Cottage holiday rentals in Eagle Lake

The Lakehouse-3bdr/Lakefront/Wi-Fi

Enjoy your stay at this cozy cottage just steps away from beautiful Cross Lake. This 3bdr, 1bath house features a 4 seasons porch so you can relax and unwind all year. Our large yard provides you additional space to enjoy the stunning view. From the first weekend of May-Sept 30th, you will also have access to our shared pier. Enjoy swimming, boating, fishing or other nearby activities: skiing, golfing and ziplining. Beach chairs/toys, fire pit, grill, games and folding chairs are also provided.

NEW! Boutique Stay – Walk to Lake, Cafes & Shops!

Nestled in the heart of Lake Geneva's historic Maple Park, this chic and charming cottage offers the perfect setting for making memories. Relax on the porch, stroll to nearby coffee shops, restaurants, boutiques, the beach, or simply stay in to soak up the cottage charm. Thoughtfully restored and designed with timeless character, it’s the perfect setting for gathering with friends and family to make memories that last a lifetime. This retreat captures the spirit of classic Lake Geneva living.

Cozy cottage in the heart of Lake Country

Entire cottage in the heart of Lake Country. Merryhill Cottage is nestled on two acres with mature trees. Included on the two acres- the host's farmhouse, a guest house and barn. The feeling of a country setting but with easy access to Hwys 16, 83 and I 94. Close to shopping, restaurants, parks, hiking, cross country skiing and snowshoeing, lakes, and beaches (10 min. to Delafield and Oconomowoc and 15 min. to Pewaukee.) Perfect for day trips to Madison (54 min.) and Milwaukee (30 min.).

The Butterfly Cottage

Your summer get-away is perfect at The Butterfly Cottage on Honey Lake! Relax and enjoy the serenity of the lake and all the natural beauty of the season! This is a cozy cottage on Honey Lake, just 4 miles from downtown Burlington and 13 miles from Lake Geneva. Alpine Valley for concerts, fishing on Honey Lake or nearby Browns Lake as well as shopping in Lake Geneva are the highlights of the season! There are hiking/walking trails all around as well as rustic roads to explore.

Close to Town + Beach • Historic Pemberley Cottage

Built in 1890 and lovingly updated in 2021, Pemberley Cottage embodies the history, charm, and character of Lake Geneva. Just a 15-minute walk or 2-minute drive to everything our town has to offer, including downtown shops and restaurants, nightlife, Geneva Lake and its beaches, boat and scooter rentals, and more! Skip the weekend traffic with easy access to and from the highways. We love our small town and take great pride in delivering the very best experience for our guests!

The Cozy Lake House/Perfect Lake Front Getaway!

Welcome to The Cozy Lake House, your year-round haven for relaxation and celebration! Savor breathtaking sunsets, indulge in boating, watersports, and high-speed internet, and make special memories during holidays, bachelorette party's getaways, birthdays, family reunions, micro weddings, and more. With a fully equipped kitchen, spacious rooms, and the tranquil lakeside setting, every moment here is magical. Reserve your spot now and experience the ultimate in lakeside living!

Peaceful, serene cottage near Lake Geneva

Welcome to Serenity. Not your typical lake cabin, Serenity has a Mid Century flair in a wooded, quiet and peaceful setting just minutes from the beach and boat launch on Williams Bay. Enjoy morning coffee in the large dining room as our neighborhood turkeys wander through the yard. There is an outdoor dining set with charcoal grill, and a gas fire pit to warm you up on cool nights, and an additional family room in the loft to play games or relax in front of the TV.

The Peacock Cottage

Cozy, quiet, accessible Lake Geneva home with large open living area, vaulted ceilings, large 1-acre wooded lot. 3 minutes from beach, 5 minutes to both Lake Geneva and Williams Bay, 2 minutes to a local Wisconsin-style convenience store. Welcome to the Peacock Cottage! Located on a deep, private lot surrounded by woods, so it's great to let loose without any nearby traffic. We are super into cozy homes, and love creating spaces that are restful and fun.

#4: Cute 2 bedroom cottage on the beach!

Come relax at Turtle Beach Marina! Rent a Pontoon or a Kayak. Spend the day at the beach and at the beach bar (Beach bar is open mid May until the first weekend in October). There is a restaurant and gaming room (slots) on the property. Quaint cottage has 2 bedrooms with a full bed in each. Up to 4 people allowed. There is no oven but has a 2 burner electric cook top. A grill is also available. Beach themed cottage is completely remodeled. 💜