Best pizza in Crystal Lake

Check out the top pizza in Crystal Lake, reviewed and ranked by the city’s locals
1. Foxhole Tap & Pizzeria
1. Foxhole Tap & Pizzeria
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
3308 W Elm St, McHenry
Closed · Opens 4:00 PM
(815) 385-6710
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Beth
Great Pizza restaurant inside the historic Riverside Hotel, try the Fox Hole Classic- my favorite!
Carrie
Another great pizza place, also a great place to grab a quick drink too.
1. Foxhole Tap & Pizzeria
1. Foxhole Tap & Pizzeria
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
3308 W Elm St, McHenry
Closed · Opens 4:00 PM
(815) 385-6710
Beth
Beth
Great Pizza restaurant inside the historic Riverside Hotel, try the Fox Hole Classic- my favorite!
Carrie
Carrie
Another great pizza place, also a great place to grab a quick drink too.
2. Chooch's Pizzeria
2. Chooch's Pizzeria
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
64 South Grove Avenue, Elgin
+1 847-888-0211
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Mandy And Dan
Nice atmosphere, outdoor seating, yummy pizza, good wine, friendly owners.
Bri
Another great pizza place in town
2. Chooch's Pizzeria
2. Chooch's Pizzeria
host-0host-1
2 local reviews
64 South Grove Avenue, Elgin
+1 847-888-0211
Mandy And Dan
Mandy And Dan
Nice atmosphere, outdoor seating, yummy pizza, good wine, friendly owners.
Bri
Bri
Another great pizza place in town
3. Rookies Sports Bar & Grill (Elgin)
3. Rookies Sports Bar & Grill (Elgin)
host-0
2 local reviews
2486 Bushwood Dr, Elgin
Open · Closes 3:00 AM
+1 847-551-9006
BarPoint of interestEstablishment
Robert
Sports Bar, Family-Friendly American, Salads, Sandwiches, Pizza, Tacos, Dollar Burgers
3. Rookies Sports Bar & Grill (Elgin)
3. Rookies Sports Bar & Grill (Elgin)
host-0
2 local reviews
2486 Bushwood Dr, Elgin
Open · Closes 3:00 AM
+1 847-551-9006
Robert
Robert
Sports Bar, Family-Friendly American, Salads, Sandwiches, Pizza, Tacos, Dollar Burgers
4. The Cottage
4. The Cottage
host-0
4 local reviews
6 E Crystal Lake Ave, Crystal Lake
Open · Closes 2:00 AM
+1 815-459-7520
BarRestaurantPoint of interest
Rosemary & Lisa
Great hometown pub with 1/2 price pizza tuesdays and other great deals. Check them out. Within walking…
4. The Cottage
4. The Cottage
host-0
4 local reviews
6 E Crystal Lake Ave, Crystal Lake
Open · Closes 2:00 AM
+1 815-459-7520
Rosemary & Lisa
Rosemary & Lisa
Great hometown pub with 1/2 price pizza tuesdays and other great deals. Check them out. Within walking distance.
5. Old Republic Kitchen + Bar
5. Old Republic Kitchen + Bar
host-0
2 local reviews
155 S Randall Rd, Elgin
Open · Closes 2:00 AM
(224) 535-9544
BarRestaurantFood
Robert
All-American - barbecue from Memphis, Wisconsin mac and cheese, New York pizza, and West Coast burgers, beer &…
5. Old Republic Kitchen + Bar
5. Old Republic Kitchen + Bar
host-0
2 local reviews
155 S Randall Rd, Elgin
Open · Closes 2:00 AM
(224) 535-9544
Robert
Robert
All-American - barbecue from Memphis, Wisconsin mac and cheese, New York pizza, and West Coast burgers, beer & cocktails
6. Randall Roadhouse Grill-Bar-Pizza
6. Randall Roadhouse Grill-Bar-Pizza
host-0
2 local reviews
2267 Randall Rd, Carpentersville
Open · Closes 12:00 AM (midnight)
(347) 318-2605
BarRestaurantFood
Robert
Neighborhood sports bar with burgers, specialty pizza & other hearty fare, plus daily drink specials
6. Randall Roadhouse Grill-Bar-Pizza
6. Randall Roadhouse Grill-Bar-Pizza
host-0
2 local reviews
2267 Randall Rd, Carpentersville
Open · Closes 12:00 AM (midnight)
(347) 318-2605
Robert
Robert
Neighborhood sports bar with burgers, specialty pizza & other hearty fare, plus daily drink specials
7. Maciano's Pizza & Pastaria
7. Maciano's Pizza & Pastaria
host-0
2 local reviews
3091 US-20, Elgin
Open · Closes 11:00 PM
(847) 697-1400
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Robert
Pizza, pasta, panini, sandwiches, bar
7. Maciano's Pizza & Pastaria
7. Maciano's Pizza & Pastaria
host-0
2 local reviews
3091 US-20, Elgin
Open · Closes 11:00 PM
(847) 697-1400
Robert
Robert
Pizza, pasta, panini, sandwiches, bar