Beachfront holiday rentals in Big Hickory Island

This is such a great, peaceful place to stay on Estero island! Valerie Jean’s spot was immaculately clean, easy to find, and had so much to offer. Definitely recommend for singles or couples looking for extensive pool time. The beach across the street was calm and had lots of great shells as well! While bars and restaurants are limited in the area right now, there were still some local gems worth checking out, as well as a good number of places delivering. Definitely appreciated having a Publix close by and a great kitchen in the apartment! Would absolutely return for another peaceful stay and the awesome pool area!!

We loved our stay. The location is great. Close enough if you want to get to the bustle of the main”beach” area but further south if you want to easily walk to a quiet gorgeous beach. The beach is walkable. .4 miles as listed. There is a beautiful lagoon behind with many dolphins playing in it during our stay. We also took out kayaks and they swam right by our boat! Publix is 1.2 miles away so very convenient. A few good restaurants very close by. Comfortable beds. Kitchen could be a bit more stocked. Overall excellent stay.

This airbnb was so much more than we wanted. It was beautiful and comfortable. The Airbnb provided chairs, beach umbrellas, and a little car that we could take it to the beach with a cooler. It was perfect, minutes away from great restaurants. Italian, lots of sea food. Ac unit was new and would cool super fast we felt right at home here. If you are looking for a beach getaway in a beautiful beach that's like paradise I recommend this Airbnb.

Nice clean spot located close to the beach (3 minute walk with little kids). Marina was friendly and accomodating. Good setup, especially for families with kids. We enjoyed our stay and would love to book here again for future Fort Myers trips!

Andy's place was perfection for our girls weekend! We couldn't have asked for a better accommodation. Pool was amazing and the private beach an incredible added bonus. Bedrooms were perfect and very comfortable. Wifi worked great and appreciated the Netflix! Everything was perfect and Andy was awesome. Very kind and responsive throughout our stay. 10/10 would stay again! Thank you, Andy!

This unit is wonderfully located, with a beautiful view of the shore. We usually prepare our b-fast & lunch in, then dinner out. The kitchen was very well equipped. It was great to have all the extras for the beach, chairs, cooler, toys, and umbrellas. We are grateful for a host with perfect communication skills, Thank you for that.

This is an absolutely beautiful house in a gorgeous location. My boys spent the entire day fishing on the dock while we relaxed in the pool. Brianna was extremely communicative and any concerns we had she addressed immediately. We would love to stay here again.

So easy to book with & communicate with. We had a wonderful staycation

There were 8 of us for our annual family vacation. (ages from 70 to 16) This home was excellant with plenty of space for all to enjoy. This home was spacious with 5 bedrooms and bonus spaces where you could enjoy get away from the group if needed some private time. Very well decorated, comfortable furniture, tropical landscaping with great views of bay. Located on dead end street and walking distance to beach. The screened in pool/hot tub was enjoyed by all.

The place was perfect for what we needed. We went with my toddlers, a 9 month baby, and my grandmother, and this place was so ADA friendly, had all the items you needed for our baby, and felt safe for our toddlers. The building is still in facade improvements after the hurricane (we went end of May 2025), and the island overall is in reconstruction mode, but the beach was direct access, beautiful sunsets, and just what we needed so a small weekend break.

This apartment was lovely and spotless. My family and I had a wonderful and relaxing time. The condo is very private and quiet. The beach is very close even though we got rough seas but weather was nice. Highly recommend this place.

Literally steps from Vanderbilt Beach and Delmore Wiggins State Park. The studio condo was clean and just as described here n the listing. David is a responsive host. I'm from out of state and decided not to rent a car. Just be advised that you'll need to use Ubers to get to shopping and restaurants a couple miles away. Wonderful first visit to Naples.

Home & amenities were wonderful! Loved the central location & all of the wonderful beach chairs wagon etc in the garage. The Aveda product in the bathrooms was so nice! Ayleen was super responsive whenever we had a question We will be back for sure! :)

If you are considering Island Too for your next vacation, don’t hesitate and book it! The place is gorgeous with such attention to detail. The views of the Gulf were absolutely breath taking. We loved spending our evening on the balcony couch watching the sunset. The building itself is located on the south side of Fort Meyers beach which is great because it’s quiet yet just a short bike ride or car ride to more of the action. We used the building bikes every morning and enjoyed stopping at the MoJoe’s food truck for coffee and breakfast. Overall, it was a wonderful time and we would definitely love to come back and stay here again!

We loved our stay! the photos of the listing don't do justice to how nice the area is, extremely well maintained, great pool, very short walk to beach, and all the conveniences that the condo provided. The views from the condo were breathtaking. We love Naples but had never been at Naples Cay but now it is our favorite place to stay. The beds were very comfortable! We had everything that we could ask for in terms of kitchen appliances, etc. The oven and the stove were great. Our 1 year old slept great in the bassinet provided, and the 4 year old loved the books and beach toys. Looking forward to coming back 😀

What a wonderful place!!! It was absolutely perfect for our family of 6. Had all the things we needed/wanted and more! Great location and beautiful view of the ocean. Easy walk to get to a nice beach. The beds were all SO comfortable. Kelly had a variety of sand toys for the kids, beach chairs/umbrella, and a variety of floaties. She was also quick to respond and SO helpful with the questions I had. Highly recommend staying at her place! Thank you Kelly for sharing your home!

This place was absolutely amazing! We stayed for 3 nights and couldn’t have been happier. Walkable distance to town square and just minutes from the beach. The pool was great to hang out in and had plenty of chairs to lay out in the sun. I would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a place to stay in Fort Myers Beach.

John’s place is the epitome of a perfect beach vacation home. I could rant on forever but you really just need to check it out for yourself, I wish we could keep it a secret but it would serve no justice to John and all the work he’s put into making this the perfect rental!

Beautiful condo, very clean and had everything we needed the week we stayed. The view from the lanai is beautiful, sailboats going by during the day and gorgeous sunsets at night. The location is perfect, close to great shopping and restaurants. We went for walks on the beautiful beach and neighborhood daily. We look forward to returning.

I would definitely recommend this place! Home was great and the pool was amazing!! We will definitely be back. Location was near restaurants and stores. Absolutely loved this place.

This condo was perfect for our getaway to Southwest Florida. Excellent host and very friendly! We will be certain to visit again!

Katlyn was a great host and the condo was perfect for our family vacation. We love Sanibel and the location near the lighthouse is the best you can ask for on the island. The unit was well equipped for our family and the extra beach chairs and umbrella were much appreciated. We’ll definitely be back to Sanibel for years to come and will look to book here again.

Clean and cozy studio housing. That open up to a Beautiful, Quiet, and Relaxing Oasis! You can enjoy from morning to night. Great Place To Relax

I was very surprised with how beautiful the house and property were. The host was very quick to respond when we arrived at the house and had a few questions. She answered immediately and we were good to go from there on out. The home was loved by my whole family and we all agreed when we come back to the area we will hopefully be able to stay at this home again.