Holiday rentals with a fireplace in Caledonia

We had the pleasure of staying here over our anniversary weekend with our 2 kiddos; it was our first vacation just our little family and it's was fantastic. Cristle was so helpful and went above and beyond to help us out when we had some issues on our end leading up to our trip. She was very thoughtful and kind and that alone was worth the 5 star rating. The home was very well kept and clean and had everything we needed for a nice relaxing weekend. We had a lot of fun out on the paddle boat and playing in the yard. The screened in porch was also a nice bonus. Our girls enjoyed the park and playing the sand. Overall it was a very nice stay and we'd love to go back sometime soon.

We had a truly wonderful stay for our women's retreat! The home was perfect—clean, cozy, and beautifully set up for a relaxing time together. We especially loved the spacious kitchen where we could cook and share meals—it felt just like home. The living room was warm and inviting, perfect for late-night chats and laughter. We also enjoyed being just a short walk away from the lake beach, which added a peaceful and refreshing touch to our time. Our host was incredibly kind and thoughtful, making sure we had everything we needed. We couldn’t have asked for a better place for our special night together. Highly recommended!

Stayed at this house for a work trip. It was so nice to have a quiet spot for me and my crew to crash after long days. Beautiful yard, and the raccoon family living in the tree in the backyard was fun to watch at night.

The space was well equipped and as advertised. We appreciate the accomodations that were provided for a weekend in the area. If you are looking for a comfortable, convenient space to stay, definitely consider Joe's rental.

Jean‘s House is charming—it was very clean and comfortable. Woodwork was beautiful and so many of the original features of the home have been kept in excellent condition or renovated to make it a great mixture of a vintage aesthetic with the modern comforts. You cannot do without a car if staying here. But if you have a car it’s a convenient base for doing things in Milwaukee. Great list of recommendations (At Random is a great little cocktail venue).

We had a great stay at Lexi’s place. The view is great and the house had everything we needed to make ourselves at home for the week. We would definitely stay here again when we are in the area.

This was a GREAT AirBnB. The home was so spacious, comfortable, free of clutter, and homey. Also very quiet. Appreciated the lighting indoors and outdoors, with some motion sensors. Have experienced homes with inadequate lighting in the past, so this was something we really noticed. This feature added a lot to our stay. The kitchen and coffee station was well stocked and very clean. The yard was perfect and well kept. Also glad to have plenty of trash cans inside and out. Something we don't always see at other homes. Had a wonderful stay. Will certainly try and stay here again when we are in the area. One of our top 3 AirBnB's we have stayed in the past 10 years as we travel across the country. Thank you. Claire

Dorothy’s Place was the perfect place for my stay! The home was very clean and well stocked with all the necessities. The property is well maintained. The backyard and deck is so beautiful and peaceful! The perfect place to enjoy your morning cup of coffee! The house rules and instructions are simple and clear. Kathy and Tom do a wonderful job with this property and I would highly recommend staying at Dorothy’s Place!

Thank goodness for places like this! Spotless, comfortable, just the right amount of amenities. Garage parking! Food & drink options within walking distance.

Julie’s place was quiet and peaceful for a quick getaway to Port Washington! She was very friendly and kind to my dog, and made me feel right at home as a solo traveler. Would recommend to anyone visiting the area who prefers to be away from the hustle and bustle of a big city.

Clean residence in a nice neighborhood. Very walkable to a lot of amenities. Close to eating and university hospital. Missing a few amenities that I’ve come to expect such as soap and shampoo, ice cube trays, tea and coffee. Overall a very nice place.

Fantastic stay at Mark’s place. Perfect for our long weekend and great food options steps away. No issues at all with check in or check out. Would definitely recommend!

Would definitely return to the property!

We enjoyed our stay at Benjamin’s place. The neighborhood was in a good location for what we were doing. We happened to run into a handful of garage sales in the area, which was lovely. Beds were comfy and the house was clean and easy to find. Over happy with our stay!

Sheila place was perfect for our trip in Milwaukee. It was super close to the church we was attending, and close to downtown to take the kids out for a walk. Sheila is an outstanding host and went beyond to help our needs. She welcomed my kids with some fun snacks and surprise them with morning treats. I also requested a highchair for my baby and she had it ready for me when we arrived. I highly recommend her place. Thank you Mrs. Sheila!!!

Owners were amazing and responsive. Place was beautiful and peaceful. It is above a bar but guests were friendly and respectful. Lots of amenities. Will definitely be back

Truly a gem near Lake Geneva. Plamena’s place was very clean, comfortable and had everything we needed to host our families. It was our first time vacationing again after having babies earlier this year and our toddler had a blast. She won’t stop talking about “her toys” at the airbnb. Plamena’s place is also a 5 minute drive to downtown Lake Geneva which was very convenient. Our overall experience was great, Plamena is an amazing host and we look forward to staying with her again in the near future.

Picture Perfect! Thank you for sharing your beautiful home with our family ~ we truly enjoyed our time together on the lawn & private beach! The house was comfortable and well equipped with all the amenities imaginable! DeepGratitude 🙏

Beautiful property! Phenomenally maintained and super clean! Kitchen and home were so well stocked! Great home!

Had a great stay! House was clean and cozy indoor pool was amazing. (Pool is about 12 feet deep.) Had a bunch of games we could play great outdoor area. Would recommend.

Clean, great communication, and easy check in!

What a lovely and hospitable place! We loved our time there. The level of comfort was unmatched. We would happily return. Truly a wonderful experience!

A group of us stayed at this home while in the area for a bowling tournament. We felt very welcome and were able to be comfortable during our stay. We enjoyed all the amenities including the pool, hot tub, and grill. The location was great for if you wanted to go for morning walks and sit out and enjoy the birds, but convenient for trips to the store or any random outings we wanted to do. We all absolutely loved the house and had a great time.