Holiday rentals in Cupids Cay

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 122 reviews

Cayo Loco Beachfront Villa Deserted PinkSand for 2

S2E2 NETFLIX "WORLD'S MOST AMAZING VACATION RENTALS"! Beachfront villa right on deserted secluded pink sand beach! Watch dolphins with your coffee/coconut water/tarts! Beach toys included! Eleuthera means 'freedom'! Tranquil authentic tropical island paradise fusing eco design w/comfort! 1 of 2 brightly colored villas! Beach stroll to dining/bar/pool! Fish/surf/boat/dive/kayak/paddle board/relax! Unspoiled pristine oasis! 1 bed 1-1/2 bath 2 ADULTS ONLY! NO SMOKING/KIDS/LOUD MUSIC/VISITORS/FIRES!

Guest house in Governor's Harbour

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 40 reviews

Casa Dogo

Casa Dogo is a simple 1bedroom cottage with a living room and open kitchen area and a screened patio. It’s an efficiency right here at my property with a separate entrance. I live here with my 6 Potcakes on the same property. If you love dogs and you are this kind of person who always misses their of when traveling then you are right here at Casa Frida. You need a rental car in Eleuthera to get around and enjoy all the beautiful, wide, peaceful beaches. As I say this is ONLY for true DOGLOVERS.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 160 reviews

Cottage in Rainbow Bay

Villa Soreli - 1 B/R Oceanfront w/Pool

Villa Soreli, a brand new bespoke Ocean Front Luxury Villa rental in Rainbow Bay, Eleuthera Bahamas (NOT NASSAU). This 1 B/R private villa includes a Queen-sized Master bedroom with an additional King-size Sleeper Sofa to accommodate a family of 4. Our villa is fully equipped with a full kitchen, indoor & outdoor shower, high end finishes & a plunge pool overlooking the Caribbean Sea. It is walking distance to Rainbow Bay Beach. Nestled in between the Caribbean Sea and the Atlantic Ocean.

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Cottage in Hatchet Bay

Extraordinary Oceanfront Peninsula. Walk to Beach.

*Low cleaning fee. No other host fees. No taxes. *Superhosts since 2016. Over 1000 reviews on Airbnb - 4.95 star average. *Discount SUV rental and adventure tours such as the swimming pigs. *3 minute walk to beaches, bars, restaurants, great central location. *Superb snorkeling and fishing right at our property. *Incredible oceans views of the Caribbean on all sides. *Unique 3 sided peninsula allows for both sunrises and sunsets. *Eagle Rays swim by the deck every day as part of their routine.

5 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Tropical Solar bungalow with great snorkeling !

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. Private bungalow. Solar powered. The bungalow also has Satellite high speed internet A Bahamian laid back vibe styled bungalow on our hillside property with gardens. Breathtaking Carib sea views and sunsets. Swimming and snorkeling is a brief walk down the hill to the sea. The Atlantic Ocean and pink sand beaches are a 10 minute walk. We are located in the center of Eleuthera and the Settlement of Governors Harbour is a 10 minute drive.

Home in Central Eleuthera

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Heart & Soul, Ocean View, Private Pool & Gardens

Heart & Soul - Ocean View House, Private Pool, and Lush Botanical Garden Refresh your Heart & Soul! A private home located just north of Governor’s Harbour on the island of Eleuthera, the Heart and Soul House is your private escape to paradise. This Island retreat is located on top of a hill catching cool breezes and providing a generous views of the water. The Property boasts a sprawling garden, a private pool, covered porch, and views of the Atlantic & Caribbean.

5 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Ocean Front Home, Banks Road, Governor’s Harbour

A beautiful ocean front cottage overlooking secluded cove on Old Banks Road in Governor’s Harbour between Pascal’s and Twin Cove Beach. It is perfect for anyone seeking a peaceful getaway. New kitchen and all modern amenities - generator, AC, Starlink WIFI, 4K smart TV, AppleTV, propane gas BBQ, fully-equipped kitchen with new appliances including dishwasher, Alexa, two new decks overlooking the ocean and elegant styling. The cove is a snorkeler’s paradise.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Contemporary Upstairs 2BR 2BA Bayfront Apartment

Welcome to The Governor's Harbour Collection - Anchor Point Apartments; an affordable, condo-style development located in the heart of Governor's Harbour, Eleuthera. The complex is comprised of two buildings: One contains 2 one-bedroom apartments and two standard two-bedroom apartments, while the other contains 2 larger, two-bedroom apartment suites. All units are built with covered, outside balconies that offer fantastic views of Anchor Bay.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Cottage in Gregory Town

“ShoreTing” oceanfront, secret beach

Featured on Magnolia Network, HGTV and Dwell Magazine, it is boho beach bliss at this modern and unique beachfront property located on a secret beach. The quaint Gregory Town is 2 miles to the North. All photos here taken at our property/beach. Built in the spirit of a modern surf safari outpost, this sophisticated yet understated property captures the true essence of adventure. Recent photo shoots include JCREW, ALO, and TOMMY BAHAMA.

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

Casuarina Bay sunset apartment

Dolphin Doon’s enchanting sunset apartment is just steps from the very private sandy beach of Casuarina bay. Charmingly decorated with island furnishings and full of natural light, this studio is perfect for 2 guests. This bright and airy new space (completed November 2019) features a large sleeping area with queen bed and five picture windows facing west to capture the beautiful Bahamian sunsets.

Holiday home in Gregory Town

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 97 reviews

Skylarking waterfront cottage

Skylarking cottage is at the end of a rolling stone path that takes you through the tropical hardwood forest. Quiet and secluded, with floor to ceiling aqua blue water views. Complete with spacious deck, hardwood floors and a stone and wood outdoor shower. Explore the coastline on gin clear water with the paddle board or kayak - you are immersed in the natural beauty of The Bahamas.

Loft in Governor's Harbour

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

"PINK LOFT", Governor's Harbour

Pink Loft is located on beautiful Governor's Harbour Bay overlooking Cupid's Cay. On the upper floor of a recently renovated building, the loft has a fully equipped kitchen, spacious bathroom and is beautifully furnished in lively tropical colors and crisp new furniture. Beaches, shops and restaurants are within walking distance, and the sunsets from the balcony are spectacular.

Holiday rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodation and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Cupids Cay holiday rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great holiday rentals in Cupids Cay

Cottage in North Palmetto Point

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Cottage on private pink sand beachfront property

KevinRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Amazing stay, peaceful and beautiful surroundings. Alexander is a fantastic host always willing to help and make the stay even better.

5 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Spacious 2BR 2BA Upstairs Designer Apartment Suite

LyndahRating, 5 stars4 weeks ago

This is our second stay here in four weeks. It was extremely comfortable for our work team, and Dom was very considerate of check-in and check-out times. Everything you need for a perfect stay is available, including sunscreen, beach umbrellas and chairs. We'll be back.

Cottage in Governor's Harbour

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

Classic Bahamas cottage / 60 second walk to ocean.

EmilyRating, 5 stars1 month ago

This little cottage is a gem! Perfect location at the center of Eleuthera but also offers seclusion. Eleuthera vibes is the perfect getaway! We really enjoyed staying and will be back again!

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Welcome to Outer Reef, a slice of heaven on Earth.

lydiaRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Our stay in Eleuthera was absolutely incredible, and this Airbnb made it all the more special. The hosts truly thought of everything — from the little touches that made it feel like home to the thoughtful details that made our beach vacation effortless and family-friendly. The space was spotless, beautifully designed, and had everything we needed to relax and enjoy our time together. It’s rare to find a place that balances comfort and style so well, especially one that works so seamlessly for families. We loved how close it was to the beach and how easy it was to settle in and just be. And the view at night? Unbelievable. Easily the most stunning nighttime view I’ve ever seen — peaceful, starlit skies over the ocean that felt like something out of a dream. We left with full hearts and beautiful memories. If you’re thinking about booking — do it. This place is a gem, and we can’t wait to come back.

5 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Upstairs 1BR Bayfront Apartment w/ ALL Amenities!

ScottRating, 5 stars1 month ago

We stayed here for 5 nights and it was a great location to base ourselves for exploring the island. The apartment itself is lovely and comfortable with a great view. Joy and Dom were both really helpful and responsive and gave us a lot of info on things to do/places to go on the island. Check-in was very easy. Would stay here again for sure 😊

5 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

Home in Upper Bogue

Tranquil private oceanfront retreat

NatalieRating, 5 stars2 months ago

We absolutely loved our stay at On The Rocks for our family vacation with a 1 year old. The house is decorated beautifully and was super clean with fresh bedding. If you're looking for a place to truly unplug, this is the place. The view is stunning and the local beach is a short walk away. We couldn't believe we got an entire beach to ourselves! The house was well stocked and had everything we needed, which made it easy to pack light. It is definitely remote – which is a amazing if you're looking for peace and quiet, but might not be for you if you're looking for something close to hustle and bustle of a town. The road in from the highway took about 10 minutes to get to the house. There are a handful of restaurants under a 20 minute drive and we enjoyed meals at El Karaka, Big Daddy's, and The Cove. We also did day trips to Harbour Island and French Leave beach (would recommend Tippy's as a place to spend an afternoon). We'd highly recommend On the Rocks or Due South!

Cottage in Governor's Harbour

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

"Settle Down" Cupid's Cay Cottage

MichaelRating, 5 stars15 months ago

Wonderful house in a local neighborhood. The home is incredibly well designed, furnished and supplied. We only needed to purchase water & food, everything else was there, including plenty of toilet paper! ☺️ As others have noted here in their reviews, the home is located in a very local neighborhood in a fairly industrial part of town (boat cargo docks). Expect to meet your neighbors and become part of the hood. Being a long time visitor of Eleuthera, we knew what to expect, as interaction with the locals is one of our favorite parts of Eleuthera and what makes it different from other islands. That said, you can expect noisier evenings in this neighborhood, especially on the weekends. During the week, it’s really not all that bad, but we did have an incredibly loud evening on our last night (Friday night) with loud music until around 3-4am. Ronnie’s bar/club is only about 100’ away, and the DJ played loud thumping music, along with his voice over the microphone, until past 3am.