Holiday rentals with a fireplace in Conneaut Lakeshore

This was our fourth year staying at Barbara's and the place has now become as familiar to us as a second home. We again enjoyed our long weekend and expect to return next March. The lodge is cozy, well maintained and has all the attributes to make your stay enjoyable and relaxing. Thanks Barbara.

Wendy's Lakehouse was exactly what my husband and I needed for our mini-retreat after our daughter's wedding. We were mentally, physically, and emotionally exhausted when we arrived; but after a couple of days of complete quiet and privacy in the house, walking and laying on the private beach, listening to the water, watching the sunsets, and basking in the fresh Lake Erie breezes: we felt restored and refreshed. The only thing that disappointed us was that we couldn't stay longer... life rolls on! 😅 Within hours of our arrival we were making plans to return- next time with our 4 sons- as soon as possible! We even were dreaming about bringing future grandkids in years to come! 🥰 Thank you, Wendy, for providing this peaceful retreat!

We had such a great time and already cannot wait to come back. The house was extremely clean, had everything you need, and offers the most beautiful and private view of the lake. It has the perfect view of the sunset! Jeff and Anne were extremely responsive if we needed to reach out and made the place feel right at home. There are a ton of areas within the house and around the property to relax and see the lake. Also a quick drive to restaurants and grocery stories and the neighborhood is very quiet and safe, perfect for walks. Would definitely recommend!

We had a wonderful stay! The place had everything we needed and more. Leslie is a fantastic host, so thoughtful and thorough. I especially loved the binder with detailed recommendations for places to eat and things to do, it was incredibly helpful. The surprise treats were such a sweet touch! Everything was well-organized and made our stay exceptional. We would absolutely stay here again!

LOVED this house! Someone with a degree in interior design must’ve been involved in the decorating bc it looked like something out of a magazine. And the view was absolutely stunning. Also, as a mom with small children, I loved how we were right on the water but high enough up from it that I didn’t have to worry about my kids walking into it while playing outside. I also loved the location of this house. We were right in between Ashtabula and Geneva on the Lake so it was a little more peaceful than being right in the middle of GOTL. My family preferred Ashtabula anyways as it had more of that quaint old town charm. The house also had great storage which may sound funny, but I love to unpack and really settle into the home. It seems like so many places don’t provide that anymore. Anyways, I would totally stay here again!

The house is very nice, welcoming, spacious, and convenient to local activities. The hosts are attentive,responsive, and friendly. It was a pleasure to stay and will be recommended anytime someone needs a place in the area.

Gene's place is wonderful! It was so comfortable for our group of five adults. The kitchen is fantastic, and there are so many thoughtful details all throughout the house. Highly recommend this spot!

Me and my fiance had our little elopement ceremony at Kimberly’s Airbnb, and we could not have had a more beautiful and peaceful stay (: we very much hope to be back as soon as possible

As soon as we walked in the door, we felt immediately at home! This was one of the best Air B&B stays that we have ever encountered! My wife was so impressed with how thoughtful the decor was and the welcome basket was yet another detail that we did not expect. The lake view was beautiful and even though the weather wasn't the best, it was the type of place that you could just relax and spend the day right there. Maripat and Tim were truly "Super Hosts" and it was evident with their home and their great communication. They literally thought of everything that you could possibly need and anything else was pretty close by. We had the most relaxing and stress free getaway that we've had in awhile. If our travels take us back to western NY again, I can guarantee that we will be trying to stay at this beautiful place on the lake. If we could give this 12 stars...we would!

Casey was a fantastical host. I was able to get as much information as needed. the place was stunning and easy to move around

We're very familiar with the area, so the location was great for the places we knew we wanted to visit during our stay. Comfy bed, hot tub was great, fireplace was nice since it was sort of unseasonably cool for late May. Would definitely stay again!

This was the best place I’ve rented. It was cozy, comfortable, clean. Overlooks the lake, the host made the stay warm and welcoming. Provided a bottle of wine and made himself available for anything we needed. They even provided spices for cooking and cream and sugar for the Keurig. Lots of places don’t do that, we end up buying sugar and cream from a store and never use it all. The decor was so lovely, and the place was well designed and put together. Lots of lights and plugs!! The first night was a little chilly outside but there was an electric fireplace that provided great warmth and ambiance. Check in was a breeze, we felt safe. It had two bathrooms which was great!! I will be booking it again for future stays.

This place is AMAZING!! It looks just like the pictures. It had everything we needed. It was spotless, the bed was very comfy, and the garage was an added bonus! We were in town for wrestling at Spire. The location was super close to Spire… just a few minutes away. There’s several good restaurants within a 10 minute drive. And we met Bob! He was a great host, very friendly and responded to any questions right away. And he did all the beautiful carpentry and construction on the property. This is definitely a 5 star property! We will be back!!

We stayed here after our Wedding that was about 10 minutes away. The place was beautiful and very clean. The host was super kind, responsive, and very accommodating. We even had the most delicious homemade cookies waiting for us when we arrived! When we woke up we got to enjoy the beautiful patio, it was a very peaceful and relaxing stay!! Thanks for having us!!

Don was great company and does a great job at taking care of any needs. Great atmosphere and sceneries. I would definitely recommend this place if you are looking for a nice quiet place with great company.

I am in Geneva because my son is wrestling. This space was so nice that I feel like I should take a trip back here just to stay the night. It’s affordable and really nice. The Tuttle’s did a great job with the space. I was very impressed. I 1000% recommend this space for anyone looking for a place to stay.