Pet-friendly holiday rentals in Put-in-Bay

Our family went for Memorial Day weekend to the Port Clinton area. We brought our boat which was so easy to park in the home's driveway. Unfortunately, the weather was not as warm as we would have liked. However, we were pleasantly surprised to learn that the Walleye Festival was going on. We enjoyed the festival and the parade which was all so close to this home. I am usually hesitant to book older homes but as other guests have described, this home was so clean with such comfortable, newer beds and linens. My boys were excited to have the upstairs bedrooms to themselves. And they loved the LED lights in each of the bedrooms. The kitchen was so well organized and had so many utensils/cooking gear to choose from that were like new as well.

The stay is great and everything looks brand new. Backyard was very nice to have to a trip!

This little cabin is FABULOUS! I love staying in places that feel like home and this definitely fit the bill. The kitchen had every dish and pan you could want. Full size frig, some dry goods in the cabinets, lots of extra blankets. We loved the quirkiness and character!

My family and I really enjoyed our stay at the Firefly Cottage on Kelleys Island! In my experience, this is one of the nicest Airbnb homes I’ve ever rented. The home is very well appointed with many amenities like kitchen basics, games, movies and supplies. Have no doubt, they have remembered anything you might have forgotten at home! This modern constitution home is quiet with a large back yard and open floor plan. Our family of 8 fit comfortably. We would definitely rent the Firefly Cottage again!

Beautiful house in a quaint and quiet beach town. Easy instructions and access to get inside. The home was decorated beautifully and everything seemed to be in nice condition. The max guest count is 10 people and the pictures did make it seem larger than the listing. It was smaller than expected for 10 people to stay but we were still able to have a great evening and instructions for leaving were clear and easy as well. The private beach access is just a quick walk down the street but we were not able to stay because of lack of parking because of having the max guest count of 10. However there was a public access beach just a short drive away with a small parking fee. Overall it was a nice stay with very friendly hosts!

Great place, and close to town. Thanks for the stay.

Had a great long weekend at Michael's place. A planned fishing trip quickly turned into a nice relaxing weekend due to all the to common, unpredictable weather on Lake Erie in early May. Michael was extremely accommodating, understanding and helpful with the unpredictable change in our departure plans. Outstanding service! We will definitely book with him again..

The house was in the perfect location for going to Cedar Point! It was very clean and easy to get into, and we loved being able to bring our dog too. The restaurant and bar recommendations were great too. We will definitely stay here again whenever we make it back up to Sandusky!

Our stay was amazing. The host did a.great job making sure our experience was the best. I will definitely be back

What a wonderful, gracious host- always immediately responsive and helpful! The place was clean, inviting, quiet, and had everything we needed! Because of exceptionally poor planning on my part, Jennifer thankfully allowed us to check in earlier than the stated time - which made it so less stressful for me! One word suffices for our stay here - Perfect!

Great home and decor. Clean and comfortable. Location wonderful. We were off season so not a lot open, but there was plenty to do. We took the ferrie over to Put-in-Bay and had lunch at the winery along the way on Catawba Island - so nice! PIB was adorable but again off season - we missed by a week. But JJs was good food as well. Worth the stay!

My family and I loved our stay at Sara's! Everything was conveniently located with less of a 10 minute drive to everything we wanted to do. African wildlife Safari I was about a 20 min drive. Scenery was beautiful, the space was clean and welcoming. We enjoyed the pool very much. We will definitely be back and will be checking out the other properties she has available. Loved it!

We stayed here during the Biggest Week In American Birding Festival, and the location was fantastic relative to Magee Marsh and many other birding spots. The cabin was clean and well maintained.

Wonderful place to experience the lighthouse festival! Cottage was very well appointed, had everything we needed, cozy, Comfortable sleeping areas. Appreciate being able to bring our pup too! Thank you for opening up your home to us.

Cozy & Compact, great for if you want to go to Cedar Point for a whole day. Definitely a place to stay if you are going to be out & about in the area.

Excellent place to stay. Nice and central location, and easy to get wherever you’re going. Cozy place! James is a helpful and responsive host.

Everything was as described! The house was super cute. Breakfast was delicious. Shelly was extremely helpful and responsive. We will definitely be back again!

Melissa was wonderful. Will stay again.

We are Port Clinton natives and wanted a place to stay when we took our grandsons to visit for the first time. This was perfect! Big enough for 5 adults and adolescents, everyone had their own bedrooms, perfect kitchen with enough seating for 6 or more at the table. TV's everywhere, with a nice big one in the living room and enough seating there for everyone also. So much to do around that area that we never lacked for entertainment - Cedar Point, Put-in-Bay, Marblehead Lighthouse, and just a good town to hang out in. Good outdoor space also, and even a cornhole game! Would definitely recommend, especially to a family group.

I rented the house for my husband’s 50th birthday. It was a perfect place to stay for our family and friends. It was very spacious, had a beautiful view of Lake Erie. Ted was very easy to communicate with. The extra touches were a definite bonus; pool table, darts, air hockey table and many games.

We stayed here before. Great place! Great host!

We initially had problems with the door code, but Cheryl immediately solved the issue. We didn't ask for a refund but Cheryl went the extra mile and refunded one night's stay. Cheryl gave us a Cafe recommendation and made sure we had a peaceful, enjoyable stay. We had a small issue with our dog breaking a lamp while we were there and Cheryl was very understanding. We agreed upon a price for the lamp and the matter was resolved with no fuss. I would highly recommend Cheryl as a host.

Ryan’s place was very clean and comfortable. Great location for what we were there for. My wife loved the charm of the hardwood floors and wood trim. I will book again if available when we are in the area.

These two are the best! Not only did they block a day off for us to come early to set up for our wedding, they left a bottle of wine and gave us a late check out! Thank you so much for everything, our weekend was perfect and we appreciate all your help along the way.