just as explained with no surprises. Great stay and a very accommodating host.

Michael’s place was amazing, means a few friends stayed this weekend for my birthday. He was always willing to help and very accommodating! The house itself is so beautiful and had everything we needed! It was our first time in The Hamptons and he gave us tons of recommendations!

We had a lively stay at David and Michiko's place. It was a perfect little getaway for 2 young familes of four. The pool was great, and it was a short drive to the beach. Lots of great restaurants around also!

A great place for family and friends. Very roomy, open kitchen to living comfort with many places to sit and socialize while preparing meals. Nicely decorated and very comfortable accommodating furniture. All the amenities. Every bedroom a king size bed with some rooms offering even more sleeping spaces. The pool pristine, perfect temperature and seating for those chatting on the sidelines while others swam. A simple walk downtown. In many cases the walk downtown was quicker than the ride downtown. My family truly enjoyed this vacation. My grand daughter (4) loved the home. Everyone was comfortable and had a great time.. Jason friendly and available before, during and at close. I highly recommend this gem in Mystic, Connecticut.

We had a lovely stay at Roger and Amy’s place. The location was great - close to Southampton, a short drive from Sag Harbor etc. The home is charming and comfortable. The kids loved the heated pool and spent hours in it every day. Roger and Amy were also super responsive, with advice and help when we needed it including with a very sweet gift for our 3 year old whose birthday we were celebrating. All in - a phenomenal time!

We had a lovely stay at Eric's home. The home exceeded our expectations and we felt right at home. The decor was warm and inviting. Everything you could possibly need was in the stunning, modern kitchen. The beds were all comfortable and we slept very well. The property was very peaceful. We enjoyed seeing deer, turkeys and hawks each day. The fixtures in the home were modern, clean and high-end. It was great being so close to Greenport with it's wonderful restaurants and shops. We can't wait to return.

Spent a long weekend here with one other couple and had an amazing first trip to the North Fork. Karine's home was beautiful and close to everything we wanted to see, and her recommendations were excellent and super helpful! I hope to come back soon and would absolutely recommend this place to others. Thank you Karine!

We had a wonderful stay at Patricia’s! Great location, beautiful view, felt like we were right at home! Our son loved roaming around the spacious backyard. Thank you Patricia!

This place was perfect for what I needed. It was cozy, comfortable, clean, simply and beautifully decorated, and well equipped. It was also a wonderful setting with great views in all directions. While the houses are quite close together, it is a quiet neighborhood and it helped that it wasn't high season. Lots to explore nearby and just as tempting to sit on the deck or lie in the hammock watching the world go by. This was more than I had initially planned to spend, and I'm so glad I went ahead with it anyway - very grateful for this spot!

We had a wonderful family weekend at Bill and Heather’s house. We felt like we were home and not in a rented house. The house was gorgeous, spacious and extremely well kept and stocked. The grounds were beautiful. The attached apartment was perfect for my husband and me when we needed some alone time. Our kids and grandkids appreciated each having their own bedroom. We cooked dinner a couple of nights and found every pot, utensil and cooking implement you could ask for. Bill and Heather were very kind, and their welcome packet was the best we’ve ever seen. We investigated a lot of places in the Mystic area before we chose this one, and we definitely made the right choice. We highly recommend Bill and Heather’s house.

Catherine’s place was even better in person! It was perfect and just what we needed. She was easy to communicate with and so accommodating. The street is amazing with the water right there! I will stay here every time I’m in the area!

This is a fantastic house for holiday overflow. Clean and cozy and Kristi is super responsive.

Beautiful stay in Groton! Well appointed house, lots of room for all, and gorgeous views on the waterfront. Great location and close proximity to Esker Beach & Restaurant, 10 minute drive to Mystic which was great for our 3 families over MDW

Staying at Daniela’s place was great! Super easy to find and get into the peaceful house on the pond. Even though it was pet friendly, the house was spotless and had no wear or tear from previous visitors. It was great that they had child gates at stairs too! The dog loved going out in the canoe and swimming in the pond! Great place overall!

This place was PERFECT. I couldn’t ask for a better place to stay. Beautiful views, plenty of space, and the home has everything you need. Kate was responsive the entire stay and was very helpful. Thanks again for a stress-free stay.

Quiet neighborhood near the beach. After months of working 60+ hr weeks, it was just what I needed to reconnect with my family. Fire pit was perfect for roasting marshmallows. Next time we're bringing a kayak or something so we can go out on the water. So peaceful.

Beautiful house, amazing location. Super close to the beach! The house is beautiful and spacious, we were 8 people and did not feel crowded at all. The amenities are great and we felt right at home. Totally recommend it! We already want to come back. Thank you so much.

Brandon and her husband were amazing. Their place is beautiful and exactly what we were looking for on our vacation. Very relaxing, intimate, and classic Montauk experience. We had a great time and the visitor guide and suggestions were perfect. We hope to go back soon!

This home was beautiful! The location had amazing views, very quiet but lots of restaurants/ coffee shops/ activities nearby. Cindy was so welcoming and responsive, would recommend to anyone!

Great little house. Very well stocked and very clean. High quality all around! Little beach area is very rocky so not for lounging but a great launch point for small boats. Water in the area is very calm. Neighborhood is very quiet and cute with lots of amenities.

We had a great stay at Kaitlyn's house. Communications with Kaitlyn were kind and thoughtful and the details in the home show the same care. It was a nice home base to explore Mystic and Westerly. We would definitely stay again!

Highly highly recommend this home it was perfect in every way we LOVED it!!!!!! Awesome hosts awesome all around