Holiday rentals with a fire pit in East Columbus

Mater’s Garage was a super place for my big family to stay! Kellie was kind enough to put out a pack n’ play for our baby and an extra mattress. It was very clean and had all the little extras you’d expect at a hotel like coffee, individually wrapped toiletries, and extra blankets. The decor was amazing and there were lots of games to keep the kids busy while we packed up to leave. The neighborhood was modest, but felt safe, plus the street was quiet. I would definitely book this place again!

Excellent location, walking distance to everything, yet still tucked back on a quiet corner.

This home is beautiful & cozy. This is a great place for family, the kitchen had everything we needed to prepare our dinner. The host was there to answer any of my questions immediately. The backyard is gorgeous! I would definitely recommend this place and book again.

I felt right at home but also on a proper vacation at the Italian Villa! Yummy coffee machine, modern updates and appliances, such a fun and functional feel in the whole space! Perfect for hang outs with friends and family. Plus parking and so many amenities! Will be back!

Wow! What an amazing place! So comfortable and had everything needed for our stay. Anna came to our rescue when the first place we booked was so horrendous, I could not stay there. She was quick to respond at the last minute when we needed a place and we could not be more grateful. I would love to stay here again in the future when we plan another trip to Ohio from Florida.

The house was great. Loved the backyard. We enjoyed the firepit a lot. Providing firewood is such a big plus. Host was very responsive when I had a question about checkout. Highly recommend!

Our host was extremely communicative and helpful, instructions were clear and the home was exactly as described. Amenities were top-notch--the pool was enjoyed by all and the other outdoor areas were terrific. With our large group, there was plenty of room to gather (as well as smaller spaces for close conversation!) for meals and time together.

Very beautiful and clean modern home, me and my family immediately felt right at home! Sydney was a great host very responsive and communicative, would stay in this home and and again!

My husband and I loved the apartment, felt quite big for two people and had everything you could ask for. Modern, tidy, pretty clean, I find it a perfect option for a couple in Columbus!

Such a fun place to stay with the comic theme with great attention to detail to the theme. We were in town for a conference held at Capital University and it was the perfect location - so close to that, parks, and other great restaurants. The hosts were very proactive and responsive about communication.

We will return to stay at Dom’s place. The location was exactly what we were looking for. It was walkable to bars, restaurants, coffee shops etc., as well as to downtown. The building had great amenities and the apartment was very comfortable, clean and quiet. However, the pillows on the bed were terrible so consider bringing your own. The parking garage was really good and close by and we were glad to have somewhere to park no matter the time of day. There was plenty of grass and garden area behind the building for our dog to use and plenty of other furry friends around the neighborhood. We felt safe at all times of the day. Overall, we had a great few days.

Loved my stay here. From the outside nature sounds and views to the quaint interior, this place was just what I needed for my stay. Jimm and Kerry were amazing host, very responsive and accommodating. Whenever I am back in the area, I will definitely return to this gem.

Left a 5 star review but i think that is still too low 10/10 recommend. Nice clean home, quiet neighborhood, peaceful. This was my first time using Air BnB and this place has definitely set the bar high. No noisy neighbors, nasty smells, or thoughts of whether there were critters sharing your bed like at a hotel. Would definitely use again!

Jennifer’s place was wonderful! Her and Dick were very hospitable. My husband and I traveled from out of state to celebrate my brother’s 60th birthday. They allowed him and my daughter and her 2 kids to meet there and enjoy their beautiful outside tranquility garden and they even built us a fire in the fire pit. They had popsicles and toys for the kids as well. They went above and beyond to make our time there enjoyable. I would highly recommend their Airbnb. A very enjoyable stay and some wonderful memories were made!

This is a great place to stay if you’re spending time in Columbus. The apartment was spacious and clean. It is also very walkable to many bars, restaurants and cafes. The hosts were so responsive and helpful. The place gave us a peaceful place to rest after all of our wedding festivities. We will be back in the future!

Would stay here again. Good location to walk places. Clean, comfortable, and cool older home.

Enjoyed our stay. Its a flashback to how people lived in the 19th century.

Amazing stay! Super peaceful, quiet location. Description and photos really are exactly what you’ll find but truly can’t do it justice. It was the perfect get away that gives you privacy but is within a short drive to do a little sightseeing or pick up any forgotten items. The pond made for excellent fishing and also for nice relaxing views both in the morning and evening. The hot tub, pool house, paddle boat, and ping pong table were awesome extras to allow our family to truly unwind and enjoy. We had questions about the stove but discovered that the house posting had instructions so be sure to check those out. An abundance of fire wood was available to enjoy the fire pit in the evenings. Our pups were able to relax and enjoy as well. We highly recommend this spot to anyone looking to make some wonderful family memories.

This home was beautiful, with lots of windows and natural light. Big open spaces to accommodate all our family. Nice location next to the river with peaceful surroundings.

Nice little cabin! The driveway is large enough for a truck and trailer, or several cars. Everything was clean, the hot tub was nice, and Ian was responsive. The neighborhood is peaceful and quiet, though a bit run-down. Would stay here again.

Coming back again on another work trip! Thank you in advance 🩶

We enjoyed staying here there was plenty of space and the lot was beautiful! However the floors were very creaky and made it difficult for my infant and little ones to sleep. Other than that we had a good time.

The place was extraordinary. Stunning and picturesque both inside and out. Owners and managers were very friendly and communicated quickly. They really think of all the little details and add great little touches to enhance the guests stay. This was the best Airbnb experience we’ve ever had.

This house was perfect for my large family. It was very spacious with a lot of fun things to do. The house and property are both beautiful. The back yard is amazing for cooking out, spending quality time with the family and the kids to run around in. Karthik was very accommodating and responsive, as I thought I may have had over 16 people coming originally and had a few questions. Karthik also brought extra toilet paper as we were arriving to make sure we were well set for the weekend. We had plenty of blankets, pillows and towels to accommodate everyone. We had plenty of cooking ware for our 2 night stay, which included cooking all meals for 16 adults and 5 kids As mentioned, the well water does have an odd smell and color, but she said she will be working on fixing it along with some other small cosmetic things that have been broken, I’m sure over the time of the house being a rental. But none of it was impactful to our stay. Would recommend for a larger group wanting a peaceful stay