Waterfront holiday rentals in Chautauqua County

Best stay ever! First time being on a beach and it was unforgettable! Views were amazing! Beach was very quiet! Pamela was very sweet and friendly! Very responsive when we needed something. Great recommendations on local things to do!

As soon as we walked in the door, we felt immediately at home! This was one of the best Air B&B stays that we have ever encountered! My wife was so impressed with how thoughtful the decor was and the welcome basket was yet another detail that we did not expect. The lake view was beautiful and even though the weather wasn't the best, it was the type of place that you could just relax and spend the day right there. Maripat and Tim were truly "Super Hosts" and it was evident with their home and their great communication. They literally thought of everything that you could possibly need and anything else was pretty close by. We had the most relaxing and stress free getaway that we've had in awhile. If our travels take us back to western NY again, I can guarantee that we will be trying to stay at this beautiful place on the lake. If we could give this 12 stars...we would!

A great place, best AirBNB I have ever rented. clean, good layout, Deborah was fast and clear on communication, great view. I have already rented it for 2 more trips this year.

Great place to enjoy the Great Lake, Lake Erie

Great house on the lake! Our first house canceled Sunday and we secured this house on Monday for a check-in Tuesday. Everything was great considering we had to book at the last minute.

Sandra and Dan are great hosts! We were super happy with the entire experience. Looking forward to becoming repeat guests! :)

We had a great time at Sally's place. It was perfect for our weekend friend reunion and just steps from the beach on the lake. We were super comfortable and Sally and her husband were super friendly and helpful. We can't wait to come back!

We had a great time in the lakeside apartment. Everything you could need was provided, and Kate and Ron were super friendly and helpful.

Had a great weekend at Stephanie's! Can't beat the location and the house is beautiful!

If you’re in the Chautauqua Lake area it’s a great stay. Beautiful view of the Lake. We’ll be back. Thank you

Very cute and cozy lake house with beautiful sunset views - perfect for our weekend getaway. We especially enjoyed watching the antics of a family of ducks (with 8 ducklings!) as they passed by several times a day. Mary was great - she reached out to me before we had even arrived which I appreciated. All of her instructions were clear and easy to follow … a very positive experience overall.

We enjoyed our stay immensely! The facilities accommodated all our needs. The grandkids enjoyed fishing off the dock and I was able to moor the boat with ease. I have little doubt we will return to the Kingfisher in the future. Great hosts!

Enjoyed our 1 night stay here. Great location looks out onto the lake. Walkable to the lighthouse. Home was clean and beds comfortable. Kitchen well stocked. Would definitely stay here again if in the area.

We had a lovely stay at this lake house in Mayville, NY. The home was clean, cozy, and exactly as described—everything was in perfect order when we arrived. You can tell the hosts put care into creating a welcoming space. Unfortunately, the weather didn’t cooperate during our stay, and we had rain and heavy fog most of the time, which limited our ability to enjoy the beautiful outdoor space and lakefront views—the main reason we booked this property. That said, the home itself was a great retreat, and we’d love to come back when the weather is more cooperative to fully enjoy all it has to offer.

We've stayed at Chad's home twice now, and it's absolutely incredible! The cabin feels like home, the property is immaculate and the pond is beautiful. This is the place if you're looking to be secluded in nature. We can't wait to plan our next trip out.

Our children grew up vacationing at my father's cabin on Chautauqua Creek. We were able to gather here and remember, relive, and share those special times and activities. We explored the creek, wading, swimming, skipping stones, walking up and floating downstream. We went hunting for beach glass early in the mornings at Barcelona. We enjoyed a smoked whitefish there at the shore. We shopped the farmer's market, buying amazing baked goods from the Amish, beautiful beachglass jewelry, local maple syrup, and strawberries. The maple glazed donuts are not to be missed! They sell out quickly, so go early! The house was equipped with everything we needed. The beds were very comfortable. The layout of the rooms gave the perfect blend of private space and welcoming common areas to do family activities. Our dog was a last minute addition and he was graciously provided with towels, bowls, and toys. We loved walking barefoot on the moss, lazing in hammocks in the woods, and rain on the roof!