House holiday rentals in Eleuthera

We really enjoyed our stay at the Hibiscus House. The beautiful blue of the ocean could be seen through the trees and there was a real sense of privacy. Listening to the waves crashing during the evening while sitting on the screened in porch was incredibly relaxing. The beach was a short walk from the house and was where we spent our late afternoons after exploring the island during the day. The house had a large stash of toiletries, bug spray, sunscreen, beach gear, and a few clothes items in select closets--which was wonderful considering our luggage got lost and took days to get to us. Lydia, the house's caretaker, came by to say hello and make sure we were comfortable...and we absolutely loved learning about the island and recommendations from her local perspective. I would absolutely love to stay here again if we make it back to Eleuthera.

Great location and amenities, had everything we needed, can't wait to visit again!

Wonderful stay at Sugar Apple! The house is clean and spacious. Having the pool was nice at the end of the day! Close to many beaches and not far from governors harbour. Second time renting this home and won’t be our last!

Heidi was very responsive and the place was very comfortable.

The house was immaculate upon arrival. lots of space. wonderful central location, so it was easy get to the popular sights. The pool was a welcome sight after the hots days.

Words cannot describe how incredibly beautiful this home is. Private but easy to get to. Having the large pool and ocean access on property was awesome. I appreciated how responsive Dina and the property manager Anne were. The kitchen is stocked full of everything you might need. Comfortable rooms and nice having multiple bathrooms. Easy to get to Ten Bay Beach with the most gorgeous water I’ve seen. Recommend Island Farms, Tippys, and The Front Porch. Didn’t want to leave and definitely will be back!

Paradise! We visited Eleuthera 3 years ago and spent the day at Rainbow Beach. All day we admired the Sayle Point House. We were so excited that it was available when we planned our next trip. There is new construction, but I believe you will still feel like you're on you're own private island. We visited a few spots and kept coming back to the house thinking why did we venture out. We enjoyed our morning walks around the property and it provided amazing snorkeling opportunities in the backyard. We hope to visit again soon!

This place is a gem! We were lucky enough to get a whole week in this beautiful home with the Caribbean as our backyard! Deborah is a wonderful host with excellent communication and an amazing home right in the middle of gorgeous Eleuthera. Governor’s Harbour is the perfect location- the island is long and getting from one end to the other can take awhile, so being in the middle means everything is a reasonable distance away. It was hard to leave the house though! We had some perfect, sunny and windless days so we snorkeled and paddle boarded right at the house! There were even 2 sea turtles to keep us company. If you want to journey farther, rent a car from Romell- he is awesome and met us at the airport! 1648 is an amazing restaurant, but we mostly bought fresh fish and cooked at home- the kitchen had everything I needed to prepare lobster and fish. We are already planning to come back- we had the perfect week at this lovely, peaceful home!

The pictures don't do justice to this home (light and beautiful) and its surroundings (paradise). There should be one of the view from the deck directly down to the ocean! :) Architecture is stunning. Full on views of the beach and tropical vegetation from every side. Two different work spaces with desks and views out the back. Kitchen is a little small if you're having a big group, but for two it was terrific. Everything worked. Fans in all the rooms! Great shower with fabulous water pressure. Loved the simplicity of the decor and having the beach to ourselves. BE SURE TO READ THE INSTRUCTIONS (and maybe print them at home). VERY useful information. Contact Latoya for practical questions. She was able to get us a rental car when other companies said they had no vehicles left. Do get a 4WD. The high chassis is important for rutted roads if you go anywhere off the beaten track. We didn't plan to, but it happens! :)

Although a short stay, it was a great stay. We found the video for the beach super helpful and the rental provided all we needed.

Fantastic location for a family; large space and perfect set up for adults and two kids. Thank you!!!!

Sara was a gracious host. Her house was exactly as she described. It had everything needed for a fun day at the beach- chairs, umbrella, floats and coolers. She accommodated the change in my travel schedule and also allowed an early check in. We had a fantastic 18 night stay. This property is highly recommended, and I anticipate a stay in 2026.

Our stay in Eleuthera was absolutely incredible, and this Airbnb made it all the more special. The hosts truly thought of everything — from the little touches that made it feel like home to the thoughtful details that made our beach vacation effortless and family-friendly. The space was spotless, beautifully designed, and had everything we needed to relax and enjoy our time together. It’s rare to find a place that balances comfort and style so well, especially one that works so seamlessly for families. We loved how close it was to the beach and how easy it was to settle in and just be. And the view at night? Unbelievable. Easily the most stunning nighttime view I’ve ever seen — peaceful, starlit skies over the ocean that felt like something out of a dream. We left with full hearts and beautiful memories. If you’re thinking about booking — do it. This place is a gem, and we can’t wait to come back.

Our stay at Shutter Box was definitely worth it! The place looks just like the photos and is extremely clean and welcoming. All of the appliances work very well and the bed is extremely comfortable. We were also impressed with small details like the quality of linens and towels. Anke and Alex were very accommodating to personal requests and always answered in a timely fashion. I highly recommend staying here.

Perfect! Cobalt Cottage was everything and more! We loved every moment we spent inside the cottage. Our kids enjoyed catching hermit crabs and playing on the slide / swings! The screened in porch was the place to be, and was so peaceful. Adrian, the property manager, was so helpful and made sure we knew where to go and how to get there; he even help set up a boating experience, it was amazing. It was nice having him close by, always ready to help if needed! We felt safe the entire time, and everyone on the island were so nice. We used Chad and Hope’s guide a lot, it was so helpful and informative. Everything we did was based on this guide and it did not steer us wrong! We will definitely be back; our kids (4, 7, 10) were so sad to leave, so were we!

We absolutely loved our stay at On The Rocks for our family vacation with a 1 year old. The house is decorated beautifully and was super clean with fresh bedding. If you're looking for a place to truly unplug, this is the place. The view is stunning and the local beach is a short walk away. We couldn't believe we got an entire beach to ourselves! The house was well stocked and had everything we needed, which made it easy to pack light. It is definitely remote – which is a amazing if you're looking for peace and quiet, but might not be for you if you're looking for something close to hustle and bustle of a town. The road in from the highway took about 10 minutes to get to the house. There are a handful of restaurants under a 20 minute drive and we enjoyed meals at El Karaka, Big Daddy's, and The Cove. We also did day trips to Harbour Island and French Leave beach (would recommend Tippy's as a place to spend an afternoon). We'd highly recommend On the Rocks or Due South!

We had a lovely stay at Sonshore Cottage! The house was clean, had a beautiful esthetic, extra beach towels were in the closet for our use, a soft cooler and plenty of ice packs were available for our beach outings, and more! Sarah was also a very responsive host providing us with a lot of local recommendations and help if we had any questions. We will definitely stay at Sonshore Cottage again when we return to Eleuthera!

Blue Moon was an absolutely amazing right on the Beach at Gaulding Cay Beach. There are no other rentals directly on the beach here. The water was amazing crystal clear just a few steps through the coconut tree. (Not many bugs) We used the SUP and double kayak one afternoon. And everyday we snorkeled the rock everyday. Hanging out listening to the water and coconut trees in a hammock was extremely relaxing. The house has loads of books and a great collection of art. Daddy Joes was just a short walk down the road. Gregory town is just a 4 minute ride in the car. We are looking forward to our next stay. I am dreaming about that beach and hammock!!

We had a wonderful stay at "Island Time"! The area is absolutely stunning and the house was everything that we expected. Any issues we had were seen to immediately. We always felt well cared for, and that all of our needs were met. Mellissa's emails were so warm and friendly. It is so obvious that she loves this home and Eleuthera, and we can absolutely see why. Shawne really went above and beyond to help us while we were on the island. You have our extreme gratitude and we are hoping that Eleuthera will one day be home , too!

Just a fantastic home in a beautiful part of the island. The kitchen is well equipped with everything you may need, and there are so many areas to spread out and activities to keep you busy that you will never get bored. Dee was excellent at helping us obtain a rental car, as well as introducing us to Horatio who made us a wonderful meal one night. While we didn’t get to explore as much of Eleuthera as we had anticipated, we were able to see many spectacular beaches within a 20-30 min drive in either direction. We’re already planning our trip back!

We miss it already! What a gorgeous home, that’s clean and homely with a lovely open living space. It’s less than a 5 minute drive from the most beautiful (and child friendly) beach, Rainbow Bay. In terms of convenience stores, you’re not walking distance to anything but easy to jump in the car and in 10 minutes you have a few options on Queens Highway. Lauren the host couldn’t have been more helpful and any questions we had she was really quick to respond. We would definitely stay again.

We stayed April 5-19 2025. The house is new, spacious and great window light coming in. Comfortable bedding etc. the house is on kind of a rocky beach but it is one of the few we have found on Eleuthera with shells! The back porch facing the ocean was one of our favorites spots to hang out when not in the sun. There are 2 hammocks in the yard which were so relaxing. Ken, brother in law of owner lives close by and checked in with us and as the house is new and just started being rented out he said to let him know if we think of anything it might need. We travel to Eleuthera about once a year. And there were a couple itemsI I thought the place could use and presto! Ken had them to us by evening! That was fantastic so now there is a cooler to use, some additional kitchen items and an iron 🙂 David also checked in when we arrived and after we checked out. We really like Neek’s. Eats for food and drinks and it is only about 5 min. Away. There are some games there and we left a couple book

Lovely and well stocked house close to beaches, stores and great restaurants. Wonderful host who was always helpful.

We loved our stay at "The Getaway". It was very private and very clean. The house itself is remarkable. As many have said the pictures do not do it justice!! Other things worth mentioning are; the settlement of Current is extremely friendly welcoming; the property manager Karen and the facilities support Pedro were excellent and incredibly responsive; we hired a private boat, Captain James from Lower Boque, to take us sprear fishing and snorkeling, was awesome. So much more we could add. Definitely worth a repeat visit. Thanks for your place Tim! Rgds, Jeff & Anne