Family-friendly holiday rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

It was a perfect week! It was in a perfect location? Very comfortable and clean. It was everything we hoped for and more.

This cabin was absolutely beautiful, clean, and well maintained. It was the perfect spot for a family get together. We all had our own rooms, and there was plenty of space in the common areas to gather. What I loved was how many little "nooks" there were so one could curl up and relax while still feeling part of it all. The outside fire-pit was perfect and the game room was so much fun. Tracey was a wonderful host- answering questions promptly, and even accommodating a schedule change for us. We felt right at home. The area of Foxburg is beautiful. If you are looking for a peaceful place to stay- this is it! There is a lot to do in this area if you love nature. Hiking trails, biking paths, the Allegheny river, and so on. There are some cute restaurants right on the river to eat at as well. You will not be disappointed with this cabin or Foxburg. I highly recommend! Thank you Tracey!

Great place to relax & forget the big city life. I enjoyed sitting on the porch watching all the animals on the farm & seeing & hearing the Amish people on their horse & buggy’s.

Wow!!!! We had such a fantastic stay in this amazing and charming lakefront house. We will for sure be booking this spot again! Thank you for a wonderful stay!

We love it so much here we've already booked several stays for next year. Cindy's condo never disappoints, and has the perfect location for skiing.

This was our second stay and it didn’t disappoint. We thoroughly enjoyed our girls’ weekend getaway and the on location massages were the cherry on top. We will be back!

We had a wonderful stay at the "log cabin"!! The hot tub was a huge hit, we loved the big dining room table, and also appreciated the 2nd living space in the basement. If you're ever looking to stay in Hartville, this is a great home for large family gatherings.

Jesse’s place worked out well for our 12 Guy golf trip. The cabin has a nice layout and was clean. We cooked breakfast each morning and did steak on the grill one night and the kitchen and grilled worked out with no problems. The only negative comment I heard from a few of the guys was a lack of TV’s.

I wish I could give more than a 5 star review! if ever a place earned a 1,000 stars, this is it! It's the perfect balance of luxury and comfort. The decor is charming. the hosts were fabulous and attentive. The kitchen has every appliance and utensil you could desire. The view is great and there is so much to do on the grounds. We enjoyed pickleball a walking around the lake. We spent a lovely evening around a campfire made from the amply stocked wood pile. No attention to detail was spared and everything was impeccably clean. I have stayed at Air Bnbs all over the country and this one tops them all! I know this is a place I will be returning to over and over again.

We’ve stayed here for several years now for a family event. Bill is always welcoming and checks in regularly to see how things are going. The small fenced area is perfect for my dogs, and in addition there’s plenty of room on the property to walk them. The home is BEAUTIFUL, with plenty of space. There are multiple parks nearby with walking trails as well.

this was our second stay here and certainly not our last. Jessica is an awesome host with a magical cabin. This area is so peaceful and private. The cabin has everything you need to make it a home for your stay. The lake is amazing and we caught so many fish !! You will not regret this cozy cabin ❤️

A great place to stay! We enjoyed the space and found that we were never overcrowded with 9 people and a dog. The cottage was even more beautiful than the pictures show and the A/C was a great amenity! The host was amazing, welcoming and accommodating! It was so close to the little town with shops and restaurants! We will for sure be back! Totally worth the price!

Joann (Jo Jo) is a wonderful hoast. When I contacted her in the morning prior to making one of our several day trips, about the need of a grab handle for the bathroom she had it there later on that same day when we returned. This was our 4th vacation trip to the Ashtabula / Geneva on the lake area. We've stayed at different rentals every time. This is the first time that neighbors interacted with us and made us feel welcome. We've already book this place for the same time period next year. A gentleman that lives at the end of the drive invited us to come down and experience the sunset any time we wanted. The house was just the right size for myself the wife and our fur baby. There is a fantastic gas grill there and I used it twice to grill dinner, I plan to bring a griddle plate for next year so I can cook up some magic for the neighbor's. We are so looking forward to September 2025 and another 7 relaxing days at J Jo's beach house. You won't go wrong if you book this cottage.

My father and I stayed here for several weeks while my mother was being treated for a serious illness at a nearby hospital. It was a very difficult and uncertain time for our family. We immediately felt at home, relaxed and comfortable when we stepped into the house and apartment. It is spacious but felt very warm and cozy. The house has alot of charm and character with the inside wooden staircase leading upstairs and a beautiful large outside sitting porch. There are many windows and natural light in the apartment. We were able to witness the beautiful blooming of the magnolia flowering tree out our windows. The host was very flexible and accomodating to our fluid situation and responsive when we needed to extend our stay. The property manager Joe was very friendly and helpful. The apartment layout was perfect for our needs. We each had our own bedroom and bathroom on opposite sides of the apartment. The bathtub was very relaxing and the beds were comfortable. Would highly recommend.

Great home to spend the weekend in with friends and our families! So much land to explore and play baseball and kickball. We loved making mountain pies and s’mores in the fire pit and having nice clean beds for all of us! Joseph was very responsive to our needs and we all had a great time!

Very nice house! Perfect driveway and room for the boat. Quiet neighborhood. Well placed for fishing the lake.

pretty good

This place was amazing! The view is perfect, everything is exactly as pictured. The communication from the owner was quick and efficient every time. They had everything you could possibly need. Plenty of super soft towels and washcloths, comfy bed, everything we could need for the kitchen. The smart tv and the shower were wonderful. We had a relaxing getaway and would highly recommend this condo to anyone.

We stayed at Michael’s condo for 4 days. It was just as described on the website. It is a nice, older complex but the condo itself has had renovations. The complex is right on Lake Erie with a beach front. We were unable to use the beach due to weather but it is a lovely setting. Nice balcony with lake view. There is a convenience store & restaurant right across the street. There is a park just down the street. Geneva on the Lake strip is close by & we saw many using golf carts which are available for rental close by. The condo is well stocked, with extra linens. Kitchen looks well stocked though we didn’t cook. Everything was in working order. Comfortable bed & plenty of closet space. We would stay there again if in the area. Michael was very responsive to any inquiries. We had no problems at all while there.

this place was beautiful exactly as pictured. lots of room and right on the water. the view was amazing. Scott was very responsive. we had an issue with the microwave and he came right over. highly recommend

Our stay at Sun Retreats was great! The house was big and clean. The check in process was easy and the staff in the Welcome Center were kind and helpful. There was plenty of parking and we were close to everything we wanted to do!