Restaurant
Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
13 locals recommend,
Tips from locals
Bryan
May 30, 2019
Gotta get a matza ball soup. Gotta get a sandwich, any sandwich. Sit at the counter, not a table. It really takes you back to old New York, this place.
Marie
July 24, 2016
One of the oldest dinners .... I highly recommend the pastrami sandwich.
Ninja & Sung
October 11, 2022
Classic New York LUNCH COUNTER near the Flatiron Building on 5th Ave. HOURS: Mon-Sat, 8am - 5pm, Sun closed. Best Pastrami & Tuna Melt sandwiches hands down. Don’t forget to get a satisfying side of Matzo Ball Soup and enjoy your time travel to a Mid-20th-Century New York lunch break. Opened in 1929, this iconic Jewish deli had to close due to pandemic hardship in 2021, but got resurrected by the amazing team at Court St. Grocers, who are contemporary sandwich magicians. They kept Eisenberg’s old storefront and most popular menu items, but the restaurant now runs officially under the name “S&P Sandwich Shop”.
Classic New York LUNCH COUNTER near the Flatiron Building on 5th Ave. HOURS: Mon-Sat, 8am - 5pm, Sun closed. Best Pastrami & Tuna Melt sandwiches hands down. Don’t forget to get a satisfying side of Matzo Ball Soup and enjoy your time travel to a Mid-20th-Century New York lunch break. Opened…
Rik
September 20, 2014
You've got to go! Just around the corner, a New York establishment!
Diana
October 9, 2012
This place is somewhat questionable looking but they are a New York City staple and their sandwiches are really good. Photos of countless celebrity patrons adorn the walls of this establishment.
Unique things to do nearby
Locals also recommend
- 29 locals recommend
- 5 locals recommend
Location
174 5th Ave
New York, NY