Holiday rentals with a fireplace in Madeline Island

Find and book unique fireplace rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated rentals with a fireplace in Madeline Island

Guests agree: these rentals with a fireplace are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favourite
The cabin's striking exterior features large cedar beams and expansive windows, blending seamlessly into the natural surroundings. A screened-in patio offers a view of the woods and lake, while a gas grill is positioned nearby for outdoor dining.
Cabin in Herbster
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 153 reviews

Cedar Ridge | Hand-Crafted Cabin with Lake Views

This newly built cabin will take your breath away. You’ll find the perfect blend of Northwoods rustic charm and creature comforts in this 3 bdrm cabin nestled in the woods overlooking Lake Superior’s Bark Bay. You’ll fall in love with all the care & attention its owners have put into every detail. From the stunning cedar beams that provide the backdrop to the incredible lake views to the hand-crafted interior woodwork and the beautiful kitchen, you will see how unique and special this cabin is.

Top guest favourite
Home in Herbster
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 411 reviews

Stunning Bark Point Home on Superior's South Shore

One of a kind, open/loft-concept (see pics: it really is open) artisan-crafted lake home on Superior's south shore: paddle in summer/ice hike in winter. Breathtaking sunsets. 300+ feet of private shoreline or short walk to public beach. Great kitchen. Up to 8 people and most dogs welcome - PET FEE: pets are an extra $25 (there is a place to leave this next to the house manual on the kitchen counter) Scenic huge patio with built-in fire pit (BYO firewood) We hope you love it as much as we do!

Top guest favourite
The cabin exterior features logs and a screened porch, offering shaded seating. A wooden deck wraps around, and steps lead up to the entrance. A propane grill is visible, and greenery surrounds the space, providing a secluded atmosphere.
Cabin in Bayfield
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 345 reviews

The Copper Squirrel of Little Sand Bay DogsWelcome

A mature forest and a beautiful pond are what you'll see when you arrive at this cozy, secluded, full log cabin. The cabin was recently completely renovated (Mar/April 2025)from log to log and is stocked with everything you'll need for your stay. It has all new appliances, furniture, fixtures, bathroom, cabinetry. 💚 It is the perfect homebase to relax after a long day of hiking Frog Bay, Houghton Falls, Lost Creek Falls, Meyers Beach, or shopping in nearby Bayfield, Washburn, or Cornucopia.

Guest favourite
A spacious kitchen is highlighted by wooden cabinetry and a striking brick wall. Countertops are topped with various kitchen appliances, including a coffee maker and utensils. Lighting is provided by overhead fixtures, and the room features a warm, inviting design with a view of the adjacent dining space.
Apartment in Two Harbors
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 178 reviews

The Fireside at Silver Creek B&B w/ SAUNA

The Fireside at Silver Creek, is a comfortable & inviting unit just outside the charming town of Two Harbors. One of three private units on our 11-acre property. 5 miles from Lake Superior, you’ll be close to some of Minnesota’s top outdoor attractions, including: Gooseberry Falls (13 min), Split Rock Lighthouse (20 min), Gitchi-Gami State Trail. Whether you're hiking, sightseeing, biking, or simply relaxing by the fire, The Fireside offers the ideal base for your North Shore adventure.

Top guest favourite
The modern cabin is nestled among tall trees, featuring a large screened porch that is partially framed by natural surroundings. Soft light filters through the foliage, creating a serene atmosphere. Lounge chairs are positioned near the porch, enhancing the inviting outdoor space.
Cottage in Bayfield
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Superior Sanctuary: Refined Rustic in the Woods

Escape to the tranquil shores of Lake Superior in our charming retreat! Nestled within the serene Brickyard Creek Community, this modern haven offers a perfect blend of rustic elegance and contemporary comforts.  Immerse yourself in nature's beauty, unwind on the spacious screened porch, and cozy up by the fireplace. Your peaceful escape awaits. • Screened Porch with Swing Chairs • Access to Beach and Hiking Trails • Smart TV & Streaming • Modern Kitchen  • Boat Slip Rental Available

Guest favourite
A studio space features a spacious bed and a queen sofa sleeper, accented by neutral-colored walls. Natural light enters through a nearby window, illuminating the cozy sitting area with its black couch. A small dining table and kitchenette are seen in the background.
Apartment in Bayfield
4.8 out of 5 average rating, 380 reviews

One Minute Walk to Lake Superior. Brookside #11

Amazing location! This Comfy Studio Condo sleeps 4, Whirlpool tub/shower,King bed & Queen sofa sleeper. Strong Wifi, balcony, AC, CableTV and fire pit wood provided. 1 minute walk to the marina. Bayfield is 2.3 mi from Brookside. Hike or bike the Brownstone trail along the lake. Take the ferry to Madeline, cruise the apostles, Sail, fish, kayak, golf, orchards, ski and more!! The pool and restraunt opens July 1st. 5 minutes from Bayview beach, Mt Ashwabay, Big top and Adventure Brewery.

Top guest favourite
A charming red cottage is nestled among tall trees, showcasing a welcoming front with two white Adirondack chairs placed on a natural surface. Decorative flower arrangements hang near the entrance, surrounded by lush greenery and plants.
Guest house in Ashland
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 395 reviews

Norrsken Scandinavian Cottage

The guest cottage is painted to resemble a Scandinavian retreat. Complete with separate bedroom, extra fold-out sofa queen bed, kitchenette, wood burning stove, WiFi (the best we can find but not great!!!) and large television (DirecTV), it is a great getaway for a couple or a family. Owners live on property if you need anything. If you are a bit adventurous, we can put up a tent right next to Lake Superior. The entire property is smoke free. For a quiet stay, no snowmobiles or ATVs.

Top guest favourite
The cottage exterior features a wooden entrance with a small deck, surrounded by a snowy landscape. Icicles hang from the eaves, and evergreen trees are visible nearby. Window boxes adorned with greenery add a touch of charm to the entrance.
Cottage in Cornucopia
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 150 reviews

Borealis Cottage by Siskiwit Bay

Borealis Cottage sits on a 2-acre, private, wooded lot in the sustainably designed Sawgrass Community of Cornucopia. Light-filled cottage with open floor plan includes a sleeping loft, screened porch, gas fireplace, and fully-equipped kitchen. A quick, quiet walk from the cottage takes you to a private wooded path with access to Cornucopia Beach on Siskiwit Bay. Explore the Apostle Islands National Lakeshore--our cottage is located 4 miles from Meyers Beach and 20 miles from Bayfield.

Guest favourite
A rustic A-frame cabin is nestled among tall evergreen and birch trees, with fresh snow covering the landscape. The entrance features two large windows framed by wood and two doors. A wooden deck extends towards the tranquil woodland, creating an inviting outdoor space.
Cabin in Herbster
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 231 reviews

South Shore A-Frame: Steps from Lake Superior

A peaceful, feel good place. Renovated rustic modern Aframe off Lake Superior's scenic south shore. Surrounded by evergreen and birch trees in an idyllic woodland setting. Enjoy walks to the beach, breathtaking sunsets and beach bonfires, kayaking the famous seacaves, biking, hiking to waterfalls, shopping for vintage treasures or just relaxing/stargazing in the beautiful private backyard. A perfect home base for exploring the Apostle islands, Bayfield and Madeline Island.

Top guest favourite
The modern home is surrounded by lush greenery, with large windows reflecting the evening light. A staircase with railings leads to the entrance, enhancing accessibility. A circular window adds a unique architectural feature, while soft lights illuminate the exterior, creating a serene nighttime ambiance.
Cabin in Herbster
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 150 reviews

Superior Sunsets @ The West Slope (Steam Shower)

Our 3 bedroom, 2 bath home is located 1 mile out of Cornucopia and 20 miles from Bayfield. Nestled in a lush forest on a sandstone cliff overlooking Lake Superior, this home is a new build featuring a STEAM SHOWER , a fully equipped kitchen and cozy gas fireplace . Deck with grill and stunning sunset views. Large entertainment room w/ 65" Smart T.V. , POOL TABLE & DART BOARD. Outdoor firepit and picnic table. WE PRACTICE ENHANCED SANITIZING MEASURES WITH EVERY TURNOVER.

Superhost
A private outdoor patio is presented with a glass dining table surrounded by four chairs. Colorful flower pots with blooming plants add vibrancy to the space, complemented by natural stone and greenery. Steps lead up to the entrance of the home.
Farm stay in La Pointe
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Hippophile Farm Get-a-way Garden Apartment

The space is a newly renovated apartment on the lower level of our home which is located at our private horse farm on Madeline Island. It is light, bright, with a modern and clean look. It has all the things you need to relax and rejuvenate after spending a day exploring Madeline Island. Enjoy the beautiful woods surrounding the apartment or take a walk to our beautiful stables on the property. Bring your horses if you wish, or just come to enjoy the scenery.

Superhost
A rustic red yurt is surrounded by a forest of trees. A large wooden deck offers a welcoming entrance and is equipped with a sturdy railing. Natural ground covers and underbrush can be seen nearby, creating a serene and natural setting.
Yurt in Bayfield
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 375 reviews

Bayfield Rustic Yurt 2 (Terra Cotta)

Nestled in the middle of the Bayfield County Forest, this rustic, minimally maintained yurt has direct access to miles of non-motorized rec trails (mountain bike, cross-country ski and hiking). Enjoy panoramic views of Lake Superior including; Pike's Bay, four of the Apostle Islands (Madeline, Basswood, Stockton and Michigan) and the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. Come prepared to relax, unwind and explore the wonders of the north woods.

Popular amenities for rentals with a fireplace in Madeline Island