Holiday rentals with a pool in Put-in-Bay

We had a great time at the round house! Jeff was super responsive and friendly! The house had everything we needed. We traveled with young kids and they especially loved the heated pool!

This is my friends' and my second time staying at Marsha's. Once again we had a tremendous time and the stay was pleasant from start to finish. Marsha's communicates clearly and proactively.

This was my second time staying at this space by Amy with my entire family. Once again, we had a blast. When anything came up, Amy was responsive and quick to resolve it. The place is beautiful and accommodating and I will def be returning again with my family in the future.

I stayed in this exact cottage as a kid and into my teen years (before the back space with w/d and extra bathroom was added). It has since changed owners many times, but man, I wish Brian had had this property all along! Fantastically helpful, check in and check out was a breeze, the place is equipped for everything you need to have fun as a fam (bikes, tennis rackets, scooters, pickleball paddles ...), the space was super functional, and the location is *chef's kiss*. No notes! 10/10. I can't wait for 2026 availability to drop so we can book 423 Cherry again (for the 21st summer!!).

Nice spacy place. The house was clean, the foosball table and air hockey table both worked. The pool is bigger than your typical above ground. The house is located is on a dead-end street which is nice, because there was no through traffic. It is located about 10/15 min from sports force and cedar point. The only downside is that you can hear the train from the house.

Great home and decor. Clean and comfortable. Location wonderful. We were off season so not a lot open, but there was plenty to do. We took the ferrie over to Put-in-Bay and had lunch at the winery along the way on Catawba Island - so nice! PIB was adorable but again off season - we missed by a week. But JJs was good food as well. Worth the stay!

We had a fantastic stay! The space was spotless, smelled amazing, and was incredibly spacious and comfortable—perfect for relaxing after a long day. The location couldn’t have been better, with everything we needed close by. The hosts were friendly, responsive, and made sure we had everything we needed for a smooth experience. Highly recommend and would absolutely stay again!

We had a great time! Great use of space, and very private and quiet. This is the perfect place for a nice and quiet trip!

We booked on short notice. Jonathon was very accommodating. The condo was clean, comfortable, and perfectly located on the lake.

Vlada was an awesome host from answering questions before and during our stay, and taking care of everything we needed very promptly! She went above and beyond for us! Beautifull place that matches the descriptions, just like the pictures!

What a wonderful, gracious host- always immediately responsive and helpful! The place was clean, inviting, quiet, and had everything we needed! Because of exceptionally poor planning on my part, Jennifer thankfully allowed us to check in earlier than the stated time - which made it so less stressful for me! One word suffices for our stay here - Perfect!

We had a great stay at Chris and Dawn's condo. The space was clean, well equipped and just as described in the listing. The hosts were very responsive and quick to answer any questions we had. The view from the screened balcony was awesome. Highly recommended!

In PC for a family holiday gathering. This condo was within three minutes drive from our party. Overall it was an excellent location, and my kids enjoyed using the hot tub late at night to cap off our stay. I hate to say anything negative about such a nice condo, however, there were a Lot of trains going through (but gladly they seemed to stop by the time we went to bed - or we just learned to tune them out). And unfortunately, our family of four were trying to get ready to go out to dinner and we ran out of hot shower water after the first two short showers. The beds were very comfortable though, and overall it was a very nice place.

Went to Cedar Point, walked to get sushi, soaked in the hot tub. Had a great time. We would stay here again.

In Sandusky for sports tournaments or Cedar Point this is a great place to stay. Ultra clean, very comfortable, walking distance to restaurants, 5 minutes from Sports Force Park and just a very comfortable home away from home. We fished as well which was great away from the baseball field. When we are out the road for tournaments we like to eat (make) our own food to save money and eat healthy, kitchen worked out well. Again can’t stress enough the comfort factor and location!

Stayed for a long weekend to celebrate our anniversary and Marks place made it an even more special occasion. Everything was outstandingly perfect, clean and comfortable. the location couldnt be more beautiful. We hope to be able to come and stay again!