Skip to content

Food and restaurants in City Island

Top restaurants

Diner
“Best Seafood in NYC City Island is renowned for its amazing water views and great seafood right here in The Bronx. Some local favorites are Tony's Pier, Johnny's Reef, The Original Crab Shanty and City Island Lobster House. This is a must for any seafood lover.”
  • 36 locals recommend
American Restaurant
“A frequent recommendation of local American-Style cuisine in a unique atmosphere decorated by Nautical pieces and treasured antiques. Great place for dinner or Sunday brunch. The also have a lovely back porch dining area for warm weather days.”
  • 9 locals recommend
Italian Restaurant
“Wide variety of seafood and Italian dishes. They also have a nice bar if you want to just grab a drink and small bite.”
  • 3 locals recommend
Bar
“A classic City Island seafood join. Large portions and lots of fried seafood.”
  • 5 locals recommend
Bar
“Picture tells a thousand words, here you go. City Island, 20 minutes drive.”
  • 7 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
“One of the classic seafood restaurants. Awesome free bread and cheese plate, a meal in it's self. Also have a nice bar, a great place to grab a happy hour drink. During the summer months enjoy the outdoor, water front bar.”
  • 7 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Our local City Island dinner is just down the hill from the City Island Nautical Museum. a cozy spot to rub elbows with the local "Clam-diggers" and "Mussel-Shuckers" while enjoying classic dinner coffee, breakfast or a lunch of fish and chips. Not 24 Hrs Open everyday 7am to 8pm”
  • 5 locals recommend
Diner
“Sea food lovers. Lots of famous seafood restaurants. The food is like you've never seen before, big portion . A seafood platter for two is enough for 8 so pay attention to that. ”
  • 1 local recommends

Cafes

Café
“Hip and trendy intergenerational coffee shop with free WiFi, good coffee and food. ”
  • 3 locals recommend
Music Venue
  • 1 local recommends
Bakery
“They have Wi-Fi, you can sit there as long as you want, and you can meet friendly people from the City Island community there. To eat I recommend the $1 multigrain bagel heated with nothing on it.”
  • 2 locals recommend

Bakeries

Bakery
“They have Wi-Fi, you can sit there as long as you want, and you can meet friendly people from the City Island community there. To eat I recommend the $1 multigrain bagel heated with nothing on it.”
  • 2 locals recommend