Holiday rentals in Town of Pitcher

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Town of Pitcher

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favourite

This aerial view captures a lakefront property surrounded by lush greenery. The spacious home features a large deck overlooking the water, with easy access to the lake. A private dock is visible, offering direct lake access for recreational activities.

Home in Tully

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Luxury Lakehouse on the water!

An unforgettable stay awaits at this private lakefront property. The waterfront home has been beautifully remodeled with high-end finishes and equipped with modern appliances, providing the ideal combination of luxury and tranquility. Start your day with a coffee on the large back deck and finish it with a campfire overlooking the lake. Song Mountain - 3 min drive Song Lake - Steps from back door Vesper Hills Golf Club - 12 min drive Create Lasting Memories In Tully With Us & Learn More Below!

FamilyLocationIndoor spaces

Guest favourite

Chalet in Willet

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 167 reviews

Lakefront Retreat: Hike, Fish, Campfires, Kayaks

Welcome to Sunset Chalet — your private lakeside escape. Set on peaceful waterfront property, this cozy retreat is perfect for relaxing and enjoying nature. Swim in the private pond, kayak on the lake, explore trails, or unwind around the fire pit under the stars. Enjoy: • Lake access • Private swimming pond • 2 kayaks + canoe • Fire pit • Private setting Close to Greek Peak, Ithaca, waterfalls, hiking, and Finger Lakes wine trails. Reserve early — summer and peak weekends book quickly.

LocationValueView

Top guest favourite

A spacious living room features two comfortable gray sofas and a decorative coffee table, positioned around a large screen TV. Natural light filters in, enhancing the warm tones of the walls. A small side table with a lamp adds to the cozy ambiance.

Flat in Greene

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 222 reviews

New Downtown Greene Apartment *no cleaning fee!*

This spacious one bedroom apartment overlooks peaceful downtown Greene. A quaint little village known for its unique shops and chic restaurants. This apartment gives you 1000+ sqft of a home away from home, equipped with all the amenities: washer/dryer, full kitchen, living room, bedroom, & off-street parking. This beautifully designed, modern apartment is perfect for the business traveler or family staying for recreational purposes. One bedroom with a pullout couch & air mattress, sleeps 6.

ValueFamilyCleanliness

Superhost

Flat in Cincinnatus

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Cozy Apartment with Arcade & Games

Experience comfort, style, and fun in this beautifully renovated 2-bedroom apartment located in Cincinnatus, New York. Perfect for couples, families, or small groups, this cozy space blends modern living with shared, hotel-style entertainment amenities designed to make your stay relaxing, easy, and memorable. Whether you’re here to unwind, spend quality time together, or work remotely, this apartment offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere with unique features rarely found in a 2-bedroom stay.

FamilyConditionAccess

Guest favourite

A vibrant red dock extends into a calm lake, framed by trees displaying autumn foliage in shades of orange, yellow, and green. The scene captures a peaceful lakeside setting, enhancing the natural beauty of the surroundings.

Cottage in Smyrna

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Hidden LakeFront Retreat

A modern designed Cozy Cottage With a stunning mirror lake Surrounded by NYS lands! Cool off in the summer and snowmobile in the winter all the way to Canada! Hike all year round We provide two kayaks for use but no motor boating allowed. 100 acre lake! (Medium size is 10 to 100) No fishing license or fee required We also have two six person Rafts relax with family and friends! Make time for your weekend getaway! Get back to nature! Uncork Unwind and Unstress! An all season getaway!

ValueFamilyBeach

Top guest favourite

A charming historic house is displayed, featuring a light exterior with decorative trim. A sloped roof and front porch with steps lead to the entrance. Lush green shrubs line the base of the house, complemented by trees in the background, suggesting a peaceful residential setting.

Home in Cortland

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

Adorable 2-bedroom home

Adorable home built in 1890 and renovated in 2019. Easy on/off from I-81, centrally located in New York- making it a great location to stay while visiting multiple colleges in one trip. Including SUNY Cortland, TC3 (~15min), Syracuse University(~30 min), Cornell (~30 min) & Ithaca College (~40 min) *Walking distance to: SUNY Cortland Downtown/Mainstreet Cortland Starbucks Several amazing local restaurants & a grocery store. Great local ski options including Greek Peak and Labrador Mtn.

FamilyLocationLayout

Top guest favourite

A spacious dining area features a large wooden table surrounded by six black dining chairs. Exposed wooden beams and stylish light fixtures add character. A staircase is visible in the background, along with modern kitchen features and ample natural light from nearby windows.

Home in Smyrna

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

The Farmhouse - 15 Mins From Colgate

Perfect space for a large family or friend gathering. Minutes from Colgate University and a short drive to Cooperstown, the Hall of Fame, Dreams Park and All-Star Village! This fully updated 1830’s farmhouse is nestled between the village library and Methodist church. Sleeps 8 comfortably (3 queens, 2 twins) and can sleep additional guests on the futon and pull out couch. Includes 3 new bathrooms (2 upstairs, 1 downstairs) and a renovated kitchen! Your home, away from home.

ValueLocationKitchen

Top guest favourite

The exterior of a historic two-story home is visible, featuring a symmetrical façade with multiple large windows adorned with black shutters. A central main entrance is framed by an arched window above, and steps lead to the door. Lush greenery borders the walkway.

Home in Homer

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Historic home in downtown Homer

The whole family will be comfortable in this historic 6 bedroom, 4 bathroom home with large yard, parking on premises, one block from the Center for the Arts and downtown Homer, minutes from SUNY Cortland and centrally located between Syracuse and Ithaca. The home’s proximity to the Finger Lakes region, Greek Peak Mountain Resort & Song Mountain Resort makes it an ideal location. Experience history by staying in this home once known as Samson’s Temperance Tavern and Inn.

LocationFamilyBack garden

Guest favourite

A white farmhouse with classic black accents is set against a backdrop of lush green grass and trees. The two-story building features a welcoming front porch and large windows, while a distant church spire can be seen through the trees.

Farm stay in Cortland

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 186 reviews

1820's Quaint Rustic Farmhouse

Beautiful, spacious, two-bedroom private suite. The Farmhouse is located on 50 acres of farmland in our beautiful river valley. We are directly off the Cortland I-81 exit and are 30 minutes to Cornell, Ithaca and Syracuse. We are conveniently located near Greek Peak and other local ski areas. Great location for professors, parents, students, outdoor enthusiast and anyone exploring the Finger lakes! We hope you enjoy your stay and come back again.

LocationFamilyDecor

Guest favourite

The living room features large glass doors that open to a scenic view of the lake, allowing natural light to fill the space. A comfortable sofa and coffee table are arranged on a patterned area rug, while a television is positioned near the doors.

Cottage in Tully

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 393 reviews

Lakeside Cottage

Spend a relaxing visit lakeside in our rustic little cottage on beautiful Song Lake. Our quaint little two bedroom cabin comes with all the comforts of home. Enjoy swimming, kayaking, fishing, or just relaxing lakeside. Also great for skiing in the winter, with Song Mountain less than a mile away, and 2 other ski resorts nearby. Just off interstate 81 and a short drive to Syracuse, the Finger Lakes or Ithaca.

LocationValueOutdoor spaces

Top guest favourite

Farm stay in Town of Plymouth

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 191 reviews

Peaceful Horse Farm with Stunning Views

Experience unforgettable views of the quiet valley below while horses graze just outside your door. Enjoy watching deer, foxes and wood chucks pass by. You'll love the modern farmhouse feel that creates a cozy and comfortable atmosphere. Climate controlled in all rooms. For the horse lover on vacation boarding is available.

FamilyValueLayout

Top guest favourite

A softly lit bedroom features a spacious bed with neatly arranged white bedding and decorative pillows. A bedside table with a lamp and a small plant add a touch of warmth to the space. Neutral walls and wood flooring create a calming atmosphere.

Home in Norwich

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 117 reviews

Charming, Cozy & Comfy

Discover peace and comfort in this newly updated Cape-style home located on quiet street in Norwich, NY. The modern interior offers a stylish escape, with cozy living and sleeping spaces, a well-equipped kitchen, and updated bathrooms. Enjoy the convenience of high-speed Wi-Fi, a smart TV, and easy access to local attractions.

FamilyValueNearby