Best ice cream in Indianapolis

Check out the top ice cream in Indianapolis, reviewed and ranked by the city’s locals
1. BRICS
1. BRICS
host-0host-1host-2
17 local reviews
901 East 64th Street, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens 12:00 PM (noon)
+1 317-257-5757
CafeRestaurantFood
Gretchen
BRIC stands for Broad Ripple Ice Cream Shop. Great place for a late night dessert right on the Monon. Try…
Geoff
Historic train depot turned into a charming ice cream shop & fair-trade coffeehouse, open year round. Easily…
Jack
Broad Ripple Ice Cream Store Good place to stop for an ice cream while strolling or cycling the Monon in Broad…
1. BRICS
1. BRICS
host-0host-1host-2
17 local reviews
901 East 64th Street, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens 12:00 PM (noon)
+1 317-257-5757
Gretchen
Gretchen
BRIC stands for Broad Ripple Ice Cream Shop. Great place for a late night dessert right on the Monon. Try the s'mores.....kids love…
Geoff
Geoff
Historic train depot turned into a charming ice cream shop & fair-trade coffeehouse, open year round. Easily accessible on Monon Trail.
Jack
Jack
Broad Ripple Ice Cream Store Good place to stop for an ice cream while strolling or cycling the Monon in Broad Ripple.
2. Sub Zero Ice Cream & Yogurt
2. Sub Zero Ice Cream & Yogurt
host-0host-1host-2
12 local reviews
427 Massachusetts Avenue, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens 12:00 PM (noon)
+1 317-252-0271
FoodStorePoint of interest
Evan & Laura
If you want to watch your own custom ice cream be made right in front of your own eyes, then you have to go to…
Terri
Super yummy and a different experience! They make your ice cream right before your eyes with liquid nitrogen!…
Brandon
Super cool ice cream shop. Literally. They pour you liquid ice cream and blast it with nitrogen to freeze it…
2. Sub Zero Ice Cream & Yogurt
2. Sub Zero Ice Cream & Yogurt
host-0host-1host-2
12 local reviews
427 Massachusetts Avenue, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens 12:00 PM (noon)
+1 317-252-0271
Evan & Laura
Evan & Laura
If you want to watch your own custom ice cream be made right in front of your own eyes, then you have to go to Sub Zero. They make their ice…
Terri
Terri
Super yummy and a different experience! They make your ice cream right before your eyes with liquid nitrogen! (a fun treat after Bru…
Brandon
Brandon
Super cool ice cream shop. Literally. They pour you liquid ice cream and blast it with nitrogen to freeze it in front of you.
3. Wyliepalooza Ice Cream Emporium
3. Wyliepalooza Ice Cream Emporium
host-0host-1host-2
9 local reviews
5535 East Washington Street, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens 1:00 PM
+1 317-351-0275
CafeFoodStore
Diana
Ice Cream Emporium - enough said. So many unique flavors and fun atmosphere.
Deb
Premium ice cream in flavors you never heard of but will totally love.
Ashley
Best ice cream in town. I am not kidding!
3. Wyliepalooza Ice Cream Emporium
3. Wyliepalooza Ice Cream Emporium
host-0host-1host-2
9 local reviews
5535 East Washington Street, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens 1:00 PM
+1 317-351-0275
Diana
Diana
Ice Cream Emporium - enough said. So many unique flavors and fun atmosphere.
Deb
Deb
Premium ice cream in flavors you never heard of but will totally love.
Ashley
Ashley
Best ice cream in town. I am not kidding!
4. Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream
4. Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream
host-0host-1
5 local reviews
9922 E 79th St, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens in 5 minutes
(317) 570-0533
FoodStorePoint of interest
Chelsea
Locally owned family business, a short drive away and great ice cream with a wide variety of flavors and new…
Randy
The BEST ice cream and really good coffee.
4. Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream
4. Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream
host-0host-1
5 local reviews
9922 E 79th St, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens in 5 minutes
(317) 570-0533
Chelsea
Chelsea
Locally owned family business, a short drive away and great ice cream with a wide variety of flavors and new flavors every month.
Randy
Randy
The BEST ice cream and really good coffee.
5. Bub's Burgers & Ice Cream
5. Bub's Burgers & Ice Cream
host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
210 West Main Street, Carmel
Closed · Opens in 5 minutes
+1 317-706-2827
RestaurantFoodStore
Mindy
It gets busy here on weekends as it's a local favorite. Get the elk burger and waffle fries. They also have a…
Susan
QUAINT little downtown area right on the Monon Trail with outstanding ice cream and Burgers - recognized by…
Josh
Wonderful burgers, ice cream and milk shakes...as seen on Man vs. Food! Challenge yourself to the "Big Ugly".
5. Bub's Burgers & Ice Cream
5. Bub's Burgers & Ice Cream
host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
210 West Main Street, Carmel
Closed · Opens in 5 minutes
+1 317-706-2827
Mindy
Mindy
It gets busy here on weekends as it's a local favorite. Get the elk burger and waffle fries. They also have a little ice cream shop next…
Susan
Susan
QUAINT little downtown area right on the Monon Trail with outstanding ice cream and Burgers - recognized by FOOD NETWORK!
Josh
Josh
Wonderful burgers, ice cream and milk shakes...as seen on Man vs. Food! Challenge yourself to the "Big Ugly".
6. Nicey Treat
6. Nicey Treat
host-0host-1host-2
7 local reviews
916 E Westfield Blvd, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens 3:00 PM
(317) 602-6423
FoodPoint of interestEstablishment
Joanna
Craft ice pops (but closer to ice cream pops), that you can dunk in milk or dark chocolate! AMAZING!
Chad
Awesome odd and interesting flavors for natural ice cream.
Deborah
Ice cream popsicles. All possible flavors!
6. Nicey Treat
6. Nicey Treat
host-0host-1host-2
7 local reviews
916 E Westfield Blvd, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens 3:00 PM
(317) 602-6423
Joanna
Joanna
Craft ice pops (but closer to ice cream pops), that you can dunk in milk or dark chocolate! AMAZING!
Chad
Chad
Awesome odd and interesting flavors for natural ice cream.
Deborah
Deborah
Ice cream popsicles. All possible flavors!
7. Graeter's Ice Cream
7. Graeter's Ice Cream
host-0host-1
3 local reviews
9367 Ambleside Drive, Fishers
Closed · Opens in 5 minutes
+1 317-845-0069
FoodStorePoint of interest
Joshua
Best Ice Cream in Fishers! Rich and Creamy. Also, have gelato and old fashion sodas.
Addison
Some of the best, highest-quality ice cream you will ever taste.
7. Graeter's Ice Cream
7. Graeter's Ice Cream
host-0host-1
3 local reviews
9367 Ambleside Drive, Fishers
Closed · Opens in 5 minutes
+1 317-845-0069
Joshua
Joshua
Best Ice Cream in Fishers! Rich and Creamy. Also, have gelato and old fashion sodas.
Addison
Addison
Some of the best, highest-quality ice cream you will ever taste.
8. Canal Walk
8. Canal Walk
host-0host-1
72 local reviews
Canal Walk, Indianapolis
Route
Rachel
Talk a long stroll on our historic canal downtown. You will be glad you did. The canal runs along several…
Chris
A wonderful way to take in Indianapolis is a canal walk downtown. Places to stop and grab a drink or ice…
8. Canal Walk
8. Canal Walk
host-0host-1
72 local reviews
Canal Walk, Indianapolis
Rachel
Rachel
Talk a long stroll on our historic canal downtown. You will be glad you did. The canal runs along several great museums and memorials,…
Chris
Chris
A wonderful way to take in Indianapolis is a canal walk downtown. Places to stop and grab a drink or ice cream, peddle boat hire is also…
9. Frosty Boy Drive In
9. Frosty Boy Drive In
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
40 West Main Street, New Palestine
+1 317-861-5433
RestaurantFoodStore
Nancy & Doug
Great local ice cream shop
Brady & Jody
Good food, good ice cream.
9. Frosty Boy Drive In
9. Frosty Boy Drive In
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
40 West Main Street, New Palestine
+1 317-861-5433
Nancy & Doug
Nancy & Doug
Great local ice cream shop
Brady & Jody
Brady & Jody
Good food, good ice cream.
10. Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream
10. Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream
host-0host-1
3 local reviews
427 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens 12:00 PM (noon)
+1 317-600-3429
StoreRestaurantPoint of interest
Evan & Laura
If you want to watch your own custom ice cream be made right in front of your own eyes, then you have to go to…
Kevin
Pick your ingredients and watch your ice cream get frozen by liquid nitrogen. Beware: There is often a long…
10. Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream
10. Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream
host-0host-1
3 local reviews
427 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis
Closed · Opens 12:00 PM (noon)
+1 317-600-3429
Evan & Laura
Evan & Laura
If you want to watch your own custom ice cream be made right in front of your own eyes, then you have to go to Sub Zero. They make their ice…
Kevin
Kevin
Pick your ingredients and watch your ice cream get frozen by liquid nitrogen. Beware: There is often a long line!
11. Alexander's On the Square
11. Alexander's On the Square
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
864 Logan St, Noblesville
Closed · Opens in 5 minutes
(317) 773-9177
StoreRestaurantFood
Sherrie
Ice cream parlor plus!
Elizabeth
Because... ice cream.
11. Alexander's On the Square
11. Alexander's On the Square
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
864 Logan St, Noblesville
Closed · Opens in 5 minutes
(317) 773-9177
Sherrie
Sherrie
Ice cream parlor plus!
Elizabeth
Elizabeth
Because... ice cream.