Best ice cream in Hamptons Region

Check out the top ice cream in Hamptons Region, reviewed and ranked by the city’s locals
1. Magic Fountain
1. Magic Fountain
host-0host-1host-2
11 local reviews
9825 Main Road, Mattituck
Closed · Opens 10:00 AM
+1 631-298-4908
FoodStorePoint of interest
Rich
Old school handmade ice cream counter serving also sorbets and yogurts. There is usually a line down the…
Ruchika
This place is a must go! Their homemade ice cream comes in custom and seasonal flavors that you will love. …
Hillary
The ice cream flavors are inventive, and unexpected. It's just delicious and worth the 20 minute drive. Expect…
1. Magic Fountain
1. Magic Fountain
host-0host-1host-2
11 local reviews
9825 Main Road, Mattituck
Closed · Opens 10:00 AM
+1 631-298-4908
Rich
Rich
Old school handmade ice cream counter serving also sorbets and yogurts. There is usually a line down the block from May through September
Ruchika
Ruchika
This place is a must go! Their homemade ice cream comes in custom and seasonal flavors that you will love. Plus its open late!
Hillary
Hillary
The ice cream flavors are inventive, and unexpected. It's just delicious and worth the 20 minute drive. Expect long lines.
2. Sip 'N Soda
2. Sip 'N Soda
host-0host-1host-2
15 local reviews
Sip 'N Soda, Southampton
Closed · Opens 7:30 AM
+1 631-283-9752
StoreRestaurantPoint of interest
Diane
A great place to take the family for breakfast, lunch or a quick bite. Established in the 50's and not much…
Jodi
Original 1950s soda shop with their own old-fashioned soda recipes poured right at the counter. Best…
Jen
Old style breakfast and lunch with counter seating available. Homemade ice cream. My favorite!
2. Sip 'N Soda
2. Sip 'N Soda
host-0host-1host-2
15 local reviews
Sip 'N Soda, Southampton
Closed · Opens 7:30 AM
+1 631-283-9752
Diane
Diane
A great place to take the family for breakfast, lunch or a quick bite. Established in the 50's and not much has changed keeping it a great…
Jodi
Jodi
Original 1950s soda shop with their own old-fashioned soda recipes poured right at the counter. Best Breakfast in town before 12:00pm and…
Jen
Jen
Old style breakfast and lunch with counter seating available. Homemade ice cream. My favorite!
3. John's Drive-In
3. John's Drive-In
host-0host-1host-2
7 local reviews
677 Montauk Highway, Montauk
Closed · Opens 11:30 AM
+1 631-668-5515
RestaurantFoodStore
Nothin' fancy serving up delicious 'n dirty burgers. Onion rings and fries are a must. The signature John's…
Lynn
Enduring quick-serve burger joint dishes up comfort eats & ice cream in vintage surrounds. Delicious Big John…
David
Enduring quick-serve burger joint dishes up comfort eats & ice cream in vintage surrounds.
3. John's Drive-In
3. John's Drive-In
host-0host-1host-2
7 local reviews
677 Montauk Highway, Montauk
Closed · Opens 11:30 AM
+1 631-668-5515
Ike
Nothin' fancy serving up delicious 'n dirty burgers. Onion rings and fries are a must. The signature John's Burger is a home run. A cone of…
Lynn
Lynn
Enduring quick-serve burger joint dishes up comfort eats & ice cream in vintage surrounds. Delicious Big John burgers!
David
David
Enduring quick-serve burger joint dishes up comfort eats & ice cream in vintage surrounds.
4. Ice Cream Cottage
4. Ice Cream Cottage
host-0host-1host-2
4 local reviews
1590 Montauk Hwy, Mastic
Closed · Opens 10:00 AM
+1 631-395-3580
StorePoint of interestFood
Marc
A short drive away you can visit the Ice Cream Cottage where the home made ice cream is amazing!
Bridget
LITERALLY the best ice cream ever. End of story.
Joni
Great ice cream cakes and other specialties!
4. Ice Cream Cottage
4. Ice Cream Cottage
host-0host-1host-2
4 local reviews
1590 Montauk Hwy, Mastic
Closed · Opens 10:00 AM
+1 631-395-3580
Marc
Marc
A short drive away you can visit the Ice Cream Cottage where the home made ice cream is amazing!
Bridget
Bridget
LITERALLY the best ice cream ever. End of story.
Joni
Joni
Great ice cream cakes and other specialties!
5. Scoop Du Jour
5. Scoop Du Jour
host-0host-1host-2
9 local reviews
35 Newtown Lane, East Hampton
Closed · Opens 7:00 AM
+1 631-329-4883
RestaurantFoodStore
Hampton
A few things to know about this place: -The best ice cream in town -Homemade Donuts! Must try the cinnamon…
Mary
Late night ice cream - and early morning fresh Dreesen's Donuts, made before your eyes and hot from the oven. …
Jp
Famous ice cream and donuts shop. A must see if you have a sweet tooth.
5. Scoop Du Jour
5. Scoop Du Jour
host-0host-1host-2
9 local reviews
35 Newtown Lane, East Hampton
Closed · Opens 7:00 AM
+1 631-329-4883
Hampton
Hampton
A few things to know about this place: -The best ice cream in town -Homemade Donuts! Must try the cinnamon donut. -Really good breakfast…
Mary
Mary
Late night ice cream - and early morning fresh Dreesen's Donuts, made before your eyes and hot from the oven. Have a couple there and take…
Jp
Jp
Famous ice cream and donuts shop. A must see if you have a sweet tooth.
6. Sandpiper
6. Sandpiper
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
142 Main Street, Greenport
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
+1 631-477-1154
FoodStorePoint of interest
James
Sandpiper has been around since 1979, and while other ice cream shoppes have come and gone from this seaside…
Clay
Local Ice Cream Shop. Yum.
Zoe
Best ice cream in town
6. Sandpiper
6. Sandpiper
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
142 Main Street, Greenport
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
+1 631-477-1154
James
James
Sandpiper has been around since 1979, and while other ice cream shoppes have come and gone from this seaside hamlet, this place has endured…
Clay
Clay
Local Ice Cream Shop. Yum.
Zoe
Zoe
Best ice cream in town
7. Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen
7. Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen
host-0host-1host-2
7 local reviews
2391 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton
Closed · Opens 7:00 AM
+1 631-537-9885
FoodStorePoint of interest
Kathryn
Great diner with enormous portions of buttery scrambled eggs for breakfast and tasty burgers and the local…
Cynthia
Best diner on the east end. Mainly locals. Great burgers, egg creams, homemade ice cream etc...
Claire
A great diner with multiple milkshake and ice cream options, burgers, club sandwiches, etc.
7. Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen
7. Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen
host-0host-1host-2
7 local reviews
2391 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton
Closed · Opens 7:00 AM
+1 631-537-9885
Kathryn
Kathryn
Great diner with enormous portions of buttery scrambled eggs for breakfast and tasty burgers and the local fave: TUNA MELT. Get a chocolate…
Cynthia
Cynthia
Best diner on the east end. Mainly locals. Great burgers, egg creams, homemade ice cream etc...
Claire
Claire
A great diner with multiple milkshake and ice cream options, burgers, club sandwiches, etc.
8. Amagansett Farmers Market
8. Amagansett Farmers Market
host-0host-1host-2
11 local reviews
367 Main Street, Amagansett
Closed · Opens 7:00 AM
(631) 267-3894
FoodPoint of interestEstablishment
Lauren
The place to hang out while buying farm fresh fruits and veggies, sandwiches and coffee, prepared gourmet…
Rhian
Local produce, coffee, ice cream and the Sunday NYT. Our local CSA Amber waves farm is behind it. They sell…
Li
Great place to buy fresh produce, breakfast and ice cream. Sit outside and enjoy your treats under the shade.
8. Amagansett Farmers Market
8. Amagansett Farmers Market
host-0host-1host-2
11 local reviews
367 Main Street, Amagansett
Closed · Opens 7:00 AM
(631) 267-3894
Lauren
Lauren
The place to hang out while buying farm fresh fruits and veggies, sandwiches and coffee, prepared gourmet specialties, cheese, breads,…
Rhian
Rhian
Local produce, coffee, ice cream and the Sunday NYT. Our local CSA Amber waves farm is behind it. They sell veggies, cheese, bread and fruit…
Li
Li
Great place to buy fresh produce, breakfast and ice cream. Sit outside and enjoy your treats under the shade.
9. Bay Burger
9. Bay Burger
host-0host-1host-2
12 local reviews
1742 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
+1 631-899-3915
RestaurantFoodStore
Andy
Decent burger and kid's friendly. I love their homemade ice cream!! And they have live music on Thursdays, but…
B. Ellie
Casual spot for lunch or dinner. Great burgers and housemade ice cream. Live music on Thursday nights.
Claire
Fabulous jazz on Thursday evenings, burgers and chocolate salted caramel ice cream to die for!
9. Bay Burger
9. Bay Burger
host-0host-1host-2
12 local reviews
1742 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
+1 631-899-3915
Andy
Andy
Decent burger and kid's friendly. I love their homemade ice cream!! And they have live music on Thursdays, but please check schedules.
B. Ellie
B. Ellie
Casual spot for lunch or dinner. Great burgers and housemade ice cream. Live music on Thursday nights.
Claire
Claire
Fabulous jazz on Thursday evenings, burgers and chocolate salted caramel ice cream to die for!
10. Big Olaf's Ice Cream
10. Big Olaf's Ice Cream
host-0host-1host-2
4 local reviews
Big Olaf's Ice Cream, Sag Harbor
FoodStorePoint of interest
Pamela
The best ice cream in Sag Harbor, open late at night over the summer, and lines move quickly. So many flavors…
Susan
There's nothing like a scoop of your fav flave of Olaf's homemade ice cream on a hot Summer day while mosying…
Abby
Great ice cream and right next to the harbor. You can enjoy your ice cream and watch the boats.
10. Big Olaf's Ice Cream
10. Big Olaf's Ice Cream
host-0host-1host-2
4 local reviews
Big Olaf's Ice Cream, Sag Harbor
Pamela
Pamela
The best ice cream in Sag Harbor, open late at night over the summer, and lines move quickly. So many flavors and each one is better than…
Susan
Susan
There's nothing like a scoop of your fav flave of Olaf's homemade ice cream on a hot Summer day while mosying along the wharf. It's the…
Abby
Abby
Great ice cream and right next to the harbor. You can enjoy your ice cream and watch the boats.
11. The Fudge Company
11. The Fudge Company
host-0
2 local reviews
67 Main St, Southampton
Closed · Opens Thursday 11:00 AM
+1 631-283-8108
StoreRestaurantPoint of interest
Jen
Homemade Ice Cream and Treats
11. The Fudge Company
11. The Fudge Company
host-0
2 local reviews
67 Main St, Southampton
Closed · Opens Thursday 11:00 AM
+1 631-283-8108
Jen
Jen
Homemade Ice Cream and Treats
12. Gosman's
12. Gosman's
host-0host-1
19 local reviews
500 W Lake Dr, Montauk
Closed · Opens Wednesday 12:00 PM (noon)
+1 631-668-5330
BarRestaurantPoint of interest
Chris
Lovely setting on the water at the fishing dock Fresh fish off the boats daily. Ice cream stand.
Ann Marie
Seafood, lobster, tuna cones, ice cream next door
12. Gosman's
12. Gosman's
host-0host-1
19 local reviews
500 W Lake Dr, Montauk
Closed · Opens Wednesday 12:00 PM (noon)
+1 631-668-5330
Chris
Chris
Lovely setting on the water at the fishing dock Fresh fish off the boats daily. Ice cream stand.
Ann Marie
Ann Marie
Seafood, lobster, tuna cones, ice cream next door