Best pizza in Erie

Check out the top pizza in Erie, reviewed and ranked by the city’s locals
1. John's Wildwood Pizzeria
1. John's Wildwood Pizzeria
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
105 Erie St, Edinboro
Closed · Opens 4:00 PM
(814) 734-7355
Meal takeawayRestaurantFood
Vicki
Locally owned & operated. Great pizza shop food at great prices; pizza, subs, wings, salads. Eat in or carry…
Brian
Best Pizza in town. Open 'til 4am. Delivery.
Lisa And Jan
Best Pizza in Edinboro!
1. John's Wildwood Pizzeria
1. John's Wildwood Pizzeria
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
105 Erie St, Edinboro
Closed · Opens 4:00 PM
(814) 734-7355
Vicki
Vicki
Locally owned & operated. Great pizza shop food at great prices; pizza, subs, wings, salads. Eat in or carry out. THEY DELIVER !!
Brian
Brian
Best Pizza in town. Open 'til 4am. Delivery.
Lisa And Jan
Lisa And Jan
Best Pizza in Edinboro!
2. Covered Bridge Pizza Parlor
2. Covered Bridge Pizza Parlor
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
380 E Main St, Andover
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
(440) 293-6776
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Patricia
If you are visiting Pymatuming this is a great place to eat. Pizza and spaghetti is great, but they have many…
Sarah
Good pizza -- served inside an old covered bridge! A fun place for large groups and casual meals.
Rodger & Tina
The Meat Lovers pizza is loaded! The hoagies are delicious!
2. Covered Bridge Pizza Parlor
2. Covered Bridge Pizza Parlor
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
380 E Main St, Andover
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
(440) 293-6776
Patricia
Patricia
If you are visiting Pymatuming this is a great place to eat. Pizza and spaghetti is great, but they have many other foods on their menu.
Sarah
Sarah
Good pizza -- served inside an old covered bridge! A fun place for large groups and casual meals.
Rodger & Tina
Rodger & Tina
The Meat Lovers pizza is loaded! The hoagies are delicious!
3. Covered Bridge Pizza Parlor
3. Covered Bridge Pizza Parlor
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
6541 N Main St, North Kingsville
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
+1 440-224-2252
RestaurantPoint of interestFood
Allen
The Pizzeria is in an old covered bridge. Great pizza and a unique atmosphere.
Lisa
This is a pizza shop located in an authentic old covered bridge.
Jennifer
Pizza, salads, subs in an actual covered bridge!
3. Covered Bridge Pizza Parlor
3. Covered Bridge Pizza Parlor
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
6541 N Main St, North Kingsville
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
+1 440-224-2252
Allen
Allen
The Pizzeria is in an old covered bridge. Great pizza and a unique atmosphere.
Lisa
Lisa
This is a pizza shop located in an authentic old covered bridge.
Jennifer
Jennifer
Pizza, salads, subs in an actual covered bridge!
4. Ashville General Store
4. Ashville General Store
host-0host-1
4 local reviews
4844 NY-474, Ashville
Closed · Opens 7:00 AM
(716) 763-3369
StoreRestaurantFood
Vincent
This is a really neat old grain mill converted to a pizza joint. We Love Love love their special pizza…
Adam And Danelle
This is a great pizza and snadwich shop. When I was a kid it used to be a feed store. It has a really neat…
4. Ashville General Store
4. Ashville General Store
host-0host-1
4 local reviews
4844 NY-474, Ashville
Closed · Opens 7:00 AM
(716) 763-3369
Vincent
Vincent
This is a really neat old grain mill converted to a pizza joint. We Love Love love their special pizza called "The General" It can be a…
Adam And Danelle
Adam And Danelle
This is a great pizza and snadwich shop. When I was a kid it used to be a feed store. It has a really neat atmosphere. Great location to…
5. Rainbow Cafe
5. Rainbow Cafe
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
263 Main St, Conneaut
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
(440) 593-2504
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Linda
This is a bar/restaurant suitable for all ages. Hometown atmosphere with great soups, subs, salads and pizza!
Kim
Friendly family-appropriate bar/pizza cafe. Pizza and Stromboli are delicious!
5. Rainbow Cafe
5. Rainbow Cafe
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
263 Main St, Conneaut
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
(440) 593-2504
Linda
Linda
This is a bar/restaurant suitable for all ages. Hometown atmosphere with great soups, subs, salads and pizza!
Kim
Kim
Friendly family-appropriate bar/pizza cafe. Pizza and Stromboli are delicious!
6. Andriaccio's Restaurant
6. Andriaccio's Restaurant
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
4837 W Lake Rd, Mayville
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
+1 716-753-5200
BarMeal takeawayStore
Norm & Paulette
Italian and American food eatery that is the nearest full service restaurant to Chautauqua Institution. A…
Tiffany
Amazing pizza and Italian food!!
6. Andriaccio's Restaurant
6. Andriaccio's Restaurant
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
4837 W Lake Rd, Mayville
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
+1 716-753-5200
Norm & Paulette
Norm & Paulette
Italian and American food eatery that is the nearest full service restaurant to Chautauqua Institution. A little noisy for my taste. They…
Tiffany
Tiffany
Amazing pizza and Italian food!!
7. Johns Wildwood Pizzeria
7. Johns Wildwood Pizzeria
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
Johns Wildwood Pizzeria
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
(814) 314-2799
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Robert
Best Pizza around, connected to the Erie Brewing Company
Lisa And Jan
Great Pizza at the Erie Brewing Company!
7. Johns Wildwood Pizzeria
7. Johns Wildwood Pizzeria
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
Johns Wildwood Pizzeria
Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
(814) 314-2799
Robert
Robert
Best Pizza around, connected to the Erie Brewing Company
Lisa And Jan
Lisa And Jan
Great Pizza at the Erie Brewing Company!
8. The Catherwood and The Kiln
8. The Catherwood and The Kiln
host-0host-1
3 local reviews
The Catherwood and The Kiln, Vittoria
Closed · Opens 9:00 AM
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Lisbeth
Wonderful place to enjoy a delicious pizza ample menu. Very friendly and family oriented restaurant. Please…
Roxanne
Bit of a drive but best pizza and wings around.
8. The Catherwood and The Kiln
8. The Catherwood and The Kiln
host-0host-1
3 local reviews
The Catherwood and The Kiln, Vittoria
Closed · Opens 9:00 AM
Lisbeth
Lisbeth
Wonderful place to enjoy a delicious pizza ample menu. Very friendly and family oriented restaurant. Please try Chicken Ceasar pizza and…
Roxanne
Roxanne
Bit of a drive but best pizza and wings around.