Holiday rentals in Bethany

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

Game Room | Hot Tub | Fire Pit @ Lake Shelbyville

Sitting just one mile outside city limits & 2 minutes to Lake Shelbyville, is this beautifully appointed home waiting for guests to enjoy all of its amenities; pool table, fire pit, grilling area, corn hole set, and hot tub. Inside, nothing was held back when it came to decorating this home for a truly relaxing experience. All the amenities of home are here just waiting for you to arrive, relax, and enjoy. We are sure you will rest easy in this boutique style home located at Lake Shelbyville.

LocationFamilyBeach

An aerial view showcases the property’s extensive 5 acres, highlighting a large, stocked fishing pond surrounded by manicured grass. Trees line the perimeter, and a spacious area is visible for both parking and outdoor activities, including a pathway leading to additional structures.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Evergreen Pond

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. This house sits on 5 private acres w/ a stocked fishing pond. The back yard has 6’H fence & there is a dog door for Fido, sorry no cats. The Wilburn Creek Rec area & boat ramp is only 1.6 miles. This property has room to park your boat & RV. Enjoy sitting on the porch swing, playing pickleball on your private court or shooting some hoops. You also have access to a 2 car garage. The basement offers Pop-a-shot basketball & ping pong.

FamilyLocationOutdoor spaces

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Cabin in Arcola

Elk Ridge

Come and enjoy yourself at Elk Ridge, the first B&B of Wildlife Manor! Located within Aikman Wildlife Adventure, we are home to over 240 animals. This retreat offers the scenery of wildlife inside or outdoors. You have the chance to see zebras, bison, camels, and much more! Elk and water buffalo love to take a swim in the pond that Elk Ridge overlooks as well. Enjoy the natural scenery in the evening around a firepit on the waterfront deck. This will be an overnight adventure you won't forget!

LocationValueOutdoor spaces

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 90 reviews

Asa Creek Cottage

This open concept cottage offers the perfect blend of nature and modern comfort for families and small group gatherings. Enjoy the creek side deck, and listen to the gentle sound of the little waterfall nearby. On cooler evenings, gather around the fire to warm up. The interior boasts a spacious design, close to The Little Theatre on the Square, walking trails, and Lake Shelbyville with boating, fishing and swimming. Relax with a modern kitchen, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and a rainfall shower.

LocationFamilyLaundry

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 68 reviews

A modern kitchen is showcased with wooden cabinets and quartz countertops. Stainless steel appliances include a refrigerator, oven, and microwave. A large island features three black stools, while pendant lights hang above, illuminating the space. The flooring is a warm wooden finish.

Home in Findlay

Ultimate Country Home!

The Hideaway at Lake Shelbyville LLC is a privately owned, secluded shed house. This house can accommodate multiple boats and trailers of any size. It is a perfect house for a weekend getaway or a weeks' vacation in the heart of Lake Shelbyville. This country home is only 2 miles from Lone Point, 2.8 miles for Coon Creek, and 6 miles for Eagle Creek Boat Launch. This amazing house also has a 4,800 sq ft shed with a pickle ball court, badminton, corn hole, basketball hoop, and much more.

FamilyLocationKitchen

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 163 reviews

A renovated red caboose, TP&W 527, is positioned on railroad tracks surrounded by grass. The structure features white wheels and an elevated cupola, with windows and a yellow emblem. Green trees provide a natural backdrop, and a cobblestone pathway leads to the entrance.

Train in Oreana

The Caboose on Mayberry

Welcome to our mid 1900s caboose TP&W 527 and step back in time. Unwind and relax as you settle into your retreat. Enjoy the view from the cupalo as you browse through one of the books on board, or sit at your dinette and enjoy a board game. Sit out back in one of the adirondack chairs around your own private fire pit and enjoy s'mores, or just a peaceful evening. The caboose has been completely renovated and many modern convienences added. You'll love this unique and romantic escape!

LocationFamilyTV

Superhost

The exterior of a charming cottage features a white facade with yellow awnings above the windows. A small porch is adorned with blue chairs and a yellow bicycle, complemented by a neatly manicured lawn and vibrant lavender flowers along the front edge.

Home in Decatur

Beach Vibes in the City | Family & Pet-Friendly

Soak up summer vacation vibes all year long at our breezy beach-themed cottage! 🌴 Fully fenced backyard is perfect for kids & fur babies to safely play. 3 minutes to Millikin University & Fairview Park 8 minutes to Memorial Hospital 15 minutes to Caterpillar & ADM Gas, groceries, and Walgreens are just around the corner. Check out family-owned local faves - Diamond's Family Restaurant & Krekel's Kustard Kick off your shoes and relax—you’ve found your home away from the shore! 🐚

ValueLocationBack garden

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 366 reviews

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 154 reviews

Cottage in Decatur

Cozy Lakefront Retreat w/ Dock, Kayaks & Games

Welcome to Lake Shore Cottage, hosted by Beyond the Path Vacation Rentals, where your experience is our priority. Enjoy lakefront living: fish from the private dock, paddle kayaks, relax by the fire pit, and enjoy the peaceful waterfront views. Comfortable beds, fast Wi‑Fi, huge digital game board, smart TV, fully equipped kitchen, quiet safe neighborhood, minutes to Scovill Zoo, Devon Amphitheater, Nelson Park, Splash Cove, restaurants, shopping, and available boat rental.

LocationFamilyDecor

Superhost

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Lakeside Haven

Relaxing property whether your enjoying a family vacation or hunting, fishing, or a day on the lake. This beautiful home rests beside Corp grounds.Come enjoy the quiet mornings drinking coffee on the porch with the birds and Watching the deer right in the front yard. Walk down the trail and you'll enjoy a lake front view.. enjoying a beautiful sunrise or sunset relaxing by the lake. 2 miles from Findlay boat ramp 2.5 miles from Cole shaft boat ramp and much more.

LocationFamilyBack garden

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

A tree-lined street is visible, showcasing a yellow house with a light-colored roof. The grassy yard is bordered by shrubs, leading to a sidewalk. Nearby buildings and a well-maintained road add to the neighborhood's residential character, with open space extending in the distance.

Home in Findlay

Charming Yellow House

This home is just 5 minutes from Lake Shelbyville and Findlay Marina! Whether you’re here to fish, boat, hunt, explore, or unwind, this adorable yellow house is your spot. 🍽️ Walk to the café, park, bait/gas station 1+ block 🥩 Dinner or drinks at the local steakhouse or the winery just 4 blocks 🛶 Boat-friendly with side street parking parking on East and South road **unfortunately we do not allow pets anymore **Jack and Jill bathroom shared between bedrooms

FamilyLocationOutdoor spaces

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Home in Decatur

Lakefront Haven in Decatur

Escape to the peaceful shores of Lake Decatur at this beautifully updated lakefront retreat. Enjoy fishing, boating, or relaxing from your private dock, then unwind around the stunning fireplace or take in sunset views from the spacious deck. The open-concept layout offers inviting gathering spaces and plenty of room for families and friends to connect, relax, and enjoy the perfect lake getaway just minutes from local dining, parks, and attractions.

ValueLocationSleep quality