Cottage holiday rentals in Olcott

This was a phenomenal stay! The house was clean and well stocked (e.g. toilet paper, soap, dishes, etc.). The rooms were as posted in the photos, so there were no surprises! Vu was a very responsive and helpful host. When we had trouble with the hot tub, he came down right away and checked the water for us. As a suggestion for those visiting, if you are sensitive to pool chemicals, you should run the hot tub for one cycle before getting in. There were some spatulas that were unclean in the drawer, but this was not of big concern to us as it might have just been missed while cleaning. Location wise, it’s walkable to Crystal Beach and it has some cute shops along the way! Overall, we would definitely stay here again!

The place was incredibly accommodating for the group of 8 of us !! We had a great time hanging out in the backyard and between the kitchen and dining table with the open concept. The place was tidy, clean, and all the amenities were as advertised — would definitely stay again!

Mandy’s place and Sherkston Shores are amazing! Mandy was so responsive and made everything easy about our stay! The cottage is beautiful, steps from the beach, and has everything you’d ever need! We will be back!

One of our favorite Air BNBs!! The house was perfect for us and our two pups and the bed was super comfortable! There were snacks waiting for us when we arrived and we loved using the Fire-Pit for s’mores. The hot tub came in handy because it was abnormally chilly for our stay. We didn’t cook while there but there were plenty of supplies had we needed to. The neighborhood was very quiet and peaceful. Definitely would recommend this place!

Our stay was great! The house comfortably accommodated three families and a dog. The location was convenient - close enough to grocery stores and letchworth park. Thank you for having us!

We stayed at one of Lauren's place at Sherkston a few years ago, and it was such a great time that we knew we wanted to come back again. Same great experience, the kids had a blast. I was asking a ton of questions throughout the stay that even I annoyed myself with, but Laura was very prompt, patient and polite each time. Will come back again in the future!

Everything about our weekend at ART CAMP was perfect. The home is a peaceful lakeside haven that managed to feel both inspiring and relaxing—a rare combo. Franky and his family have clearly poured heart into the space. It's not just a house; it’s an experience. The environment was thoughtfully eclectic in all the best ways—every corner sparked conversation or curiosity, yet nothing felt out of place. From the whimsical art touches to the tranquil lake views and bubbling hot tub, everything was designed with intention. Our kids absolutely loved the loft—it was their own little adventure hideaway. They were thrilled to have a space that felt just for them, and it added a whole new layer of fun to the stay. The check-in was smooth, the location serene, with great vibes all around. If you're looking for a creative recharge or simply a beautiful, restful space for your crew (kids included!), ART CAMP is truly a gem.

What an amazing space! Everything was above and beyond our expectations. Was able to use washer and dryer and loved the hot tub. Perfect location for walking to the beach and shops. Local food was great and affordable. With only a 30 mins from Buffalo NY, will definitely be booking again!🩷

The Crystal Cottage is such an amazing place! Anne Marie and Norm are such wonderful hosts and go out of their way to make guests feel comfortable. The cottage is in a great location within walking distance to everything and is still very quiet an peaceful. The local people are also fantastic and make guests feel welcome. I highly recommend the Crystal Cottage to other guests and will be back for sure!

A great couple of days! From the phone call a couple of days, Jeff was proactive to ensure we had a wonderful stay. Very well situated - easy walk to restaurants and the beach as well as to access the Friendship Trail for biking. Comfortable beds too. Slept great. Thanks, Jeff!

I rented this for my mother’s 80th birthday. It was perfect for her and her husband. Lake views amazing, perfect size home and fully equipped with everything one would have at their own home! House was quaint, personable and a feeling of comfort and relaxation. Beautiful deck overlooking Lake Ontario, beautiful well maintained yard. The privacy was another great bonus!! Would rent this again. Instructions were on point! Everything was perfect!! Thank you for sharing your slice of heaven!!

I was looking for a last-minute getaway from Toronto with my dog Luna, and Robert was quick to respond and accommodate us. The Airbnb is the perfect cottage -- cozy, thoughtfully decorated, and equipped with everything we needed for a relaxing stay. Every detail made it feel warm and welcoming. We enjoyed peaceful walks on the beach and also discovered a lovely trail nearby for Luna to explore. When I accidentally locked myself out of the cottage, Robert was incredibly responsive and showed up within 10 minutes to let us back in. We’re already planning our next trip back — we highly recommend staying at Robert and Cole's!

The lake views from this quaint little cottage were breathtaking!! Cottage was very clean and ready for our arrival. Wonderful hosts, very accommodating. Shopping, ice cream and farm stands, wineries, restaurants, state parks and Niagara Falls all within a nice distance, not too far. We enjoyed our stay very much!

The location of this cottage is great! Despite the fact that it's right by the road, it feels very private. It's also very close to many wineries, shops and restaurants. We didn't have a car and biked every where and it was very convenient. Also it can easily fit 5 couples!

Always a pleasure staying at this beautiful lake house. Everything your looking for very clean,comfortable and peaceful. Can't wait until our next trip.

Nice cozy cottage.... Will go again...

The sunrise off the dock was amazing. Wendy was very helpful with local places to eat and making sure we had everything we needed before even getting there. 10 out of 10 would recommend. We will booking again next fall! Very close to Oak Orchard dam (went for a fishing trip)! Thank you for recommending Roadies food was awesome!

Roland's place was absolutely perfect. Such a great location and a short walk into town. The place was spotless with a really well stocked kitchen and plenty of soft, fresh towels. The beds were also extremely comfortable and Roland was very responsive. He even offered us an early check-in as the place was ready for us. Would definitely stay again!

So peaceful!!! We sat out on the deck every night and watched the sunset across Lake Ontario. So beautiful! We loved our stay and are already planning our next trip back. Thank you so much!

Amazing place to stay and a wonderful location. The hosts were friendly and supported us throughout our stay. A place to stay one more time in the future !

This place was even more beautiful than the pictures. Three levels of seating to enjoy the lake views. The beds were so comfortable unlike many places. The restaurant Garden Houzz just down the street is a close walk and a hidden gem! We had a rainy cold stay but we enjoyed an amazing time because of the views and amenities.

I had stayed at this resort before but through the resort. No plunger. Had to call and wait to get the toilet unclogged. No wifi as well. I paid more as well and the cottage was smaller in size. This cottage was spacious and had all the amenities. Never had to contact John except how to turn on the heat and hot water. I highly recommend this cottage

I had an absolutely wonderful stay thanks to Poulomi! The place was spotless, stylish, and exactly as described in the listing. Poulomi was incredibly responsive and went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect—quick replies, helpful local tips, and a warm welcome that made me feel right at home. The attention to detail and hospitality were top-notch. I’d highly recommend staying here and would love to come back again!

This was a nice place to stay. It was well decorated and furnished. The bed was very comfortable as was the couch. The river nearby was beautiful scenery and had a nice walking path right next to it. This is a great place to stay if you want to visit the area or Niagara Falls.