Holiday rentals in Greencastle

Great place, very clean and new, near several restaurants and beaches. Melisa was a great host, kept us informed and replied promptly. Very cute and peaceful place.

The pictures don't do justice to this home (light and beautiful) and its surroundings (paradise). There should be one of the view from the deck directly down to the ocean! :) Architecture is stunning. Full on views of the beach and tropical vegetation from every side. Two different work spaces with desks and views out the back. Kitchen is a little small if you're having a big group, but for two it was terrific. Everything worked. Fans in all the rooms! Great shower with fabulous water pressure. Loved the simplicity of the decor and having the beach to ourselves. BE SURE TO READ THE INSTRUCTIONS (and maybe print them at home). VERY useful information. Contact Latoya for practical questions. She was able to get us a rental car when other companies said they had no vehicles left. Do get a 4WD. The high chassis is important for rutted roads if you go anywhere off the beaten track. We didn't plan to, but it happens! :)

We really enjoyed our stay at Baha Mara. It was everything we had hoped for and more. The house itself is spacious and light-filled, well appointed and equipped, with lovely art and nice touches throughout. Comfortable beds and living room space, great kitchen for cooking, large porch for sitting out. We spent a lot of time relaxing on the day beds at water's edge, as well as exploring the tide line and in the water on the SUPs and with snorkels. This was our first visit to Eleuthera, and we found Baha Mara to be perfectly located to venture out to various villages, beaches, restaurants and grocery options not too far from the house. We discovered on our first day that the closest eastside beach, Islandia, is closed to the public pending a sale of the surrounding 466+ acres (!), so we explored a handful of the myriad sandy stretches up and down the coast. We only wished that we had more days to spend and that we had booked a day out on the boat with John/Big Mac Fishing. Next time!

Amazing stay! Tropical Paradise exceeded our expectations. We were looking for a place to relax and recharge from the hectic schedules of life over the holidays and this stay was exactly what we had in mind. The house is about an hour drive from the airport/large grocery store. The liquor store was closed. When we return we would probably plan our food better and hire someone to shop/cook for us. Over Christmas many places were closed. Once you arrive you truly are in paradise. The location of this home is absolute PERFECTION! Steps away from the most beautiful, private, clear water, tranquil beach! We loved walking the beach each day, snorkeling right in front of the house and kayaking. Sherri and Alan have thought of everything and the house is well appointed. We ate at Shana’s Cove a few times and found that experience lovely and the food great! The noseeums were the only negative! They are especially bad at sunset. We all got bites despite our efforts. We can’t wait to return🏝️❤

Wonderful stay in a calming environment! Eldecia, was a very responsive host!

Our stay at Shutter Box was definitely worth it! The place looks just like the photos and is extremely clean and welcoming. All of the appliances work very well and the bed is extremely comfortable. We were also impressed with small details like the quality of linens and towels. Anke and Alex were very accommodating to personal requests and always answered in a timely fashion. I highly recommend staying here.

Martin, Carlien, and their family made us feel right at home. We enjoyed the spectacular kite surfing, resident sea turtles, boat rocking us to sleep, grilling the fisherman’s barracuda catch over the campfire, and even kayaked for the first time using their glass-bottomed kayaks going through the magical mangroves! It’s definitely the unique experience we’re glad we chose to celebrate our 39th anniversary!

This property is perfectly situated right in the middle of the island making commuting easy from GHB. It's waterfront. I was able to snorkel right from the property beach. Clean, comfortable, spacious. There is a full working kitchen if wish to cook meals while staying here. Everything great for a couple or a small family. We loved staying here and would absolutely book again. Great property.