Restaurant

Paul's Live From New York Pizza

16 locals recommend,

Tips from locals

Vacasa California
July 2, 2014
Take the whole family! Local Pizza joint!
Ed And Elsie
March 27, 2017
Pizza, wings, pasta. They've got it.
Aimee
July 8, 2020
Open 12pm - 9pm for takeout, call to confirm hours. Pizza joint featured on Food Network's "Diners, Drive-Ins, & Dives," with locations in Eureka & Arcata. Flavortown's Guy Fieri says "The two hot choices from the menu include the Margarita Pizza which include thick garlic cloves as the finishing touch. Also, their thick crust, deep dish square pie is a delight as well. Crispy, crunch, fried at the bottom, you'll eat every crumb!"
Open 12pm - 9pm for takeout, call to confirm hours. Pizza joint featured on Food Network's "Diners, Drive-Ins, & Dives," with locations in Eureka & Arcata. Flavortown's Guy Fieri says "The two hot choices from the menu include the Margarita Pizza which include thick garlic cloves as the finishing to…
Michele
January 5, 2016
One of the best pizza places in Eureka. Thin crust pizza in a great variety of flavors.
Laura
July 13, 2022
Pizzas, calzones. Walking distance or delivery available.

Unique things to do nearby

Sailing in Trinidad or Humboldt Bay
Mountain bike through stunning Redwood forest trails

Locals also recommend

Location
604 F St
Eureka, CA
Downtown