Nice apartment. Well situated, a quick walk to the beach and next to the bay. Alan is a very nice and responsive host who answered all my questions before I arrived, and also call few time to check everything was good. We had a problem with the pool. The water turned florescent green after a rain storm. Alan sent 3 sets of pool maintenance technicians to fix it. Sadly, was still bright green when we left. The pool technicians said it was an excess of iron in the water from run off from the trees. Weird. But, they were confident that they could fix it and were still their when we left. The kitchen is really really nice. Just like the pictures. Maybe better. We had a great experience and can recommend this place without hesitation. We would definately stay again!

Although I did not actually meet Alan at his house in the Pines, he kept me completely informed by email and text messages. I did meet another housemate of his, Bill out at the beach, a very nice and friendly guy who filled me in on everything else I needed to know. Alan had told me that Bill was one of their favorite quarters. Rentals in the Pines usually are sold by shares, a share of an approximately 24 week summer season. So a full share would be 1-bed for the whole 24 weeks, a half share 12 weeks, a quarter share 6 weeks. The apartment Alan created was spectacular, and looks even better than the photos, and the entire unit, on the pool level, was completely stocked with everything you could possibly need or want, especially the kitchen. I can truly say Alan's rental unit exceeded my biggest expectations, and it was a pleasure to stay in such luxurious comfort.

The poolhouse is a great way to stay in the Pines without committing to a share house. The apartment is comfortable and the kitchen is well-equipped. There's a dishwasher and washer/dryer in the unit. Fresh herbs grow by the pool, including oregano and rosemary. And the pool is heated. The two upper floors are rented by the share so there could be as many as 8 additional people at the house (or more with guests), but everyone was friendly and there were plenty of times when no one was around (if that's your preference). Overall, a great experience.

The reservation was canceled 75 days before arrival. This is an automated posting.

Wonderful apartment in the Pines with nice pool, hot tub, and plenty of space!

Beautiful place and great location!

We had a great time, everything was just as promised, Alan was a great host. The apartment is awesome.

I've done Fire Island shares in the past, but having our own apartment was really nice. The place was clean and very nicely appointed. Bonus for having air conditioning, as homes on the island without it often smell mildewy. We'll definitely look to Alan and 281 Shady Walk for our next stay in the Pines!

Linda's place on Fire Island was a perfect little escape for my solo vacation. The room is small but very clean. It's ideal for 1 person or a couple. There's an AC unit that's controlled in the room which was perfect when it got too hot at night. It was a 2 minute walk from the ferry and right by Flynn's. I loved the common area deck outside and had my coffee and read the newspaper undisturbed in the morning. The apartment is on the bay side of the island so the walk to the beach took about 5 minutes (which is nothing in beach time!) I had a wonderful time and hope to stay again next season.

Had a wonderful time here! Linda answered all our questions promptly, and the space was perfect for myself and my partner. Everything was clean and cozy when we arrived even though we were a little early for check-in - there were towels, beach chairs, and an umbrella for our visit to the beach. The little kitchen was great for heating up our food and making breakfast - we had silverware, plates, even a water filter. The outdoor shower was lovely as well. Beautiful area, right next to the ferry and minutes from the beach! It was a wonderful little space to call home for a few nights. Overall we had a great time and would be very happy to come back.

Linda was responsive and super helpful as we found our way to Fire Island, and the rental itself was a tiny, fun place to stay while we enjoyed the beach :)

Lovely place. Fire island was wonderful. Martha's place is quiet with lots of privacy and if you did need her she was there! Outdoor shower was cool too Thank you also for the bug spray!

Martha was a lovely host and very welcoming! Her home was just as described - super comfortable for a couple and conveniently located to the ferry, nightlife, and the beach! We had a great time and hope to come back soon!

Martha was very welcoming. She directed me from the ferry to the place and met me with the key. The place was clean and well taken care of. She was very hospitable. We had a wonderful stay!

Martha is one of the most accommodating, generous and warmest hosts I've ever met. She went out of her way to turn our brief getaway into amazing vacation!!! The place is very close to the beach and to a couple of restaurants, and you have privacy and peace and quiet. You're also close to nightlife, if that's what you're into. We loved having breakfast on the porch and an outdoor shower. Thank you, Martha, for making us feel so welcome and a very relaxing stay! Looking forward to coming back!

First of all, the listing is deceptive: It is neither an entire home nor an apartment. It is just an attic with no kitchen (not even a coffeemaker), dining area or indoor shower. My GF and I were disappointed but we tried to make do as there was nowhere else to go in the vicinity. This is the first time I had to write a negative review but it was dismaying how shabby the place was and how little the owner cared about the comforts of us the renters. Directly below our floor is a party of frat boys and their hookups blasting their music day and night. It got so bad on the second night that we had to pound on their door to complain (they couldn't hear us for 10 minutes.) I called the owner at close to midnight and she never did anything to intervene. The frats lowered their music a tad but it was still audible through the very thin walls, so we got very little sleep as they didn't stop till 3am. The owner said the next day that she could tell people to lower their music—which she failed to do—but not to turn it off. Really? At midnight? That's totally unacceptable! Besides the incessant noise, the place was not very clean. There were ants everywhere, even on my bed. There was no curtain on the only window so it was impossible to sleep past sunrise. There were also holes in the window and door screens so we got bitten by many mosquitoes that got in. The towels smelled of mildew, and the beds were lumpy and soft, very uncomfortable to sleep on. The small AC worked OK on the first day, but barely worked on the second day. The only positive thing I can say is that it's close to the beach. There was a cute little patio right outside the room, but we couldn't enjoy it as the noisy renters downstairs were always out lounging and blasting their music very close by. I had liked the outdoor shower, but at times we had to walk past the frat boys to get into the shower, which didn't make us feel very safe at all. For what we paid, it was a very unpleasant experience, not the quiet and peaceful getaway we had hoped for. The owner was also unresponsive to my 2 emails in the weeks before our arrival (I had to write her a third email and called before she finally replied.) Unless you love partying with frat boys and their hookups with dorm room-like vibes, and don't mind shabby amenities or an uncaring owner, stay away!

Made us feel right at home! She was only a text message away when needed, very welcoming and didn't fuss over us arriving earlier than expected. Very accommodating. We loved the shower that was outside, which made the beach stay more authentic, downside was that we had to share with guest staying downstairs from us. That wasn't specified in the listing, wasn't a problem for us to coordinate with them but a heads up would've been nice. We loved the location, super close to the beach and stores, close to a couple of restaurants as well. We used the grill every day, so having a store close by was convenient. Grill wasn't maintained very well and was dirty, but overall we worked around it. Would highly recommend Martha's beach house for anyone who wants a relaxing beach stay! Hoping to be back soon!

Martha was a great host! We stayed over at her place over the weekend. She was accessible to answer all of our questions. When we first arrived, she was very friendly and made sure we had all that was needed along with giving recommendations for places to check out.

The host canceled this reservation the day before arrival. This is an automated posting.

Petra was an amazing host - she waited for us at the office to meet us and take us to the apartment, and was very sweet and welcoming. We were so happy to be upgraded to the unit with the ocean view and 2 bedrooms instead of 1, and also were allowed to store our luggage in the office and use the beautiful deck on the property facing the beach even after we checked out!!! The apartment is gorgeous - clean and modern with everything you could possibly need. Petra's staff was also very sweet and helpful, doing everything they could and more to make us feel welcomed and comfortable. I will absolutely recommend this property to anyone, and cant wait to go back there next summer.

My fiancée and I really enjoyed staying at Dune Point. Petra was very responsive prior to check in, and the Dune Point staff were very helpful and accommodating. The apartment is beautiful and clean and worth every penny! We would definitely stay here again.

Great Place, Accurate Description, and Friendly/Helpful

Great 1 bedroom apartment with beach access steps away. Very clean and modern accomodations, would definitely recommend staying here.

Petra was there to greet us on our arrival from the ferry. She walked us to our place in the dark and made us feel most welcome.

Loved this place and Petra & Mika are super nice & accommodating. All is well maintained, clean and in a great location. Would go back in a heartbeat!

This place was exactly what the doctor ordered. Very clean and well maintained. The staff was very helpful and friendly. The kitchen was well stocked with appliances and utensils so we could easily prepare meals. I forgot to pack some coffee for the coffeemaker and Petra arranged to have some sent over. What a life saver! The beach towels, umbrellas and beach chairs made it possible to comfortably spend all day at the beach without having to bring all that equipment from home. I would definitely stay here again!

My fiancé and I throughly enjoyed our short stay at cherry grove. The room was super clean and modern and the bed was very comfortable. The people at cherry grove are extremely friendly, and wont let you pass them without giving you a smile and quick greeting. We plan on returning and would recommend to anyone.

We had a great time!! Close enough to town that you don't feel like you're missing out but far enough away to feel secluded. Although not the only apt in the house, we felt that we had great privacy. The apt was super clean and many necessities were supplied to us. Alexandre was very responsive and even let us keep our stuff in his own house so we could enjoy our time on the island after checkout. The apartment was great and met our every need. We will definitely come back!

Alexandre was warm, welcoming and accommodating -- the studio is cozy and conveniently located. We had a great stay!

Alexandre was a wonderful host and everything was just as we had hoped. The studio and the deck were private and we had such a relaxing, peaceful time.

WE LOVED THIS PLACE and ALEXANDRE IS AWESOME!

Once again, Alexandre was a very accommodating host and it was a pleasure to stay in one of his studios. The location in Cherry Grove and the amenities can't be beat.

Loved the place! Alexandre is an extremely cool and friendly host.

Alexandre was the perfect host! Super responsive and helpful and he has a very sweet, dignified, easy-going manner. He really made us feel at home. The property is very convenient to the center of "town" and close to the ferry, but still quite, set-back and private. We had one of the studios, which is small but functional and with a very nice, private terrace. Easy walk to the beach too. We spent four nights here and honestly it was probably our best beach vacation ever. Highly recommended!

Fire island is a great getaway. Loved the plank walkways, no cars, and serene beach. This lodging has almost everything you need. Full kitchen with utensils and dishes down to wine glasses. We cooked breakfast easily (bacon and eggs), watched TV on the DirectTV in the evenings, and used the beach chairs and umbrellas to relax during the day on the beach. The front patio is also a nice place to get rid of some stress. The bathroom was good, with a great shower and shelves stocked with towels. If you have a Mac the wifi does not work. Seems like an ongoing issue according to the owner. But he definitely tried to help us get it to work which was nice. And the bed is a trundle bed, meaning it is split into two and a bit small. It worked fine for us, but each person is on their own side of the bed with a metal frame between if you try to lay across. It did not take away from the lodging to a large degree but just something to be aware of. I would highly recommend this studio getaway.

John's place is fantastic and just steps from the beach. He and his wife are very welcoming and accommodating. It's the perfect spot for a weekend getaway with your significant other or a friend.

John's place is perfect for a stay in Fire Island. Close to the beach, with a lovely patio in the garden. Watch the birds and butterflies while listening to the sound of the surf. The apartment itself is cozy and clean, and feels nestled in, tucked into a natural setting. John was a perfect host, friendly and welcoming.

Enjoyed this place even more the second time, especially outside. The front deck table area under the umbrella stayed dry even during a rain. The outdoor shower came in handy too. The area is quiet enough to leave the windows and doors open to continually let the outside air inside. John once again was a friendly and accommodating host. I hope for the chance to return.

John's guest house is the perfect escape for a weekend on Fire Island. It is very private and while it is a bit cozy, it has all you need and is the right size for up to two guests. We loved the fact that there was a grill on the patio and John let us use it! The chaise lounge chairs on the deck were also great. We also loved the little encapsulated outdoor space behind the bedroom, it is very private and makes you feel very much like being a part of nature. The house is a mere one minute walk to the beach, and plenty of long towels are provided in the apartment that you can use. Overall, it was exactly what I was hoping to find and I would love to stay with John again some time in the future.

Made to feel very welcome by lovely host/couple. Idyllic quiet spot with secluded shady garden and deck. Still very close to night life if you want it and the beach. Easy to get to from ferry 5-10 mins walk Host provided usual amenities and filter coffee as a bonus. Good advice on local bars/eateries shops etc. All of fire island expensive so this flat reasonable value

John was a great host. His apartment was just as depicted in the photos: very charming and enjoyable. The neighborhood was clean, quiet, and a great oasis from NYC. He responded very quickly to messages and was very kind by allowing us to check out later than the listed time because there were no new guests expected that day. I would definitely choose to stay here again if I returned to Fire Island. Thank you John!

The studio is a perfectly comfy and cozy place to stay in Fire Island. Small private listings like these are hard to come by and so it fills a nice niche for a solo traveler or a duo. I would say the location is absolutely perfect. Just far away from town to feel privacy, but close enough to walk in and make the Pantry before closing or grab a beverage at Low Tea. Proximity to ocean is great. I would walk out to the beach on Nautilus with my coffee and breakfast since it really is so close. There is a simplicity to the studio, don't expect any frills or luxuries, but it is soulful and unique, this modest perch in a beautiful garden. The outdoor shower is basic, but it is there and certainly welcome, the two burner stove is sufficient for low-maintenance cooking, fans keep the space cool, there are enough kitchen tools to make small meals work, the fridge is a great size and a freezer for making ice and keeping ice cream. The bed is comfy. There's a grill and having use of the washer-dryer lifesaving as nothing fully dries in the humidity and it's great to be able to dry towels for multiple days of beaching. This humble spot is a beach shack in the most honorable and affectionate senses of the term, a great value for the high-priced Pines set on a quiet and peaceful walk near the ocean and close enough to town for creature comforts. Recommended.

Johns studio was exactly as I expected. It had an extra lovely patio plus had great access to the beach.

As always I enjoyed fire island but this time it was extra special because we picked the perfect place to stay. Close to shops, beach and restaurants with enough distance to escape the loud music from the bars if you want a quiet night in. House is well equipped with needs and provides plenty storage / shelving space for a tidy and organized visit. Beds , pillows and comforters are comfy and clean with plenty of towels (unlike some places that only give u one or two). And they provide wagons for ur stuff to the house which is super handy. The neighbor is a sweet heart and kinda hard of hearing so a little music outside didn't hurt. Lots of privacy too !!

The home was clean, spacious...a mid century quaint house. Great location. I would rent this home again or front unit with roof top.

I spent a few nights staying in the bungalow. Sofina was very welcoming and checked in to ensure that the accommodation was working out. She also came to the rescue when the internet connection needed to be refreshed even though it was late in the day. The accommodation provides the perfect spot to explore and enjoy the beaches on Cherry. There is plenty of space outdoors to have a BBQ as well. I would most certainly return to enjoy this wonderful little part of the world.

Terrific space. Perfectly equipped. Brilliantly located close to the beach and to restaurants. Lovely people (both owners and guests). Has a Beautiful little deck, Comfy bed and Great heating (which we needed one day because of the chilly weather). I would LOVE to come back. Cherry Grove is a very special place and we couldn't have been happier with our choice of where to stay. One tip to light sleepers, cherry grove buildings are all light wood construction and close together so you will hear some noise from the boardwalks and neighboring apartments. Bring earplugs and you'll sleep like a baby.

It was a great location and extremely accommodating. The studio was clean and was perfectly described. I highly recommend it to anyone who is interested in an overnight stay in cherry grove.

We had a wonderfull vacation! The room was perfect. Beautiful, clean and so close to the beach. The room was ready for us at 12 even when the check in was at 3. Petra was really welcoming. We didn't realize that the season ended so the grocery shop was closed. Petra was great and brought to our room plenty of food! it was heart warming :)

Alexandre was very welcoming and was extremely responsive to texts and emails prior to arrival and during our stay.

Alexandre is a very kind and helpful host. Thank you! Roberto

Alex was a very good host, very helpful, accommodating and made the visit a very comfortable one. Would definitely seek out to stay with him on my next trip.

Alexandre was a gracious host and the space was exactly how it is shown on the page. Would definitely recommend to friends/book from again.

Alexandre was a very welcoming and charming host. The studio itself is relatively small but also cozy. There is no kitchen in the studio, only a small fridge including some utensils. I would suggest to rent out a bigger space that includes a full kitchen and a fantastic view. Overall my experience here was wonderful. Thanks Alex:)

This was a perfect stay! Exactly what the accommodation promises. Alexandre was so nice and accommodating. Always responded back to me with any questions I had. Highly highly recommended.

This place is delightful! We had a great time and we would definitely stay here again. The ad is completely accurate- the studio is a very short walk to the beach, is private, and has a very lovely deck. Drinking coffee and reading the paper on the deck was completely dreamy. Alexandre also let us stay way past the check out time which allowed us to have extra time at the beach- very accommodating host!

I had a fabulous stay on Cherry Grove . The location is perfect to enjoy the beach, the fun -relaxed -buzz if you decide to walk to the shops and restaurants animated area .But you can also peacefully enjoy the quiteness, the sounds of nature and relax at Alexandre's place. The studio is really cute, convenient and confy. I loved having breakfast on the outside patio. Thanks so much for your hospitality and great conversations. Hope to catch up soon. Florence