House holiday rentals in Baiting Hollow

Nanette and Jaime were wonderful hosts. The house felt like home, and the place felt bigger than what it seemed like from the photos. Our family enjoyed the time in the hot tub (also not shown in photos) during the chillier evening. Thank you for a wonderful time!

We loved staying at this home - it was the perfect place for our group of ten. The outdoor space was definitely the highlight, with the pool & spa being our favorite part of the trip. The only thing to note is that we weren’t supplied quite enough toilet paper or paper towels, though I did not reach out for more - It was the last evening when we ran out and we were leaving early the next morning. The trash requirements were a surprise after booking, but going to the transfer station was easy enough, and it is listed on the house rules. Overall, an excellent stay and would absolutely return!

Paula was great! The house was beautiful! Stayed here for my cousins wedding and we really enjoyed our stay!

Gorgeous house and property that is even better than the photos. Like other reviews have mentioned, the highway noise in the backyard is definitely present, but easy enough to ignore. Really enjoyed our stay and communication was great!

We had the most beautiful weekend stay at Tim’s home! Everything is accurately described and the pool and hot tub were amazing!! All the beds were very comfortable. Was perfect for a 5 girl weekend getaway!! Tim was incredibly communicative and checking in was a breeze. The location is PERFECT in East Hampton!! So many amazing restaurants and bars nearby. 100% will stay here again for my next Hamptons trip. Thank you so much Tim!!

Sarah is an amazing host - super quick responses to questions, friendly, helpful, it was such a pleasure to stay at her house! The house is more than that - Sarah makes it feel like home! From the countless comfy reading nooks that our teenagers loved and used, to the awesome outdoor space, the pool table & wine cooler and well stocked kitchen all the way to the nice touch of live plants (because let's be honest, at how many AirBnBs have you have live plants before?!). We felt right at home and are definitely planning on coming back! Highly recommend!!

We we’re going to Port Jefferson for a family wedding. Our Airbnb was perfectly situated. There is a pool area that we never used because we just didn’t have time. But it looked very inviting. The town of Port Jefferson had plenty of nice restaurants and shops. This house was perfect for our situation. We had six adults, all family members.

Christine's place was nice and clean! We especially loved the fire pit and the pool. Upon arrival of the AirBNB Christine was waiting to meet us and show us around. This was something that was new to me in my AirBNB experience, but it was honestly so nice and so was she! Christine let me know that I could communicate with her for anything that was needed and asked for recommendations to make her place better. This place was so well-equipped, close to everything and it comfortably fit me and my 6 other friends! I would definitely book again with Christine.

There’s so much to love about this charming open plan beach cottage! We especially enjoyed the water views, hearing the birds, and eating on the breezy porch. It was sparkling clean and stocked with everything you’d need, from comfortable beds and towels to many thoughtful essentials like hand and dish soaps, tea and coffee pods, paper towels/toilet paper, and shampoo/conditioner. Eileen is a gracious and responsive host — she was particularly understanding when we had to reschedule our visit. Thank you for a wonderful stay, Eileen, and we hope to return!

Well equipped! Enjoyed our stay :)

Ellen’s place was great for the 4 of us! We loved the quiet residential location which was a short drive to good restaurants. We spent a lot of time lounging on the back patio which had comfortable patio furniture. We drove to beaches, and found that a couple further away met our needs better than the local Yacht Club. The beach gear that was provided at the guest house was really helpful. Ellen was a top communicator & provided more snacks and drinks than I’ve ever seen at an AirBNB. I recommend Ellen’s place!

This stay was truly beyond incredible—it far exceeded all of my expectations! The house was not only stunning and beautifully decorated, but it also had such a warm and inviting feel the moment I walked in. It was spotless, impeccably clean, and clearly cared for with love and attention to detail. The highlight for me was the serene back deck overlooking the canal—such a peaceful, calming space that made it easy to relax and unwind. I found myself spending hours out there, just soaking in the tranquility. Yoon was an absolute dream to communicate with—always prompt, kind, and so accommodating. Every part of this experience was seamless and full of thoughtful touches. I honestly can’t say enough amazing things about the home, the location, and the entire experience. It was perfect in every way! I’m already looking forward to my next visit.

Well-appointed and beautiful new property with space for a family of four to spread out and feel comfortable. We greatly appreciated the beach chairs and towels and beach pass so that we could enjoy the private beach access down the road. The board games and family-friendly downstairs space was also a wonderful addition! Chris was an incredibly friendly and responsive host; I was comfortable asking questions at anytime during our stay.

Ashley’s house is the perfect get away. I booked this house for my family to stay for my wedding weekend. My mom had never stayed in an Airbnb before and I’ve never seen her so happy and relaxed. She truly enjoyed her first Airbnb experience at Ashley’s place. It was exactly as described and the view is beautiful. Ashley was very responsive and made sure to answer any questions I had.

This was our wedding day weekend and we were shocked just how well this Airbnb was designed, built and cared for. All of the appliances were high quality, an art TV, a gorgeous shower. My wife and I couldn't have been happier calling this cute cottage home for this special weekend. Thank you Sara!

Such a lovely place to stay for the night and Konrad was amazing! Super attentive and the charm of this place is perfect! Def recommend

We loved the location and the place was beautiful. Its was nice and clean. Definitely will be booking again

Yu’s place was beautiful and right next to the beach! We had a wonderful stay. She was very responsive and communicative. The beds were comfortable and there was plenty of space! I loved the kitchen. The beach was ideal for my family’s trip! 12 mins to New Haven!

The house and gardens are beautiful. We enjoyed the outdoor deck with grill and pool, as well as the outdoor seating at a table with gas heating on it. Inside is wonderful, as well. Well equipped kitchen. Nicholas was very responsive and addressed our needs quickly.

The stay at Matthew's place was great. One of the best airbnbs we've stayed at. Right on the water and the views were amazing. The place was clean and everything we needed was there. Matthew was an amazing host, probably one of the best we've ever had. He answered all my questions before heading out there and made sure we had everything we needed. We would definitely come out here again and it was great for our family.

The house was gorgeous and such a beautiful location and time of year to stay. Highly recommended!

We had a great stay at the Airbnb. One thing I haven’t seen mentioned in the reviews or descriptions is that this beach had tons of sea glass! In our short stay we found over 100 pieces and my 4 year old was absolutely delighted scouring the beach for it. There are also tide pools less than a five minute walk from the house. These two things made the stay quite magical for my kids. Otherwise the location is great and the house was very clean. I appreciated the bed on the first level having a trundle as well as a door at the top of the stairs for safety. The house is minimally decorated which is honestly a plus when you don’t have to worry about your kid breaking nicknacks on coffee tables. A few nice throw blankets and nicer glassware would have added to the stay though. Overall we were very happy with this property.

Meaghan was a wonderful host who was very prompt, kind, and respectful of privacy. The house itself was stylish, comfortable, and modern while being kid friendly which is a tough thing to achieve in any home let alone an Airbnb. The view from the house was an absolute highlight! We had a great time!

My extended family (6 adults and 6 kids) had a wonderful stay! The house was gorgeous and in a perfect location for all of our activities!! We felt right at home and there was plenty of room for all of us. The view was simple amazing and we enjoyed walking around the neighborhood. We would recommend this house!